+- CDBZ Archive (http://alex.zulenka.com)
+-- Forum: Out of Character Forums (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=8)
+--- Forum: RPG Discussion (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=125)
+--- Thread: Member Vote--Goku vs Broli (/showthread.php?tid=4140)
Member Vote--Goku vs Broli - Alura - 03-06-2005
As both are staff members and the fight is HUGE, we are opening it to the public.
Now, vote for you who you feel did the best and deserves to win. Please post a reason with it.
http://cdbzrpg.dracondev.com/forum/thread.php?threadid=8832&sid=
http://cdbzrpg.dracondev.com/forum/thread.php?threadid=9074&sid=
^Those two threads. Posts by Broli and Goku.
PLEASE DO NOT POST OR VOTE IF YOU HAVE NOT READ IT ALL.
Please post a reason after voting. The poll ends in 5 days.
EDIT BY REIJIN: Let's make this interesting... First to 15, or 2 days.
Member Vote--Goku vs Broli - Banned Dana - 03-06-2005
I believe that Goku should win. Sure, they both had ubber big posts, however, I liked Goku's more. I felt like his descriptions were better and I could image the fight a lot better than when Broli posted.
However, they both did an outstanding job. Great job guys! YAY!
Member Vote--Goku vs Broli - Sage - 03-06-2005
Voted Goku. Both roleplays were extraordinarily well done, and both RPers used vivid descriptions to accent the action going on, I just felt that Goku's was just a smidgen more engaging and had a better 'flow'. So, yeah, Gokuh just barely edged out Broirrri.
Member Vote--Goku vs Broli - Abel - 03-06-2005
Wow. I've been inspired to write more again.
Both Burori and Goku did VERY well. They both used a lot of descriptions but Goku had more description. That gave Goku an advantage. But when reading through, I believe Broli was more in-depth and seemed to...argh, I don't know the words. Broli was more inspiring and seemed to give me a pleasant attitude after reading it, more than Goku. It's weird, I know, I just don't know how to explain it.
Very well done to both of you.
Member Vote--Goku vs Broli - Tamsin - 03-06-2005
I personally would vote for a tie, beacuse while Goku looked trough severals pectors on the fight, Brolly went deep into one. They were both awesome. But If i really must chose one, id have to say Goku. I dont know why but it seems to be that he described a lot of things and connected them to things I couldnt even imagine. But I seriously think this should be a tie. It jsut seems unfair to me if one of them lost beacuse they were both excellent.
Member Vote--Goku vs Broli - Old Selipa - 03-06-2005
With Broli, I find it easier to visualize the way the action is being lay forward. With also the way he describes his surrounding and how they interact with him, this makes his role-plays better. Also Goku does the same however I find Broli with the edge in the fight. But great job Goku and a very well written fight.
Member Vote--Goku vs Broli - Sage - 03-06-2005
Quote:Originally posted by Jackie Chun
I personally would vote for a tie, beacuse while Goku looked trough severals pectors on the fight, Brolly went deep into one. They were both awesome. But If i really must chose one, id have to say Goku. I dont know why but it seems to be that he described a lot of things and connected them to things I couldnt even imagine. But I seriously think this should be a tie. It jsut seems unfair to me if one of them lost beacuse they were both excellent.
There has to be a loser. This is Dante's Abyss. Not kindergarten. I don't mean to sound harsh, but this isn't a game where the teacher says "everybody wins."
Member Vote--Goku vs Broli - Tamsin - 03-06-2005
I also make mistakes. When I write quick im not perfect in grammar.
Well yeah this is Dante`s Abyss and I know there must be a winner. But ill still feel bad for whoever will lose this.
Member Vote--Goku vs Broli - Ander - 03-06-2005
Tough choice. Both of them really gave the other a run for his money. Depth and description were unprecedented. Goku had me until Broli's last post. I hate to say it, but Broli gets my vote. His roleplaying gave more to ponder. Goku, you still kick some serious ass though. That was your best work yet.
Member Vote--Goku vs Broli - Kaden - 03-07-2005
I added a blank vote for people who don't have time to read it.
Member Vote--Goku vs Broli - Ashe - 03-07-2005
Quote:PLEASE DO NOT POST OR VOTE IF YOU HAVE NOT READ IT ALL.
Please post a reason after voting. The poll ends in 5 days.
Why have a blank spot? That seems to defeat the point of saying to vote one, the other, or not at all. It isn't lasting until everyone votes, it will last till 5 days times out.
Member Vote--Goku vs Broli - Kaden - 03-07-2005
Quote:Originally posted by Reijin
Why have a blank spot? That seems to defeat the point of saying to vote one, the other, or not at all. It isn't lasting until everyone votes, it will last till 5 days times out.
...
Because I didn't want to click "see results" everytime.
Member Vote--Goku vs Broli - Ashe - 03-07-2005
Haha, laziness shall prevail! XD I just hit see results. Silly Mexican.
Member Vote--Goku vs Broli - Yamu - 03-07-2005
Both are amazingly well done Rp's. I personaly got alot out of them a great ideas for my own furue Rp's from both of you.
As I read the post I kept going back and forth over who's I liked better. I have to give me vote to Broli though, the pure plot development that advanced the story is what became the deciding factor for me.
Member Vote--Goku vs Broli - Orion - 03-08-2005
That's 15 votes to Broli. Congrats man, you deserve it. =D
Winner: Broli
Loser: Goku
Great fight, man. I haven't seen praise from the whole RPG on ANYTHING like this before.
Member Vote--Goku vs Broli - Broli - 03-08-2005
You wouldn't rather wait for the 5 days to end? I'm sure there's a number of people who've yet to vote, and those people could all vote for you.
I reopened it. You can close it again if you disagree.
Member Vote--Goku vs Broli - Alura - 03-08-2005
Actually we(as in Goku , Reijin and myself) decided the first to 15 will win, if it gets up that fast.
Member Vote--Goku vs Broli - Broli - 03-08-2005
Oh. I didn't know we changed it from 5 days to 2 days/15 votes.
Goku, great fight man. That seriously has to have been the most challenging fight I've ever been in. You've done some serious developing in your RP skills over the past months, and I'm sure you're just as eager as I am for Round 2 =).