![]() |
|
Popular Mechanics - Printable Version +- CDBZ Archive (http://alex.zulenka.com) +-- Forum: Out of Character Forums (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=8) +--- Forum: The Legendary Asylum (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=133) +---- Forum: Workshop (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=32) +---- Thread: Popular Mechanics (/showthread.php?tid=9513) |
Popular Mechanics - Kaden - 10-31-2006 This is a story by Raymond Carver that I recently read for an english class. This is in no way my own work, nor am I taking any credit for it. I thought it was a pretty interesting read and that some of the other people here might enjoy it as well. I am copying it exactly as it appears in the book What We Talk About When We Talk About Love. Quote:Originally written by Raymond Carver A short, but very interesting read. A quick note, there are not quotation marks in this short story. Just imagine where you would put them if you were editting this and it reads just fine. Popular Mechanics - Tamsin - 10-31-2006 Interesting read. It isn`t anything especially impressive, but it`s interesting. It kind of reminds me of one of the storys about King Solomon where two women claim that they are the mothers of a baby. So they take the issue to the king who proclaims he will cut the child in half so both mothers get their half. While one of the women agrees, the other pulls from her claim, saying she would rather see the baby live. Naturally, this reached king Solomons pourpose and revealed the true mother to him. So he gave the baby to her. Popular Mechanics - Kaden - 10-31-2006 While I can understand how it would literally remind you of that Solomon story, they're very very different. Popular Mechanics has nothing to do with love for a child. Popular Mechanics - Hellfighter 17 - 10-31-2006 It reminds of King Solomon (not that I have read the Bible, but who hasn't heard half of the stories, and Jackie justgave a synopsis of what I am referring to) in the fact that the author hints that the baby was pulled in half, or at least hurt by the pulling on both sides. I agree with Rad, though, that it is not about love for the baby. I didn't really find it moving. I like stories with negative endings, and I should as a Canadian writer, or so my English teacher tells me, but that's left too open to be purely negative, although I do like its openness there. Popular Mechanics - Tamsin - 10-31-2006 Quote:Originally posted by Raditzu I know. That is why I said it kind off reminds me of it. Popular Mechanics - Kaden - 10-31-2006 The author ends all his stories in that manner. Some people were complaining a lot about that in class. I think its kind of fun. Personally, I don't think any babies actually exist in that story. Popular Mechanics - Hellfighter 17 - 11-01-2006 Well, I think there is (how can you not unless it is magic realism?), but the baby isn't the true purpose of the story, you need to "scratch beneath the surface." The baby was a wonderful use, though. Popular Mechanics - Ruhiel - 11-01-2006 Is that the entire article? Or did the author go on to explain his point? Or is this one of those "you figure it out" things? Out of context, it's hard for me to figure out what connections to draw. Wait, is this not from the magazine "Popular Mechanics"? I think I may have taken this out of context. >.< Popular Mechanics - Kaden - 11-01-2006 Its a short story by Raymond Carver. Its not from a magazine or anything. What I quoted was the story in its entirty. Quote:He did not answer. He fastened the suitcase, put on his coat, looked around the bedrom before turning off the light. Then he went out to the living room That's where I think the literal story ends. Popular Mechanics - Hellfighter 17 - 11-01-2006 So do you think it's a mental struggle or thought of processes that went on in his head? Popular Mechanics - Kaden - 11-01-2006 I think its a reflection of how their relationship went wrong. Moreover, I think it sums up a good deal of relationships. "Flashback" is the closest term I can think of. Popular Mechanics - Tamsin - 11-01-2006 Quote:Originally posted by Hell Fighter 17 Agreed. |