CDBZ Archive
Hit me with the criticism! - Printable Version

+- CDBZ Archive (http://alex.zulenka.com)
+-- Forum: Forum Games (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=274)
+--- Forum: Chubbs Idol (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=187)
+--- Thread: Hit me with the criticism! (/showthread.php?tid=34381)



Hit me with the criticism! - Ruhiel - 09-01-2006

My three choices:

Bardock
Zarbon
Super Buu


Hit me with the criticism! - Raditzu - 09-01-2006

Super Buu

Quote:Android 20

20?s very creative, as you can see just by looking at his character vault. He?s also a good writer. I do doubt his ability to exert authority, however. He?s been running a saga on FoF and he has a tendency, it seems, to ?bow down? to what the members want. One member asked, ?can I drown a giant city in pudding and make everyone in the saga have to wade through pudding,? and 20 approved it on the grounds that it ?wasn?t as bad as the other ideas involving Godzilla/King Kong.? On that occasion I had to intervene and put my foot down.

I feel 20?s strengths are in the creative side of things, as opposed to updating/moderating/leading. He comes up with really unique, inventive stuff, but I don?t think he handles PR very well.

Bardock

Quote:Android 20
Strengths: Personally, he inspires loyalty. You get put under him and you want to do the best job you could possibly do. He commands the respect of everyone in his team. It may not sound like a lot, but I think it?s very important and is an imperative quality to have as a leader.

Weaknesses: He?s a good leader in the ways of motivating others, but there are also a few downfalls. In both tasks he gave a strong first impression, and then kind of left people to their own devices for a bit, showing up near the end to guide along the finishing touches. When he?s working with people, great, but he vanishes somewhere in the middle process, when it would be best if he was there the whole way. I?m not saying he abandoned his team, but it would have been better from a to z, and not skipping a few letters along the way. Real life did get in the way, but it?s a factor nonetheless.

ZARBON

Quote:Subject: Android 20

Strengths: Twenty is good as all parts on a team, though in my personal opinion, he fits the leader role best. He knows what has to be done, and makes sure it is done in an organized fashion. He doesn?t let it go all over the place, making sure the team?s work is controlled. He makes intelligent decisions based on his teammates? and his own ideals. As for the other roles, he brings up great, creative ideas. A fine addition to any team, staff or otherwise.
Weaknesses: There is a couple of issues with Twenty when it comes to saying ?no? to people on the team about certain things. He is far too kindly for his own good in other words. As a good leader, it?s important that you have the will to say ?no, we can?t do that? at certain moments (he still has yet to say ?no? to Godzilla to my face). And, as a good general member of a staff team, it may take back on criticism a tad and let people go on their ideas. He does, however, redeem himself by trying to make sure things go smoothly.
Comparison: Twenty is a much better leader than myself, in fact, if he wasn?t so unwilling to disagree at some points than he would be the perfect leader. When it comes to other positions, I?d say we are pretty equal.
Extra Notes: He has done a fantastic job working on ?The Atomic Saga? over on FoF, an example of his skill.

Grade: B+