The following warnings occurred:
Warning [2] Undefined property: MyLanguage::$archive_pages - Line: 2 - File: printthread.php(287) : eval()'d code PHP 8.5.13 (Linux)
File Line Function
/inc/class_error.php 153 errorHandler->error
/printthread.php(287) : eval()'d code 2 errorHandler->error_callback
/printthread.php 287 eval
/printthread.php 117 printthread_multipage



CDBZ Archive
Impact Class of 06' - Printable Version

+- CDBZ Archive (http://alex.zulenka.com)
+-- Forum: Out of Character Forums (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=8)
+--- Forum: RPG Discussion (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=125)
+--- Thread: Impact Class of 06' (/showthread.php?tid=10710)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8


Impact Class of 06' - Drake - 03-02-2007

Class of 00' is where it was at, all you posers loose.


Impact Class of 06' - Belle Hibiki - 03-02-2007

Quote:Originally posted by Aqua
Though, I'd point out that those who were of the 2006 class that were still here when the award voting took place, mostly, had only been here for a few months tops. That's hardly enough time to develop a storyline that would "awe"people.

I don't think this is true, TBH. Veni Vidi Vici (the winner of Personal RP) was started a little over a month after I joined (after participating in The Red Stallions) and took another month to write. You don't have to be here very long to write something that impresses people - you just have to work hard.


Impact Class of 06' - Jonathan Meer - 03-02-2007

One: The argument that the '06 Class is greater than others because of the sheer number of awards won is absolutely faulty, as is your irrelevant reminder that you were nominated for a number of awards. No one reads enough of anyone else's posts to truly make a good judgment on these things. For example, how many of you consistently follow Reijin's posts? How many of you know his backstory? Very few, I can imagine. I would argue he is without a doubt one of the greatest roleplayers on the site, but he was not even nominated. It doesn't take actual talent to win an awards show. It takes a general level of "fame", for lack of a better word. Thus, is it any coincidence that '06-ers, currently the most populous class simply because they are the most recent class, tended to win? Of course not. As newbies come in, they tend to befriend one another, and clump together. I did this same thing. Then, once they move past the status of "newbie", they maintain those friendships, and are much more likely to follow their posts than others.

Two: Kid Buu is smart. If your vocabulary can't keep up, don't accuse him of using a thesaurus. Expand your mental horizons.

Three: Your claims that the '06 Class is great for their activity is rather silly. All Classes were rather active just a few months after their "graduation" (if that's what we can call December 31). Eventually, however, some of you will stay and become established members of the community, while others will leave. That's how it's worked for every Class thus far.

If nothing else, from what I've seen thus far, the '06 Class is pretty egotistical, if its "representative" is any indication.


Impact Class of 06' - Super Buu - 03-02-2007

It was the 05ers that won, not 06, Krillin. Reprazent. *handflick*
Quote:Originally posted by Krillin
For example, how many of you consistently follow Reijin's posts? How many of you know his backstory? Very few, I can imagine.
Whilst he's a good writer, he doesn't really post outside of sagas. Kinda hard to vote for someone's projects when they dinnae exist. Tongue


Impact Class of 06' - Kaden - 03-02-2007

Quote:Originally posted by Super Buu
Whilst he's a good writer, he doesn't really post outside of sagas. Kinda hard to vote for someone's projects when they dinnae exist. Tongue

Krillin's point still stands, though.


Impact Class of 06' - Super Buu - 03-02-2007

Quote:Originally posted by Raditzu
Quote:Originally posted by Super Buu
Whilst he's a good writer, he doesn't really post outside of sagas. Kinda hard to vote for someone's projects when they dinnae exist. Tongue

Krillin's point still stands, though.
Oh yeah, almost certainly. In a community this small, bias is unavoidable. Just pointing out a problem in the example he used.

The rest of the post is kind of moot, though. What with it being 05 and not 06 that won. I guess it says a lot for your debating skills that you can argue with invisible ammunition, kekeke.


Impact Class of 06' - Anya - 03-02-2007

Quote:Originally posted by Kakarot
Class of 00' is where it was at, all you posers loose.

Amen. I already stated that we fucking kicked ass.


And Sammah? I still talk to Shawn occassionally. Just not very often. And Alex, too.


Impact Class of 06' - Belle Hibiki - 03-02-2007

@ Krillin:

I'll concede the point that the 'awards' didn't mean terribly much. My first post on this thread was largely a joke - a complete overdramatization - so I'm sorry if I came off as very self-absorbed there Tongue

As for referencing my own award... It was mainly to point out that you don't need to be here long to write a good thread (I hope it doesn't sound egotistical when I say I do consider Veni Vidi Vici to be so).


Impact Class of 06' - Jonathan Meer - 03-02-2007

Quote:Originally posted by Super Buu

Oh yeah, almost certainly. In a community this small, bias is unavoidable. Just pointing out a problem in the example he used.

Ok. Reijin doesn't pump out 1000-word mediocre posts thrice a week. That does not at all discredit his work, both in-saga and out of it. You certainly aren't arguing that his non-saga work is non-existent?

Quote:Originally posted by Super Buu

The rest of the post is kind of moot, though. What with it being 05 and not 06 that won. I guess it says a lot for your debating skills that you can argue with invisible ammunition, kekeke.

I was attacking the principle, Super Buu. For that reason, I didn't think it necessary to actually check how many had won from each individual class. 'Invisible ammunition' has nothing to do with it.

Oh, and Kid Buu, no worries. None of that post was directed at you. I jumped in alongside you, not against you. *thumbs up*


Impact Class of 06' - Belle Hibiki - 03-02-2007

Quote:Originally posted by Krillin
Quote:Originally posted by Super Buu

Oh yeah, almost certainly. In a community this small, bias is unavoidable. Just pointing out a problem in the example he used.

Ok. Reijin doesn't pump out 1000-word mediocre posts thrice a week. That does not at all discredit his work, both in-saga and out of it. You certainly aren't arguing that his non-saga work is non-existent?

The thing is that those awards were based on performance solely from '06.

If we were to do awards taken in totality, from the beginning, I'm pretty sure that Raditzu and Reijin would claim the top spots every time.

As it is, while Reirei was very active in sagas (and totally pwned!), he was not very active outside of them, so wasn't nominated for a lot of positions. Did he even have a personal roleplay saga in '06? Or a quest? (Not an attack - honestly asking.)


Impact Class of 06' - Jonathan Meer - 03-02-2007

If memory serves, he wasn't even considered at all for Best Roleplayer. That's really what I'm referring to.


Impact Class of 06' - Hellfighter 17 - 03-02-2007

At the beginning of the year he did the thing where he killed off Videl and he did the dragonball wish. Only two I know off the top of my head.


Impact Class of 06' - Super Buu - 03-02-2007

Quote:Originally posted by Krillin
Quote:Originally posted by Super Buu

The rest of the post is kind of moot, though. What with it being 05 and not 06 that won. I guess it says a lot for your debating skills that you can argue with invisible ammunition, kekeke.

I was attacking the principle, Super Buu. For that reason, I didn't think it necessary to actually check how many had won from each individual class. 'Invisible ammunition' has nothing to do with it.
It was a compliment. You're the only person I know who can hold an argument with no real idea as to what they're talking about. Tongue


Impact Class of 06' - Jonathan Meer - 03-02-2007

As I just said, I was attacking the principle. I had assumed Aqua got his facts correct, and decided to go with them. Because these are the 'facts' he used to create his argument, then it is absolutely necessary to use the same 'facts' to defeat the argument. If I had considered it at all necessary to actually get the specific instance cleared up, then I probably would have checked, but I was more concerned with the principle.

Conclusion: Not worrying about facts that do not at all actually apply to the intent of my counter-argument does not constitute an ignorance of what I'm talking about.


Impact Class of 06' - Super Buu - 03-02-2007

Quote:Originally posted by Krillin
As I just said, I was attacking the principle. I had assumed Aqua got his facts correct, and decided to go with them.
He did.

Quote:Because these are the 'facts' he used to create his argument, then it is absolutely necessary to use the same 'facts' to defeat the argument.
Okay, but he did. So you were arguing against something nonexistant.

Quote:If I had considered it at all necessary to actually get the specific instance cleared up, then I probably would have checked, but I was more concerned with the principle.

Conclusion: Not worrying about facts that do not at all actually apply to the intent of my counter-argument does not constitute an ignorance of what I'm talking about.
You argued that 06ers won because they are the most populous class and that they thus voted for their friends in the same 'class'. That's what you concluded. But 06ers didn't win, so obviously they're not as bias as you think.

So yes, IMO at least, getting your facts straight does matter, even if you're already arguing for the 'right' principle. I myself agreed with Kibbles, but arguing something that's 'right' for the wrong reasons is just as bad as arguing something that's wrong.

The problem with this method of debating is that it counts on nobody calling it out. Still pretty effective when you have the power to lock threads, though. Tongue


Impact Class of 06' - Jonathan Meer - 03-02-2007

Quote:Okay, but he did. So you were arguing against something nonexistant.

Yes, on a re-read, I missed a "not". Rather important little pronoun there.

Quote:You argued that 06ers won because they are the most populous class and that they thus voted for their friends in the same 'class'. That's what you concluded. But 06ers didn't win, so obviously they're not as bias as you think.

In light of the fact that I misread his post, yeah.

Quote:So yes, IMO at least, getting your facts straight does matter, even if you're already arguing for the 'right' principle. I myself agreed with Kibbles, but arguing something that's 'right' for the wrong reasons is just as bad as arguing something that's wrong.

At the most basic state, even if my argument was based upon a misreading, the actual intent of my argument still applies to the intent of Aqua's argument.

Quote:The problem with this method of debating is that it counts on nobody calling it out. Still pretty effective when you have the power to lock threads, though. Tongue

There's a difference in misreading, and counting on "nobody calling it out". I made a mistake. Implying that I'm intentionally glazing over issues just to craft a good argument doesn't quite logically follow.


Impact Class of 06' - Hellfighter 17 - 03-03-2007

Buu's right on yoru '06 bias, Krillin. Your ideas behind the voting were wrong, in principle, and in fact.


Impact Class of 06' - Alexander Trafford - 03-03-2007

I think the thing that matters here, and it's the only thing that matters, is that the class of 2004 is by far the most kickass.


Impact Class of 06' - Aero - 03-03-2007

Mathematically, that's impossible.


Impact Class of 06' - Jonathan Meer - 03-03-2007

Quote:Originally posted by Hell Fighter 17
Buu's right on yoru '06 bias, Krillin. Your ideas behind the voting were wrong, in principle, and in fact.

Point out the errors in my logic, and THEN I might be inclined to agree with you. Until then, forgive me for not holding your evidence-less statement as divinity.