+- CDBZ Archive (http://alex.zulenka.com)
+-- Forum: Forum Games (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=274)
+--- Forum: Chubbs Mafia (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=27)
+--- Thread: Mafia - Debrief (/showthread.php?tid=16432)
Mafia - Debrief - Celena - 03-07-2011
Rose, did you at any point think I was Mafia or were you just breaking my balls the whole time?
Mafia - Debrief - Kaden - 03-07-2011
This is almost as entertaining as the actual game was.
Mafia - Debrief - Jonathan Meer - 03-07-2011
Kaden Wrote:This is almost as entertaining as the actual game was.
If this was on fb, I would 'Like' this.
Mafia - Debrief - Super Buu - 03-07-2011
Celena Wrote:Rose, did you at any point think I was Mafia or were you just breaking my balls the whole time?
At the very beginning I decided for my own shits and giggles to do the SUSPICIONS RATING LIST, and arbitrarily pick a single person to continually accuse regardless of where my other suspicions went. Your reactions did actually arouse my suspicion a bit, but for the most part I was just being a dick.
Mafia - Debrief - Rafael - 03-08-2011
Anyone here play Starcraft Phantom Mode? I play the shit out of that and it's basically the RTS version of Mafia. However, that apparently translates 0% into this because I have no idea how people reached any of the conclusions they did. Only person I ever figured out was Leo, but as far as figuring out who the Mafia are I'd be useless.
Mafia - Debrief - Jonathan Meer - 03-08-2011
Mafia...RTS?
Mafia - Debrief - Rafael - 03-08-2011
I love it, and I'm pretty accurate most games, which is why this baffled so much.
http://www.sc2phantom.com/
Mafia - Debrief - Piper Juunanagou - 03-08-2011
That was fun, even if I lost interest a day in XD
I'm satisfied that I killed Leo. It pleased me so.
Mafia - Debrief - Jarka - 03-08-2011
I definitely think that for the next game, have one stickied thread of explicit rules, including specific rules for each of the roles. Just to clarify things for people, yeah?
Mafia - Debrief - Jonathan Meer - 03-08-2011
But that's so much wooooooork
k
Mafia - Debrief - Jarka - 03-08-2011
jonathan meer Wrote:but that's so much wooooooork
k
Submit to my demands, Meer! Mwahahaha!
Mafia - Debrief - Tyr - 03-08-2011
You shot the sheriff, but you did not shoot the deputy.. or.. something...
I thought I died for inactivity? Was I double whacked? I didn't get to post on my last phase.
Hate the fact I finally scooped on a mafia and died though, I had a grand reveal prepared but then I had to go sleep. : (
Mafia - Debrief - Sigfried Hunin - 03-08-2011
wtf does the sheriff even do?
Mafia - Debrief - Super Buu - 03-08-2011
Jarka Wrote:I definitely think that for the next game, have one stickied thread of explicit rules, including specific rules for each of the roles. Just to clarify things for people, yeah?This is mafia, not super league poker chess ... fire emblem? People what want clarification can get they ass to wikipedia.
Mafia - Debrief - Tyr - 03-08-2011
Sigfried Hunin Wrote:wtf does the sheriff even do?I find the mafia, each night phase I also got a PM and I could check on people. Should have checked JD on the first night but on the other hand, if I had gone around saying "I definitely know he's mafia cuz I the sheriff" I would have got a cap in my ass.
Mafia - Debrief - Blue - 03-08-2011
Leo Wrote:I find the mafia, each night phase I also got a PM and I could check on people. Should have checked JD on the first night but on the other hand, if I had gone around saying "I definitely know he's mafia cuz I the sheriff" I would have got a cap in my ass.
That's why I kept my mouth shut til the last day and it hit crunch time.
Mafia - Debrief - Jarka - 03-08-2011
Rose Wrote:This is mafia, not super league poker chess ... fire emblem? People what want clarification can get they ass to wikipedia.
But there's so many variant rules! Every time I've played, things have been a little bit different. *begins sobbing hysterically* IT WAS JUST TOO MUCH TO TAKE IN.
Also, Meer said there was going to be extra roles. Those would need specification as the bonus roles often do wildly different things depending on the group.
Mafia - Debrief - Jonathan Meer - 03-08-2011
The only people who need to know about the special roles are those with the special roles.
Mafia is a game of information. Part of that game involves lacking information. The Mafia, as a rule, have more information than the townspeople, but even they don't have ALL the information.
But yes. There are repositories all over the interwebs for the typical roles.
Here's a well-developed one: http://wiki.epicmafia.com/index.php?title=Main_Page
Basically, don't make any assumptions for the upcoming game. There will be special roles. There will probably be mechanics you haven't seen before. The game WILL be balanced, but it will be a game of somewhat more chaos. Both the Mafia and the Townspeople will, as a whole, have greater and more diverse (and hidden) powers.
THAT SAID, if we get a dedicated sub-forum for these games (if they really take off), I don't have a problem with constructing a sticky to solidify some of our rules.
Mafia - Debrief - Super Buu - 03-08-2011
Jonathan Meer Wrote:Basically, don't make any assumptions for the upcoming game. There will be special roles. There will probably be mechanics you haven't seen before. The game WILL be balanced, but it will be a game of somewhat more chaos. Both the Mafia and the Townspeople will, as a whole, have greater and more diverse (and hidden) powers
I think I speak for everyone when I say 'sweet'.
Mafia - Debrief - Waffuru - 03-08-2011
You fuckers killed me for nothing.