Super Mafia Bros. 2 After Party

[Blue]

With a laugh and a shrug, Peach put the noose around her own neck. She had tried her best, but it was clear now that neither Wart nor Mario would be dissuaded from their decision. Moments later and the deed was done. Peach was dead, and the evidence of her affiliation was found on her.

Suddenly, the two came to a realization. Not only were they the only people still alive, but they had killed off all the women. So, with a laugh and a shrug, the two clasped hands and walked off into the sunset, eager for the man-love to follow.

Mario - Ashe

Townie

Ability: Dr. Mario
-You can target a single player to protect per Night Phase. Activated Night Phase Ability.



Luigi - Rafael

Townie

Ability: Green Shell
- You can target a single player per night phase to eliminate. Activated Night Phase Ability.



Toad - Dehan

Townie

Ability: 1-Up
-If an ability, lynch vote, or Mafia execution would result in your death, you don't die. At this time, your identity will become known, but not your allegiance. One Time Use Ability.


Peach - Teemer

Mafia

Ability: Body Guards
-Once in the game, you may PM me that you want protection. Until the end of that phase, you are immune to all abilities to remove you from the game. You must PM me prior to the end of the Phase for this ability to work. Activated One Time Use Ability.



Shy Guy - Mal Nova

Townie

Ability: Easily Overlooked
- Once a night, you may investigate a person of your choice, revealing their allegiance (T or M). Activated Night Phase Ability.



Birdo - Kayne

Mafia

Ability: Resemblance
-When investigated, you come up as a Townie. Passive Ability.



Mouser - King B

Townie

Ability: They all look the same to me.
-You can vote twice during the Day Phase. One via the thread and the second vote will be PMd to me. Activated Day Phase Ability.



Wart - John Doe

Townie

Ability: Froggy King
-Once in the entire game, you have the ability to lynch a person of your choice instead of the choice of the group. You must PM your decision to me prior to the end of the Day Phase and it doesn't take effect until the Day Phase has ended. Activated One Time Use Day Phase Ability.



Pokey - Kaden

Townie

Ability: Prickly
-When targetted by the Mafia for a kill, but not any other ability to kill a player, you take one of them down with you. Passive Ability.


Not gonna explain anything this time, but there's the stuff for everyone. To be honest, I'm shocked the town won. Once everyone was on the "Kayne must be innocent" boat, and no one voiced any suspicions of Teemer, I assumed ya'll were fucked. But, if I had to give a reason for the win, it would have to be everyone telling everyone their power. Once ya'll started with that, the tide really started turning against the Mafia.

Though, I was still shocked when Doe sent me his nearly last minute ability use to use on Kayne. Even after 90% of the Townies having their abilities confirmed.

[Jonathan Meer]

This game is a perfect example of why I don't like making the Sheriff's power unreliable.

EDIT: Also lol at vigilantes shooting their load off on night one with zero information

[Kayne]

It was fun as shit. I am surprised too that I lasted so long. I am a horrible liar. Doe used his one time use on me, so kind of flattered about that. I guess. Good game.

[Kole T. Merr]

Jesus...that was a crazy game...

[Kaden]

As I pointed out to him on Steam, Teemer actually could have won. He misread his power.

And am I seeing right that Luigi could use his power more than once?

[Kole T. Merr]

Thank God we took him out early...

[Mal Nova]

Of course I wind up investigating a mafia member on Night 1.

NIGHT 1!!!!

MAFIA!!!

Fuck Sheriff powers. I'm trusting my gut from now on. And for the record... Teemer acted TOO MUCH like a friggin Town member. And who lets the douche bag that killed the Sheriff with the final blow live?

[Dehan]

Loved this game. I wonder how a Naruto version would work.

[Kayne]

Absolute best moment:

Kayne it's still black history month. The fuck bro?

and

[Kole T. Merr]

Too much like a town member?

[Mal Nova]

Correct. TOO MUCH. AKA: Tried to much to look like one.

[King B]

Of course I wind up investigating a mafia member on Night 1.

NIGHT 1!!!!

MAFIA!!!

Fuck Sheriff powers. I'm trusting my gut from now on. And for the record... Teemer acted TOO MUCH like a friggin Town member. And who lets the douche bag that killed the Sheriff with the final blow live?

Lol, right?

What are the fucking chances, for real!

Awesome game though, but we need to bring back quirks!

[John Doe]

I managed to get Mal killed and win the game. Both objectives complete. Achievement unlocked. Title granted: Mafia King.

[Blue]

Teemer did read his power wrong, but he never asked about it, so I let him roll with it. He did use it the phase where you guys all voted for him, though, so it wouldn't have changed matters. I doubt he woulda changed his mind when it seemed he was gonna go.

And yes. Luigi coulda been killing people the whole game, had he survived.

I'm surprised no one killed Doe merely for the fact that he had a hand in nearly every Town death in the game. I don't know if he actually knew Kayne and Teemer were Mafia and was just trolling you, or making wild guesses, but in the end Doe did win it for you guys.

[John Doe]

Can't I just be not stupid? :\

Mal's death was mostly spurn on by my hatred of him, but it did manage to give me information on who to suspect and who not to. Mainly, Kayne and Ashe respectively. Even before she bullshit about her powers, I thought it was odd that you would lynch the guy who had just cleared you. Teemer and Dehan fell to secondary suspicion status since they also killed Mal. It wasn't until the power reveals that I was sure of Teemer's mafianess.

Day 3 I mixed truth and lies to try and eventually get everyone to reveal their powers. Ashe surprised me with his reveal that he was the doctor, though after that almost everything went exactly as I had planned. I would have force lynched Kayne on Day 3 if Dehan didn't say he was toad and had 2 lives. Even if he was lying or telling the truth, town would end up ahead. In addition, King B's demonstration of his powers almost guaranteed that I wouldn't be targeted that night, so I had another free day to trololo.

I should say that, while everything went as planned, I was pretty scared that I could be wrong when I sent in my power to Blue. I was so sure I had played everyone, but what if Ashe really wasn't the doctor? The biggest scare factor was Kaden's death early on. His power was never revealed, so it was possible a mafia could lie about their power if Kaden's happened to match. It's what I thought had happened with Mal, and what I feared would happen with Ashe. But it turns out I was right so GG me.

There is one thing that I don't like about themed games where the players become known, iconic characters. By having X character you are limited to a certain amount of abilities which would fit that character, such as a transgender/godfather Birdo or Doctor Mario. Having abilities that match your character kinda subtracts from pure investigative deductive reasoning. I know I've hosted themed games before, but I kinda regret it.

Although, if I were to host a themed game, Naruto wouldn't be a bad choice. They're all ninjas, so I'm sure it wouldn't really matter who got what ability. Probably...

[Kayne]

I rolled through it. I didn't calculate much of anything. I didn't even think about the fact that he cleared me and I lynched him anyways. Also, I would have picked you off instead of King B the other night, but I figured killing you off would have been too obvious as I was laying stake in the fact that you may have been a suspect for mafia. I wanted to leave that little bit of doubt open. And also, I really thought you were bullshitting your power. It seemed a little too OP.

I am also never going to reveal my power in future games, either. If it gets me picked off early, so be it, but I think it's bullshit to trick people into doing that. It's probably not an illegal move by any means, but it just opens up way too much. Forcing people to reveal what they have or risk being the next one lynched is being a bully.

[John Doe]

I both regret nothing and would do the same thing again a hundred times over.

[Kayne]

lol

[Jonathan Meer]

I think it's pretty clear that John Doe played that game extremely well.

Kanye, you weren't 'tricked' into giving anything away. You gave it away freely.

[Blue]

It's true. I didn't think he even knew what he was doing half the time, aside from trolling. When you can fool the guy in charge, you're doing it right.

Course, now Doe might wanna stay outta the next one. I can't imagine the Town wanting him as a possible Mafioso or the Mafia wanting him around either.