CDBZ Archive
Rate the Roleplay Above You - Printable Version

+- CDBZ Archive (http://alex.zulenka.com)
+-- Forum: Out of Character Forums (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=8)
+--- Forum: RPG Discussion (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=125)
+--- Thread: Rate the Roleplay Above You (/showthread.php?tid=13257)



Rate the Roleplay Above You - Alura - 01-05-2009

Old favorite thread coming back to life. Rules:

-In order to get your roleplay critiqued, you must rate and C&C the one above you. It must be detailed, and you must read the entire roleplay

-After doing so, you can link to your own roleplay (the direct link, not the whole thread) and have someone rate your's

-You may only have one single roleplay rated up to three times.

-You can not rate the same roleplay more then once

-You may only post in this thread up to two times in one day.

-There is no 'calling dibs.' Make sure you refresh before you post to make sure someone hasn't beaten you to it. If two people accidentally rate the same roleplay, the first person to post is the one who gets their roleplay rated next.

-By 'rate' I mean give a score 1-10. Make sure to include C&C too!


I don't have a roleplay, so next person gets to put the link up and start us off. Go!


Rate the Roleplay Above You - Jonathan Meer - 01-05-2009

http://cdbzrpg.com/forum/showpost.php?p=484043&postcount=1

BAM


Rate the Roleplay Above You - Juno - 01-05-2009

The first post? That's like, a NINE POINT FIVE. I loved that freakin' post.

http://www.cdbzrpg.com/forum/showthread.php?p=485129#post485129

EDIT: Forgot the C&C.

OK, so it was a nice introduction that I enjoyed muchly. But here's the problems with it that made it less than a 10. OK, you normally write comedic stuff, I know. Now, when I read this, I saw the title, and I was like 'double ewe tee eff.' So I come in here, and I read it, and I'm like... whoa. What the eff was that. Now, it was a really good post that looking back on it, I enjoyed, but everything just sort of popped out of nowhere, like 'huh whoa'. I think that's the only thing that brought it down. It was just strange enough to keep me reading, to say the least. =]


Rate the Roleplay Above You - Kaden - 01-05-2009

Alura Wrote:-By 'rate' I mean give a score 1-10. Make sure to include C&C too!

C'mon Juno.


Rate the Roleplay Above You - Juno - 01-05-2009

Kaden Wrote:C'mon Juno.
I did! =]


Rate the Roleplay Above You - Alexander Trafford - 01-06-2009

As the last person to post a link, this is to Juno:

7/10

I enjoyed your character, as I've already told you, and i think you write well. The post flowed well and you added just enough detail so that i could picture what was going on, but not too much so that the story was bogged down. It seemed as though you were going for comedy, however, and for a few parts - like the old woman and the image of her skydiving and dying, i had a smirk on my face. But the end, with the mouse being inside the tank and Juno comforting it? It felt like it was an attempt at odd humour, and i just didn't find it funny, or like it at all. Overall a solid post, but i think you should work on fleshing out your character rather than trying to get humor. Also, i haven't read all your posts just a few, maybe two or three, this one being the one i've paid the most attention to.

http://cdbzrpg.com/forum/showthread.php?p=485524#post485524

Either one, there is only two. I'd prefer the second one be rated.


Rate the Roleplay Above You - Cain - 01-08-2009

It's very good. The description is well done, and the scene with Slade is reminiscent of manya magician movies. There's something off about the flow and the blocky paragraphs that make it an eight five. I like the gruff addition of alcohol and cigarettes mirroring talking the crowd over in the second post.

http://www.cdbzrpg.com/forum/showthread.php?p=486194#post486194
Top post


Rate the Roleplay Above You - Kaden - 01-08-2009

I thought that was a very interesting intro post. I liked the setting a lot. A kind of birth for your character. What I like most is that you strayed away from either side of the "newly awakened machine" stereotype; Cain wasn't annoyingly naive about everything, nor did he coldly and mechanically understand exactly what he was and what was going on. Not being a stereotype is a good thing, most of the time.

My suggestions, if I had seen this before you posted it, would have been to devote a little more time to the specifics of the setting. The bit about the window wasn't really clear until Cain actually took a capsule out of it. That the mysterious voice was being heard and read wasn't clear until I had gotten through a significant part of the RP. I know they seem like minor details when you're writing it, a reader's mind gets hooked on small stuff that doesn't fit and that detracts from the rest of the writing.

I think I only have two other criticisms, and they're both about punctuation. Be careful about using the semi-colon, though that usually goes without saying. You misused one in the first paragraph. The second bit is about using the hyphen more. Instead of "pinky sized blue cylinder" try "pinky-sized blue cylinder." It helps guide the reader, which is something I know I prefer when I'm reading. I like to devote more attention to the picture the author is trying to paint than the way the words should go together; the more of that the author does for me, the better.

Everything else is pretty solid, though. The pace didn't dawdle, the descriptions are good, the characters seems interesting. Off to a very good start.

http://www.cdbzrpg.com/forum/showpost.php?p=484223&postcount=2

That's my first post in Seredipity (and actually, my first post as Kaden). It's not my most recent RP, but it's the most indicitive of what I'll be shooting for while writing this character; at this point in time, at least. Thanks to whoever goes next.


Rate the Roleplay Above You - Super Buu - 01-08-2009

Skillful as always. People looking to improve their writing should note the way Kad often implicitly states details without it actually being the subject of a sentence. Like "As he hopped into the driver's seat, Kaden made sure his couriers "liscence" -- simply an ID card meant to ensure people that he was who his company said he was -- was dangling from the rear view mirror, inches below the fuzzy dice his boss had got him to celebrate making his 100th delivery." is a nice easy way of slipping in the fact that he's done at least 100 deliveries. It loses no detail or significance, and makes things more concise. I don't know whether that was actually a deliberate detail you included in this case, but you do it anyway and it's good.

There were quite a lot of typos and mispellings, like 'liscense', 'apetite' 'corssed' and 'passanger'. Nothing MS word wouldn't be able to fix. You also could vary up the wording a bit to use 'Kaden' less often, though that's somewhat stylistic preference.

Kaden's character came across quite strongly, though, as always, I'm more curious as to the 'whys', what made him into the personality he is. Though the reasons for his current mood aren't so hard to pick out. Speaking of which, was Greg a deliberate name choice? =P

Story-wise, I'm intrigued to see where it goes - but obviously, it's a bit hard to judge it yet.

Do we really have to give numerical ratings? =(

http://cdbzrpg.com/forum/showpost.php?p=485682&postcount=1


Rate the Roleplay Above You - Jesper - 01-08-2009

At first, I didn't know why you chose that particular post, but then I saw that it was your intro. <.< As an intro, it did everything that you'd hope an intro would do--it described your setting adequately, and it gave me a hint as to what I have to look forward to when reading up on your character. I've never been so torn between wanting to love and wanting to hate a character; you really have her attitude down, and it particularly shows in that post.

No outstanding grammar errors, and pretty solidly written altogether. I like your setting, and the dialogue was good, albeit corny. xD Dunno if it was your intention, but some of the dialogue reminded me of something like School House Rock (I was expecting Arlutheus to tell Rose that knowledge is power, for instance). Not saying that's bad, or anything--if your intention was to make it laugh a little bit, it did. =P

Since it's in the rules, I'll give a numerical value: 7/10. It was a good start to a very good roleplay.

http://www.cdbzrpg.com/forum/showpost.php?p=484518&postcount=6

Not my first post, and not even my best post, but the most relevant to my character in Serendipity.


Rate the Roleplay Above You - Alexander Trafford - 01-09-2009

Not the best roleplay of yours that i've read recently, but still a very strong piece of work. Some parts of it seemed a bit wordy, for example "Anyone who knew her from the temple watching this situation would surely point out that this was the point in time when Sophia told him to take the wounded criminal to the nearest town for him to recover.". I don't exactly know how, but i'm sure there is a way to say this more succinctly, making it easier on the reader. I had to re-read the middle part of that sentence to get a grasp on who exactly was pointing out what to who in what point of time and it interrupted the little 'movie' i had playing in my head. Other parts seemed surprisingly anti-climatic,However, the young girl that the room belonged to had picked up Theodore’s dagger and plunged it into the raider’s side. It seemed like you had put a decent amount of time into this confrontation, then wham! in one short sentence he was dead, which isn't a problem but you probably could have spiced up that sentence a bit since, at the time, it seemed reasonably important.

All in all a strong RP that flowed well with very good imagery, i could picture exactly what was going on and didn't have to stop (more than once) to re-read anything, which is exactly what i like.

7/10, most of your other posts that i've read so far i'd give 8.5s, you're of to a very strong start and i think RPing in a group has really helped you with your character and your writing, especially since your in the company of other strong writers.

http://cdbzrpg.com/forum/showpost.php?p=486526&postcount=4

This is post #4 of Dreams and Doorways and the first time i've incorporated a flashback, let me know if i made it work.


Rate the Roleplay Above You - Jack - 01-11-2009

Alexander Trafford Wrote:http://cdbzrpg.com/forum/showpost.php?p=486526&postcount=4

This is post #4 of Dreams and Doorways and the first time i've incorporated a flashback, let me know if i made it work.

That was awesome. I'm going to be honest, I had no idea you could write like that. As Minoshia, it always seemed that you had the vocabulary of a writer, but could never put together sentences like one. This time around, your descriptions are really good. Not too dense, but not overly simple and "dumbed down". That's a balance that I'm jealous of, and not many people can do right.

The flashback was ok. If you were going for the whole "he's haunted by his past" angle, you should have put something haunting in there. A syringe isn't really that bad, and I'm sure that wasn't the extent of the experiments. And if it was, try and go for something more out there and horrific, I know you can pull that off. It's a flashback, seemingly the kind that people with PTSD suffer from. Should be something more traumatic than that. Just a suggestion though, that's getting into your territory a little bit.

I give it an 8.5!

Me: http://cdbzrpg.com/forum/showthread.php?p=486732#post486732

Spontaneous and I have no idea where the story is going. What you read is what you get.


Rate the Roleplay Above You - Alexander Trafford - 01-11-2009

Bil Baer Jaxx Wrote:The flashback was ok. If you were going for the whole "he's haunted by his past" angle, you should have put something haunting in there. A syringe isn't really that bad, and I'm sure that wasn't the extent of the experiments. And if it was, try and go for something more out there and horrific, I know you can pull that off. It's a flashback, seemingly the kind that people with PTSD suffer from. Should be something more traumatic than that. Just a suggestion though, that's getting into your territory a little bit.

Thanks, that's all good advice and i'll take it into account, much appreciated. The point of the flashback, and their won't be many of them, that might even be the only one, was to try to explain the estranged relationship with his father, which is hinted at and pointed out in post 3, and tease at his links to military and scientific testing and experimentation in the past. More of a teaser than a 'traumatic or haunting' kind of deal.


Rate the Roleplay Above You - Vad - 01-11-2009

I loved it. Your comic style of describing things really makes it interesting to read. The description of the guys perched atop the gunner seats was amazing. Perfect. I hope it's not the only thing you write.

I should, mention that I'm not hard to entertain.

10/10


http://www.cdbzrpg.com/forum/showpost.php?p=486618&postcount=21


Rate the Roleplay Above You - Cain - 01-12-2009

"Only at fifty percent power, and he was matching his grandfather. Each calculated blow, matched evenly with the older man’s prowess. The sadistic assassin caught his grandfather’s right foot as he threw it toward him. Bashing it to the side, Vad aimed his knuckles toward his grandfather’s exposed sternum only to have his fist swatted away."
I'm a stickler for using different words in certain situations.

In the next paragraph, I say if you're going for the drama of a lightning storm, use a thesaurus and add some strong words. I think the lighting storm could've been described a bit more, but thats personal preference. For instance, It brewing, getting larger and larger, and then breaking into a fierce storm as the scene progresses. Not as one paragraph.

The next paragraph has instantly at the end. I'm not sure if that's necessary or not.

"The assassin’s eyes were blood shot, his pupils were dialated, and blood was running down both corners of his mouth, which was clenched shut. Piper could see, Vad was getting frustrated with himself. Unleashing a battle cry, the assassin unleashed himself to 95% of his maximum ability, and his body became surrounded by a magnificent aura that was burning violently like the tail fire of a ship booster."

You have two subject POV's in one paragraph. It reads funny.

Laughing maniacally, Vad lurched forward, pushing a massive gust of air to his rear, pushing dust and debris toward his two new allies. As he neared his grandfather he formed his left arm into a blade, and as he approached, shifted his flight to the right plowing through Raden’s left arm; his undead side.

Can't comment on the semi-colon, as I'm not sure how to use it. As for the bold, this time I liked the use of pushing twice. It was sortof poetic. The end of the paragraph is a little blocky.

The next bit is about Grammar.
“Let him finish this alone.” She explained. = Incorrect.
“Let him finish this alone,” she explained. = Correct.

You say consciousness once when you mean conscious, but the message still exists.

Good job. That's about it. The story reads like something out of a manga. Cool points for that.
7/10

http://cdbzrpg.com/forum/showpost.php?p=487181&postcount=7


Rate the Roleplay Above You - Cain - 01-16-2009

Bump.


Rate the Roleplay Above You - Jonathan Meer - 01-16-2009

Don't bump this topic.


Rate the Roleplay Above You - Cain - 01-16-2009

Sorry.


Rate the Roleplay Above You - Alexander Trafford - 01-16-2009

8/10. Very intriguing RP, the story flowed well and, while there were some grammatical errors, none were big or bad enough that i had to stop and re-read. I was very impressed and i plan on going back and reading your entire storyline, i've read the beginning and now the 7th post, but you got me wanting to know more. That's the most impressive thing about your writing in this post, it's interesting from start to finish with very little boring sections, when the middle started to get bogged down and tiresome, you came out with the wafflehouse comment to the police officer, and that got me chuckling.

Very good RP, nice work and keep it up!

http://www.cdbzrpg.com/forum/showthread.php?p=488004#post488004