![]() |
|
I haven't asked in a while, so.... - Printable Version +- CDBZ Archive (http://alex.zulenka.com) +-- Forum: Out of Character Forums (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=8) +--- Forum: RPG Discussion (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=125) +--- Thread: I haven't asked in a while, so.... (/showthread.php?tid=10804) |
I haven't asked in a while, so.... - Kazuya - 03-14-2007 Who feels like reading? =D Red Ribbon Advance and Red Ribbon Advance Its a two parter. =D I would really love some C&C on these, questions welcome. I haven't asked in a while, so.... - Kazuya - 03-16-2007 No one? ;.; I will offer comments and criticizm in exchange, all ya gotta do is provide a link... it don't have to be just one RP, it can be a few, I don't care. I just would like some feedback on these two RP's. =) I haven't asked in a while, so.... - Szar - 03-16-2007 Alright, fine. I'm a nice guy. Give me a minute here. I haven't asked in a while, so.... - Szar - 03-16-2007 First off, if there's one thing I can't stand it's when people CAPITALIZE something for emphasis. It's just a pet peeve of mine. Secondly, I'm not a grammar whiz, so I can't help there. And finally, I raise the point that I couldn't help but feel I was reading a soap opera. It just had that vibe, and I don't know if that's what you were going for. If it was, good for you. If it wasn't, I wag my finger in your general direction. Overall, I enjoy your style, and you're clearly talented. It just seemed like the drama was forced. That's what I have to say. Hope it helped. I haven't asked in a while, so.... - Kazuya - 03-16-2007 Its the thing between Violet and Nathaniel. Thus, drama, perhaps a little soapy, was what I was aiming for. Thanks, Recoome, although, not to be picky, I was looking for something a little more...thourough. I haven't asked in a while, so.... - Szar - 03-16-2007 I apologize. In-depth criticism has never been my strong suit. I can try again, if you'd like? I haven't asked in a while, so.... - Old Zangya - 03-16-2007 That was good; I should start reading more of your work, heh heh. Anyhow, to get down to the specifics. On your first post, I was a bit put off by the fact that it seemed too, as Recoome said, soapy; a little soapy is okay, but this just went slightly over the edge. It was filled with all sorts of revelations and stuff like that. Also, you have a few capitalization errors, although I'm sure you're aware of that; I can see that you used a word processor, so I don't know why it didn't correct you. But still, it's minor, and nothing can be done, can it? ![]() Second post. I liked this one. It seemed long, perhaps, to me, but then, that's just me; also, the dialogue in the conversation between Nathaniel and Violet seemed more soapy than the dialogue was slightly more overdramatic than it was in the first post. Honestly, I half expected that bounty hunter to drop out from nowhere. But it was still good, overall, and I do believe that the last bit was just a tiny bit corny, with the ransom meeting and all that. But again, just my opinion. One last thing...as Recoome said, capitalizing for emphasis is slightly annoying when it's not used in dialogue. My main query here is: What exactly did this have to do with the quest? Now, having not read the earlier parts I may just be naive; but if you could just answer me that. Also, you implied you would give criticism. There is a topic in this board called "Android 7 Posts"; if you could possibly give some critique there, that would be helpful. I haven't asked in a while, so.... - Kazuya - 03-16-2007 You don't have to apologize, I apreciate the input. Just people who know my storyline a little better know how I write, lol, and can offer a bit more insight between some of my earlier posts and this one. Its not so much grammar I am looking for, but its the basic premise of the overall story at hand that I am seeking comments on. Nathaniel, the android that is in there, is actually one of my ongoing NPC's, and the ex husband of Violet. If you want, just do a search on my username in the IC forums and look at my earliest posts. That'll give you a little history on why I chose this theme to write in. =) But, nah, you're good. You don't have to try again, I am not that much of a butthole. =) EDIT to Coola: Nathaniel and Surreo have both been sent to fetch Violet to bring her back to Red Ribbon. Commander Red, being the dirty guy he is, is probably going to be killing off Surreo later on, Nathaniel is sort of there to make sure she is brought back, alive, so that she can be used to take control of several other forts around the contenient. Back in the day, she used to be one of the number one killers/assassins for Red Ribbon, and no one has really surmounted her skills, thus why Red wanted her back so that they can ensure that the takeover is as silent, but effective as possible. The earlier posts explain the attacks on the first fort, and Nathaniel following Violet around, as well as when Violet was in the custody of Surreo and his band. And alright, I'll look into that post. =) I haven't asked in a while, so.... - Old Zangya - 03-16-2007 Thanks, and that's an interesting backstory. Nice. |