ST3: Vegeta vs Yajirobe (First Round)

[Burter Jr]

Subject: Garlic Jr

Theme: Deceit

Text: Garlic Jr; Fallen Knight Complex OR FKC

PM me the sig with a description of how it ties into your theme.


Sig #1


Well I felt that Garlic Jr. always had a little green in him, so the color to me fit well. The picture is of him using a sly smirk, no doubt treaterous, and the sculpture behind him is of Benedict Arnold, it's self explanatory.


Sig #2


The thing that I think goes with the theme the most is the pic I used. He has a kind of a "What?!" look on his face, like something really unexpected happened, for example, deception. I also used darker colors, save the bright one in the middle, which I used to make more contrast. The font doesn't exactly show deceit, but it could be used for similar themes like evil or sadness or something along the lines of that. I can't say it's my best work, but I do think it goes with the theme.






-The Poll will last 24 hours. Winner after that time will move on

-Artists, do not say which one is your's. If anyone knows who's is who, do NOT say.

-Comments are appreciated. Artists, do not respond to any comments until the match is over.

[Kazuya]

I like them both, but the second just says PHATNESS all over it. Good Job!

[Hellfighter 17]

I dislike basically every aspect of the second. It's alright, but there's not really anything in it that make sme say, "Oh, at least I like that." The first is really good, especially the effect on the background, which I love, but the sculpture of Ben seems like a stupid ide,a but otherwise, great job. *thumbs up*

I think it's ovcious which one I voted for. >.>'

[Rem-13]

I dislike the interference with GJ's face in the second, however the backround is very nice.

In the first I enjoy the text, the border, and the thin look of it appeals to my personal tastes on sig demensions. The picture is not what I would have chosen, though, nor do I feel the statue was needed. The first also illistrates the theme better, although niether did it particularly well in that regard.

So, I voted pour teh 1stzorz.

[Sage]

k. Neither image conveys "deceit" to me. Like, at all. That said, the first sig outclasses the second in virtually every way (and, honestly, it wasn't exactly gorgeous, either.) Therefore, I voted for the first one. Both artists obviously have talent, but... it almost looked like you guys weren't even trying.

Sorry to sound so harsh, but I figure you'd rather have a real opinion than something wicked sugarcoated.

[Broli]

I voted for 1, even though I don't think either of you guys did a good job sticking to the theme. Also, the second's bluish layer is just nasty.

The first one also could have been better. I didn't like the brown, as it looked like someone had dropped mud on the sig. Also, I didn't like the statue, as I don't think anyone would have known what it was if you hadn't told us.

Good job to both of you.

[Burter Jr]

WINNER

18 TO 5

VEGETA

[Kazuya]

Originally posted by Yajirobe
I got pwned. =( You did a good job Vegeta.

I liked yours. How did you do that like color burny thingy?

[Hellfighter 17]

Originally posted by Yajirobe
I got pwned. =( You did a good job Vegeta.

If you didn't have the text, as Bra said, it would've been much better.