[LoM] Aftermath

[Jonathan Meer]

You could have made a better argument then what you did. And I can give you a few examples if you would really like me to...

Sure. Let's hear them.

Note: Thinking about it... Meer.. Maybe you tried to hard to not be obvious... lol

Since you're the only one that's given any indication that you were suspicious of me as being potentially mafia (and others have indicated that, actually, I was rather unsuspicious), and since you've still been unable to articulate any real reason why you thought I was suspicious, I'm still chalking your selection up to blind, dumb luck, and won't be taking your suggestions for an edit to my play-style or decisions at all seriously.

[Jonathan Meer]

All it takes is to see enough of the picture that you start to see what other clues could mean. Kaden was all for lynching someone until it came 'round to Meer, then he became more hesitant to do. Given that he was the most likely to be ghosted, it was too easy to figure out.

lolwut? I don't recall Kaden ever saying 'Let's not lynch Meer.' I certainly don't recall that happening after he was ghosted. He's a better player than that.

[Super Buu]

He never said to not lynch you, as he pointed out to me himself; but he didn't go to lynch you either, whereas he'd jumped on a few others. Alone, it meant nothing, but it's just another one of those little pointers.

[Jonathan Meer]

He never said to not lynch you, as he pointed out to me himself; but he didn't go to lynch you either, whereas he'd jumped on a few others. Alone, it meant nothing, but it's just another one of those little pointers.

Ah. So 'too easy to figure out' was an overstatement, I take it?

[Mal Nova]

Lol...

Meer, my friend... You are taking things to damned seriously. I gave you my main reason for suspecting you from the beginning... You just can't take it it seems. Your first post made you suspicious!

This is my first time playing... after watching a little of the last game. I could have done more of an evaluation like Jarka was doing... But I was gonna just have fun and do my thing...

I kinda hinted to who I was on the day Doe died anyway... Was fun though... The past few days he had mentioned TF... Argued with Leo or Raf about it on a sheriff role.. and I wanted to shout it's me! lol...

Kaden handled Josh, and Rose got Kami... that meant 3 were left and Doe was dead...

Doe preaches about being active in the game... He died... So at least one mafia was kinda quiet... It was actually 2...

An example for your thing would have been... That their ablilty was already revealed and that even though they lost their abilities, that they were immune from mafia's attacks so long as you are still alive... or dead...

I have a few more but yeah...

[Jonathan Meer]

Lol...

Meer, my friend... You are taking things to damned seriously. I gave you my main reason for suspecting you from the beginning... You just can't take it it seems. Your first post made you suspicious!

*shrug* You're the only one, apparently, who thought so. Funny that your suspicion never culminated in a lynch-vote, or in a check via your power until Day Four. I don't buy it, tbh.

An example for your thing would have been... That their ablilty was already revealed and that even though they lost their abilities, that they were immune from mafia's attacks so long as you are still alive... or dead...

I have a few more but yeah...

...Huh?

[Ashe]

As stated before, I will have a more comprehensive list of abilities, roles, players, etc as well as hopefully giving insight on some of the events that happened. I will mention things that I felt from my perspective as well as try to find out some information regarding specific things from others. I'm also going to consider my options regarding changes after I ask about those (So I don't need to read tons of suggestions out of order from when I ask about it, for the sake of organization).

That said, I've got to run out the door at the moment. I've got a busy time ahead of me, and I won't be able to run the immediate next mafia game nor participate, and possibly the one after that, depending on scheduling. I'm very happy with how the game turned out, overall (and with some reservations), and absolutely appreciate the responses. I do hope to do another like this (with some changes both for shaking things up and from learning) when able. This was a blast to run.

[Kaden]

@Meer: Rose is talking about page 6 of Day 4. At that point, to be perfectly honest, I had given up. That Mal pulled the right investigation on the right day just blew my mind. I would have just sat on my Waffuru lynch vote, but he sent me a text saying he would blow me up. Hence the "wtf I don't want to die." I started making up shit about using Bloodscent. It was pretty obvious I was trying to not vote.

EDIT: Next game, if there are people who aren't posting in the actual game, I'm going to be gunning for them non-stop. That's just dumb.

[Mal Nova]

*shrug* You're the only one, apparently, who thought so. Funny that your suspicion never culminated in a lynch-vote, or in a check via your power until Day Four. I don't buy it, tbh.

Ironies and coincidence... How often must I say this... It's funny that what... 3 people of the last game were mafia this time?

Ive only watched the last game before LoM...

Let me say that, once again, your fist post said basically you weren't gonna talk cuz it leads you to getting accused...

BAM!

On the suspect list...

And whenI say suspect list I meant for Destiny...

After seeing Does power and realizing I couldn't see an alignment.. I had to wonder...

Whompt was second on my list... and you were third...

Had Tmer not used Amumu...you would have been solid and might have won... But you didn't.

You may have been at the back of my list... but that first comment...

It's not my damned fault that everyone else dismissed it... Had I had missed I might not have selected to look at you...

If you would like for me to call everyone that missed it, some word of blind or ignorant, I could. But it wasn't their job to decide who to pick.

Call it dumb luck if you want... and be piss poor about it. But yeah...

I Found it funny and ironic...


Edit:I had fun bitch about the assholes getting rid of Doe =(

[Jonathan Meer]

@Meer: Rose is talking about page 6 of Day 4. At that point, to be perfectly honest, I had given up. That Mal pulled the right investigation on the right day just blew my mind. I would have just sat on my Waffuru lynch vote, but he sent me a text saying he would blow me up. Hence the "wtf I don't want to die." I started making up shit about using Bloodscent. It was pretty obvious I was trying to not vote.

Oh. Well sure, but by that point, I was pretty much dead. I think it's a bit silly to say I was too easy to figure out, after the Sheriff essentially reveals himself, said he investigated me, and revealed that I had a clearly Mafia-esque power.

But that's how Mafia's gone game after game after game. Townspeople consistently get the right thing on the right day, over and over again. I can only think of two games out of eight (nine?) that were at all close, and one of those (where I was the last Mafia member) was tilted heavily toward townspeople after the first two days.

Ironies and coincidence... How often must I say this... It's funny that what... 3 people of the last game were mafia this time?

Ive only watched the last game before LoM...

*snip*

Heh. Clearly your brain works in a very different way than the others. If that's what you took to be mega-suspicious, then I'm comfortable with that.

That said, that's exactly what I would have posted were I a townsperson. In fact (I don't exactly recall), I may have made that post before I even checked my role.

[Kole T. Merr]

There we go. New rule for next game. Nobody gets to look at their role until day 2.

[Jonathan Meer]

It's certainly a good idea for Mafia, especially if they're the sort of person to prematurely tip their hand.

[Mal Nova]

Ironies... and coincidences..


Ask Ashe... I sent him a message finding it funny I got the Twisted Fate role... Retane being the start of my upcoming with his cards in '07... and the Ultimate bravery (I clicked it and it gave me Twisted fate too lol) You felt odd and I was new and you just felt right...

It was in my beer belly! =D

[Jonathan Meer]

You're more than welcome to follow beer-belly feelings anytime I'm Mafia =D

[Mal Nova]

And I actually debated on revealing my role when I found Mordy...

I initially opted to act stupid...

But as I thought about it.... I had a chance to take out a third out of ...4-5 of them and I decided I better go ahead and do it.

Guess what though? After you were gone I had a 4th! With no damned condom though... Sigred raped me lol...

You guys stuck out for me... and it was my ability to hunt you guys down....


and for the record.. I had some Super high scenarios....

[Jarka]

There we go. New rule for next game. Nobody gets to look at their role until day 2.

We could play quantum mafia! I've always wanted to do so.

[John Doe]

We already played that. Like half of the last game was inactive (yuk yuk yuk).

Since Ashe says he's busy, I wouldn't mind hosting the next game (unless somebody else feels like stepping up).

Oh gawd themes I just thought of one...

[Mal Nova]

I'd run one... With someone's help I think I can run one like Ashe did... with my own twists... If you guys would like?

[Kaden]

Since there are multiple people who want to host one, we'll do it this way.

Whoever makes the first sign-up thread after 12:00 am PST tonight will host.

[John Doe]

That's like, 3 am for me.

Sneaky devils.