| The following warnings occurred: | |||||||||||||||
Warning [2] Undefined property: MyLanguage::$archive_pages - Line: 2 - File: printthread.php(287) : eval()'d code PHP 8.5.13 (Linux)
|
![]() |
|
Pebble Logic? - Printable Version +- CDBZ Archive (http://alex.zulenka.com) +-- Forum: Administrative Forums (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=7) +--- Forum: Questions and Suggestions (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=124) +--- Thread: Pebble Logic? (/showthread.php?tid=10074) Pages:
1
2
|
Pebble Logic? - Super Buu - 12-28-2006 Since the old thread has clearly progressed past Body Split, I thought I'd make this thread so we can focus on what I consider to be the most important issue. I would rather that my answer come from an admin, because, from what I can see, not even the SMs have heard of this before either. Apparently, on Chubbs, we are working with what I have dubbed Pebble Logic. To put it in RPG terms: a certain amount of damage dealt to a character is nullified completely - damage is not merely divided based on stats. The usage of Pebble Logic within Chubbs is backed up by the word of an admin, so I'd say it's fairly solid. However, this is the first I've ever heard of this. It pretty much shifts how powerlevel is handled within the RPG. It also affects how I'll be roleplaying fights and the like, so I'd consider it a pretty important issue. According to the Body Split thread, the current Body Split rules are a fairly accurate portrayal of how Pebble Logic works. Let's have some examples. According to Pebble Logic, Super Buu, with a powerlevel of 34,540,000, is roughly equal, battle-wise, to the combined powers of Yamu (22,440,000 ki), Celipa (20,604,375 ki), Sno (21,395,000 ki) and Tapion (21,599,500 ki). Another example is Raditzu at full power (168,025,000 ki) being roughly equal to three of Reijin, also at full power (123,255,000 ki). The examples could go on and on, but that's the basic jist. My question is, quite simply; are the examples in this thread correct, power level wise, or am I misunderstanding something Raditzu has said? Pebble Logic? - Alura - 12-28-2006 I'm not following at all. Pebble Logic? - Super Buu - 12-28-2006 Quote:Originally posted by Super BuuNo offense, Burt. =) Pebble Logic? - Alura - 12-28-2006 Yea, but it sounds like something I should know about, and I'm staff, so you're gonna tell me. Thanks in advance. Pebble Logic? - Super Buu - 12-28-2006 Most of it was in the other thread. It is supposedly the logic behind why the current Body Split rules were implemented. Explained by Rad: Quote:What you're looking at incorrectly, Super Buu, is your "maximum ki" figure. Just because four characters have 250,000 ki individually doesn't mean they fight together at the level of a fighter with one million ki. Even if all four of the weaker characters punch the stronger character at the same time, he's not going to feel any of them.Simplified by Piccoro: Quote:If four people threw a 1/4" pebble at a window, they'd probably bounce off, but if you take a full 1" rock and throw it at the window, it'll shatter. Pebble Logic? - Kaden - 12-28-2006 Quote:Originally posted by Super Buu First off, I gave no numbers in any of my responses that would support this example. I never once said anything even close to "if your character ten thousand ki stronger than your opponent, their attacks don't matter." You're using incomplete logic. Quote:Originally posted by Super Buu What is that even supposed to mean. 3 Reijin clones whose total is 123,000,000? Three clones that possess individual powerlevels of 123,000,000? All of my references I made to power discrepencies were along the lines of "400,000 vs 1,000,000." In that case, I would very much argue that the stronger character would be hardly phased by the attacks of the weaker. You're overexaggerating something I said and trying to twist it into, what I can only see as, and attack on Chubbs. Pebble Logic? - Vegeta - 12-28-2006 There is a point where enough difference in ki and you can't actually hurt your opponent. Their resistance to your attacks surpasses the damage you are able to do. Pebble Logic? - Kaden - 12-28-2006 Quote:Originally posted by Waffuru To back this up, look at Vegeta vs Perfect Cell or Tien vs Cell or Yamcha vs 20. In every single one of those cases the weaker character could do precisely jack shit to the stronger. In the case of Tien, yes his attacks stopped Cell, but they also did nothing in the way of damage to him. Tien was on the verge of killing himself and Cell hadn't even broken a sweat. Pebble Logic? - Super Buu - 12-28-2006 Quote:Originally posted by RaditzuMy argument, and numbers, are based entirely off of the current Body Split rules. Quote:Sorry if I was ambiguous here. Three full, identical Reijins. Or simplified, Reijin and two guys who match his powerlevel, ganging up against Rad.Quote:Originally posted by Super Buu Quote:All of my references I made to power discrepencies were along the lines of "400,000 vs 1,000,000." In that case, I would very much argue that the stronger character would be hardly phased by the attacks of the weaker.Like I said, all of this is based on the current Body Split rules. I wouldn't pull these numbers out of my ass. Attack on Chubbs is kind of ridiculous. I'm attacking the logic behind a certain technique, not Chubbs. I love this place and I want to make it better if I can. As for the show logic, I thought you said all of that was thrown out of the window, since this is a game and we're making decisions based on fairness and balance, rather than what happened in the show? If we were were using that argument, I could provide contradictory examples, such as the Frieza vs Goku fight (Goku was still able to damage 50% Frieza, even though he was a fraction of Frieza's power). Pebble Logic? - OldNoriAccount - 12-28-2006 Quote:Posted by Raditzu I second that. Also, I beleive you are looking to far into this. Raditzu isn't saying that if you are weaker then a individual it is impossible to win, and that roleplaying has no purpose in a fight; that it all goes by Ki. He is saying that a weak person, based on Ki, can't beat a extremely high person, based on Ki. I beleive Perfect Example. Krillen uses Destructo disk, while not a weak character, he is a infidel compared to perfect cell. Destructo Disk does nothing. It isn't that Ki is everything, its just that someone a lot weaker then a stronger individual, even in great numbers, is still a lot weaker. If you had a thousand Krillens doing Destructo Disk, not only would it do nothing to Cell, but he would vaporize them all with one technique. I beleive thats right. Edit: Sorry Rad, didn't see your last post with the weaker fighters versus a stronger fighter. Pebble Logic? - Kaden - 12-28-2006 Your examples are completely wrong. I would never, under any circumstances say that 1 Rad > 3 Rei. Ever. You have absolutely no basis for claiming I implied that, either. For are those examples based off of the Body Split rules? You're just making up some invisible point at which a character is no longer effective against another character. You're mixing my words about what's based off of the show. The Body Split technique was taken from the show and adapted to fit the RPG. "Pebble Logic," while my examples are drawn from the show, just makes sense. If we went the way you seem to want to go, I could write that Super Buu was attacked by 40,000,000 townsfolk and killed because their strength added up was greater than Buus. Pebble Logic? - OldNoriAccount - 12-28-2006 Oh. Better example. In the series Cell splits into four cells, after a few minutes Goku wins, having taken barely any damage himself. By dividing himself into four people, Cell actually *weakened* himself, and lowered his possibility of winning. Even cell, who was stronger then Goku, was unable to beat a weaker foe with *four* copies. It weakened him, and made him all that much easier to beat. Just wanted to throw that in there, as a superb example of how Body Split in the show/on here with the new policy, would work. Pebble Logic? - Super Buu - 12-28-2006 Quote:Originally posted by Raditzu Not >, =. I didn't say either wasn't effective against the other, I said they were roughly equal. Ie three Reijins roughly equal to one Rad, and one SB roughly equal to the four fighters in my example that possessed ~20 million ki. If you want, I can explain it further. Quote:You're mixing my words about what's based off of the show. The Body Split technique was taken from the show and adapted to fit the RPG. "Pebble Logic," while my examples are drawn from the show, just makes sense.I'm not arguing that. Pebble Logic does make sense in a real world, but this is an RPG. Forget logic for a second, and think about fairness. Quote:If we went the way you seem to want to go, I could write that Super Buu was attacked by 40,000,000 townsfolk and killed because their strength added up was greater than Buus.Equal. >_> If you wanted to RP that, sure. But this is mainly for the sake of working out fights and the like. Pebble Logic? - Kaden - 12-28-2006 Hey guys, SB marked this "Staff Only" for a reason. Pebble Logic? - Kaden - 12-28-2006 Quote:Originally posted by Super Buu >. Look at your max ki. 3 Rei > 1 Rad. There, I corrected myself. I am thinking about fairness. The people who are strong are strong for a reason: the time and effort they have put into their characters on this RPG. The people who are weak are weak for a reason: they have not been here long enough to build up their character. If you don't want "pebble logic" to be a problem for you in fights, don't fight people who are four times as strong as you are. Pebble Logic? - Kaden - 12-28-2006 I really don't know what to say to you, SB. You're exaggerating what I've said until it sounds completely ridiculous and that the character with the higher powerlevel will always win no matter what. I haven't said anything like that and would never condone it. Pebble Logic? - Vegeta - 12-28-2006 You don't seem to be understanding how the system actually works so maybe it would help if you explained how you think it works, not just how you think it should. I don't seem to be understanding what the hell you're going on about. Pebble Logic? - Super Buu - 12-28-2006 Quote:Originally posted by RaditzuThat's fairly unavoidable in say, Dante's Abyss. ![]() Powerlevel will always be an issue in the RPG, and it's pretty central. I don't think it's a good idea just to dismiss the problem like that. I know you're a smart guy, but I don't understand this way of thinking. It's fine without pebble logic. But the way it is now, powerlevels are effectively increasing exponentially. Eventually it's going to get to the point where certain members are completely untouchable. Is that what you want? You're contradicting yourself. On one front, you're saying that yes, pebble logic makes sense and it's okay. On the other hand you're claiming that I'm exaggerating what you've said to make it sound ridiculous. I have exaggerated nothing. All the numbers I've used are based off of Body Split, a system you've claimed is fair. If it's not fair, then fix it. If you do think it's fair, then well, we've come to a disagreement. It would be nice to have it clarified either way without being accused of exaggerating facts. Pebble Logic? - Jonathan Meer - 12-28-2006 Quote:Originally posted by Super Buu Then I'll explain. At least three veteran members of Chubbs who have crafted it over the years have told you that current system is perfectly fine. YOU are convinced that it is an issue. Thus, while the Staff has decided that this is a non-issue, you still aren't satisfied, so you still consider the subject to be an issue. Quote:It's fine without pebble logic. But the way it is now, powerlevels are effectively increasing exponentially. Eventually it's going to get to the point where certain members are completely untouchable. Is that what you want? There will never be a point where members are completely untouchable. Writing Ability > Stats. But yes, someone who has put fifty years of work into a character should not be hassle-able by someone who has been on the site for a year. Pebble Logic? - Kaden - 12-28-2006 Like I said before, I don't know what to tell you. The admins think its balanced and you don't. Does this make it unfair when someone with a powerlevel of twenty fights someone with a powerlevel of twenty million? Yes. Is that a percieved problem? No. In the thread "Body Split = Multiplier?" you said that a debate should be about coming to a rational conclusion. You don't seem to want a rational conclusion, you seem to want it to be your way. Your suggestion, very obviously, has not gone over well and you obviously are displeased with the system the way things are now. Instead of trying to come up with a comprimise you're just repeating your same points over and over again. Unfortunately for you, though, those points are based on something that you percieve as a problem and the administrators do not. This is the way Chubbs has been since its conception. I see no reason to change something that has worked for over seven years because you took the most dramatic example you could and said it wasn't fair. Techniques and abilities in Chubbs are balanced to be used against other PCs of comparible powerlevel. When you take them out of the scenario they're balanced for, of course they don't seem fair. |