+- CDBZ Archive (http://alex.zulenka.com)
+-- Forum: Forum Games (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=274)
+--- Forum: Chubbs Mafia (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=27)
+--- Thread: Ye Olde Mafia - Day Two (/showthread.php?tid=17578)
Ye Olde Mafia - Day Two - Ashe - 02-28-2012
Not entirely following your slot method, but here's how I'm reading it.
Basically, you feel the top three on this list are the most likely to be mafia but its in top down order of your suspicions.
1. Kaden
2. John Doe
3. Ashe
4. Sophia
5. 17
6. Tyr
7. Keiko
*I'm branching off these next two as you seem to be saying that you more or less trust them. I'm going to list you as 10, if I interpret you to say that 8, 9, and 10 are who you find most likely to be town.
8. Anzekay
9. King B
10. Mal Nova
Then you are just pointing out that Kaden, Tyr, and Keiko were all mafia most recently.
Would this be a fair interpretation? If so, what about myself (followed by Sophia) screams "MAFIA" to you? What actions of mine or Sophia's are odd?
I ask because, naturally, you listed me as your third choice for a mafia member, and since I'm not (though we'd all say that), I'd like to go ahead and have an opportunity to address said concern. I do follow your suspicion with Doe, and while I don't really suspect Kaden, I can understand why others would. Continuing to Sophia, I haven't really seen anyone put anything down about his actions, so I wouldn't mind hearing that as well.
Anyone below this seems to more or less be non-suspect to you, from what I can tell.
Ye Olde Mafia - Day Two - Ashe - 02-28-2012
Also, just in case, I should put my lynch vote. At this point, I feel no choice but to say Lynch Doe. I don't particularly want to, but I don't like that he's just insisting on us lynching blindly and begging for Doctor support. Its possible that he could be the Sheriff by that, but I doubt it. I hate lynching a possible townie, but we shouldn't stay idle for too long either.
He could easily persuade me to take that vote back by explaining ANY reasoning, but right now he seems too interested in just killing anyone, without caring if its a townie or a mafia. He just wants blood and his actions are screaming either mafia or some kind of anarchist that gives no fucks. I'm more inclined to take Kaden at his word of being an ordinary towns person at the moment, but that can easily change too. I second the notion of someone investigating him to clear that up, but we'll probably never know for sure.
Ye Olde Mafia - Day Two - Mal Nova - 02-28-2012
No. Each Slot in my thoguhts has a single potential mafia member...
That means Kaden/Doe/Me
Ashe/Sophia/17
Tye/Keiko
Anz/KingB
Originally it was...
Kaden/Doe/Me
Ashe/Sophia/Waffles
Tye/Keiko/17
Anz/KingB
And Bonus chances are that 1 is a repeater...Kaden/Tyr/Keiko
It's hard to get a reading on someone on how they play if they don't put forth much(suspicious) but easier to try to discern what someone gets at even if they try to trick you...
Remember in Game 1..I pretty much picked them out the bush like picking cherries. I had assumptions on the last game just by some typings and gut feelings. And they all came through correct.
My thoughts/assumptions are Merely some of the things that run through my head(am I overthinking somethings? Sure... but I realize this) At the same time, someones going to slip up... it's why edditting is suppose to be prohibited.
We all know 6 people are gonna fly under the radar to the best of their ability and we know a few that can do so easily.
Sheriff wont bark unless he at least got one. I havent played a game where he really did it just to save a neck.... Aside Kaden's WW and Doe's Olaf... Confessing gets you a kill maybe... and a chance to be protected for another hunt... Unless he really needs to.. and then its just another day he has bought lol
Ye Olde Mafia - Day Two - Kaden - 02-28-2012
Tyr, Soph, and King are my picks for mafia with Ashe as an alternate.
Based on Day 1 voting and nothing else.
Android 17 Wrote:Didn't you say the same thing in the previous mafia game? You know, before you killed everyone?
I said I was Caitlyn and had the ability to reveal someone's champion given certain circumstances, all of which was completely true.
Quote:And FOR ALL intents and Purposes... I'd OVERestimatedly put myself with the tier of Kaden and Doe =P
I don't know what tier puts me on the same level as John Doe, but that makes me sad.
Ye Olde Mafia - Day Two - Mal Nova - 02-28-2012
I DO have a question! I thought I asked... How do we know the diference between a Viglante Kill and a mafia kill? Or do we?
Ye Olde Mafia - Day Two - Kaden - 02-28-2012
Stop asking the GM to reveal a bunch of information. The whole point of the game is using the information we have.
Rose. Don't answer that question. We'll find out when two people die on the same night.
Ye Olde Mafia - Day Two - Mal Nova - 02-28-2012
@ Kaden... You still got your own tier... But you are a very active and wondered and high suspected person..... Just Like the Doe.
Ye Olde Mafia - Day Two - Mal Nova - 02-28-2012
I wasn't asking him..I was asking you guys! i have never played a regular mafia. Do we know any difference from batman and joker?
Ye Olde Mafia - Day Two - Kaden - 02-28-2012
It depends on how the GM wants to do it. See it both ways.
Ye Olde Mafia - Day Two - Kaden - 02-28-2012
Unlynch
Lynch Keiko
Based purely on post count. I'd rather play a game with active people than people who just kind of sit back. They both have 2 posts total for the game.
Ye Olde Mafia - Day Two - Mal Nova - 02-28-2012
So... We dont know who killed who last night? =/
Anyways...for records
Need 6 to lynch
Doe(4): Kaden, Nova, Sophia, Ashe
Kaden(1): Doe
Ye Olde Mafia - Day Two - Mal Nova - 02-28-2012
Doe(3): Nova, Sophia, Ashe
Kaden(1): Doe
Keiko(1): Kaden
Ye Olde Mafia - Day Two - Mal Nova - 02-28-2012
Shut up ! I was not editing shit!
Ye Olde Mafia - Day Two - Mal Nova - 02-28-2012
They both?
Ye Olde Mafia - Day Two - Ashe - 02-28-2012
Rose! I demand you tell us who all the mafia are right now! (And then he goes "Ashe, Mal Nova, and Kaden" just to be a dick).
Ye Olde Mafia - Day Two - Tyr - 02-28-2012
I don't know about you fellas, but that looks like an outright confession to me.
Maybe them all three mafia and they just talking to confuse us townies to not do anythin', slowly pickin' us off one by one till we all dead.
Ye Olde Mafia - Day Two - Mal Nova - 02-28-2012
We haz been hadz!
Ye Olde Mafia - Day Two - Super Buu - 02-28-2012
12 hours left of Day 2.
Ye Olde Mafia - Day Two - Mal Nova - 02-28-2012
Oh shit! he spoke some more!
Ye Olde Mafia - Day Two - Mal Nova - 02-28-2012
Rose you cutting us 30 minutes short fucker!