03-07-2013, 10:55 AM
John Doe Wrote:Man, Ashe, if I'm right about you and you really are the doctor, and this game doesn't end immediately after lynching Teemer, I want you to put all your protectingness powers to good use on me.!
Ashe Wrote:I think Teemer is the most likely mafia candidate and I think that Doe is also a mafia (at this point in time) and lying about their powers. *Dehan's power doesn't make sense for a mafia*, **Kayne has been validated by Mal**, and I know I'm not
Ashe Wrote:On the other hand, I think Doe is being untruthful about both. I think the way we test this is to all vote for Teemer, and dare Doe to do exactly as he has threatened to do since he first revealed his power (stating he'll lynch anyone that doesn't reveal, and now making the threat again - despite not doing such). Yeah, he could have just held off for whatever reason, but I call it an empty threat. I don't think he has that power.Yeah, Doe. I'll totally protect you tonight, mang.
1. Teemer
2. Doe
3. Dehan
4. Ashe
5. Kayne
Yeah, negative. I'm certain that Teemer is mafia, and I'm certain that you are mafia. I'm protecting myself tonight, again, like I've been doing every night since you lead the charge and got the Sheriff lynched. You are lying about your power. If you weren't, the mafia would have killed you by now and made sure that you didn't get a chance to use your power to kill one of them. The only other option is that you are mafia (which invalidates your ability). I haven't protected you, and yet you are alive. Dehan is not likely mafia with his ability, and Kayne is the only person absolutely guaranteed not to be a mafia member. Thus, whichever of the two of you (Dehan or Doe) survive tonight is mafia by default. Not wasting my vote on Kayne tomorrow, for the same reason as the Sheriff. I'm not letting you convince me to lynch another certain town person.
If I protect you, the town loses 100% because you kill me during the night and then follow during the day but convincing Dehan or Kayne to kill the other. Pretty sure with Dehan already suspicious of you, they will vote kill you anyway if they play this right. Rather just protect myself to ensure this goes down correctly.
Also, videovideovideovideovideovideo

