The following warnings occurred:
Warning [2] Undefined property: MyLanguage::$archive_pages - Line: 2 - File: printthread.php(287) : eval()'d code PHP 8.5.13 (Linux)
File Line Function
/inc/class_error.php 153 errorHandler->error
/printthread.php(287) : eval()'d code 2 errorHandler->error_callback
/printthread.php 287 eval
/printthread.php 117 printthread_multipage



CDBZ Archive
Pebble Logic? - Printable Version

+- CDBZ Archive (http://alex.zulenka.com)
+-- Forum: Administrative Forums (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+--- Forum: Questions and Suggestions (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=124)
+--- Thread: Pebble Logic? (/showthread.php?tid=10074)

Pages: 1 2


Pebble Logic? - Super Buu - 12-28-2006

I still don't see where I'm exaggerating anything or taking 'extreme' examples to use. They all use the same formula.

I just want to know is the question that I asked at the beginning of the thread. Is. This. All. Correct. ?

It's just that if so, I'll have to take it into account with calculating the probability of winning future fights and how to roleplay things IC. That's all I want to know. Is the current Body Split formula a fair representation of how fights on Chubbs work (roleplaying ability aside)?


Pebble Logic? - Super Buu - 12-28-2006

I'm going to elaborate on my examples, since people are apparently having difficulty understanding the maths behind it.

Body Split as it is now is supposed to split a power's fighter by effect, not by pure ki. From this, I can derive that, on Chubbs, a fighter is equal to two fighters 80% of his own power. Or three fighters 70% of his own power. Etc.

My question has two possible answers, each with its own repercussions.

1) The 'battle effectiveness' examples are correct. Thus, Body Split as it currently is is fair.

2) The examples are unfair. Thus, Body Split is unfair and the added power should either be weakened or removed.

I've recieved examples of both responses whilst in this thread, and I'd like from from an admin to see a definitive answer. It's a one word response, yes or no. 1) or 2). I don't see how it's gotten to page 2, but hopefully the above should make things clear.


Pebble Logic? - Vegeta Jr - 12-28-2006

Don't hold my word to it, but it's pretty much approximately like this:

20% ki difference doesn't matter much.

30% ki difference you need more guys.

40% ki difference is near impossible.

This doesn't include extra variables like Roleplaying Quality, extraordinary circumstances, unused powerups, etc.


Pebble Logic? - Vegeta - 12-28-2006

Body Split is not the basis for how fights work. I have no idea why you think that makes sense.

Body Split is a powerup, so the split fighters are NOT equal to the original. That's where your math is wrong.


Pebble Logic? - Kaden - 12-28-2006

Totally not in the mood to deal with this, SB.


Pebble Logic? - Super Buu - 12-28-2006

Quote:Originally posted by Waffuru
Body Split is not the basis for how fights work. I have no idea why you think that makes sense.

Body Split is a powerup, so the split fighters are NOT equal to the original. That's where your math is wrong.
Thank you. That makes a little more sense, even though I disagree with Body Split being a powerup (I think that, as I said before, it doesn't take into account the advantages of coming from more sides, giving them less time to think and the like, and the situational/strategical advantages of being able to order around extra corporeal bodies).

I'll give you guys a break until I return to the topic, seeing's though you have a lot of other things to deal with.


Pebble Logic? - Vegeta Jr - 12-28-2006

Quote:Originally posted by Super Buu
I'm going to elaborate on my examples, since people are apparently having difficulty understanding the maths behind it.

Body Split as it is now is supposed to split a power's fighter by effect, not by pure ki. From this, I can derive that, on Chubbs, a fighter is equal to two fighters 80% of his own power. Or three fighters 70% of his own power. Etc.

My question has two possible answers, each with its own repercussions.

1) The 'battle effectiveness' examples are correct. Thus, Body Split as it currently is is fair.

2) The examples are unfair. Thus, Body Split is unfair and the added power should either be weakened or removed.

I've recieved examples of both responses whilst in this thread, and I'd like from from an admin to see a definitive answer. It's a one word response, yes or no. 1) or 2). I don't see how it's gotten to page 2, but hopefully the above should make things clear.

To make two things clear about yoru analogy(sp?):

1) Body Split is a specialised Technique, not a powerup.

2) A chicken is an animal but not each animal is a chicken.

I can see how you were thinking, but the logic doesn't work the other way around. The rules of Body split does not equal the logistics of the chubbs dbz universe of multiple people with different strengths fighting each other.

Oh, and *points up to my last post again.* That's pretty much my opinion, but as it says its not written in stone as there are a lot of other variables involved in a fight.

VJ


Pebble Logic? - Super Buu - 12-28-2006

Just for the record, VJ, I agree that Body Split should be a specialised technique and not a powerup. However, as has been explained by staffers, it was made into (and currently is) a powerup, because apparently it was useless before and nobody wanted it. I'm actually arguing against this, not for it. =P


Pebble Logic? - Ashe - 12-29-2006

SB, I haven't had a chance to read through any of this, so I hope I'm not missing anything. I apologize for not having the chance to address your concerns, but given the current situation, I'm trying to regain my bearings.


Pebble Logic? - Kaden - 12-29-2006

Quote:Originally posted by Reijin
SB, I haven't had a chance to read through any of this, so I hope I'm not missing anything. I apologize for not having the chance to address your concerns, but given the current situation, I'm trying to regain my bearings.

=(

If you get this argument started up again I'm going to cut you.


Pebble Logic? - Ashe - 12-29-2006

meh, I've already been told today to go cut myself.

Besides, I have no clue what this is about, any details on it, or anything. Hehe.