Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Revolution
#11
Eh, just to toss my 2 cents in this, Rei, but his writing doesn’t give me the impression of either of those two, and I’ve roleplayed with them both enough to recognize the style. And this guy is nowhere near it, lol.


OK, what I’m going to do is break this down bit by bit. I’ll point out sections and try to help you with grammar, things that could have been worded better, and footnotes, etc. I’m not claiming to be a Goddess of Grammar, but I always seem to pick up in other people’s writing what I blindly skim over in my own, lol. Hopefully this helps you out.

I haven’t read your previous writing, so pardon me if I’m a bit ignorant, lol.
Your first roleplay of this thread is what I’m going to pick at first. So without further ado….here we go.


Quote:The nomadic life had done nothing to tame him—he looked at himself every day, and all he saw was the same angry, unkempt young boy that had resorted to violence. And on his own sister, too; he felt horrible, and yet, nothing had changed. He had been here for months, living off the land, living alone, associating with no one but himself, and he noticed that he remained the same. It saddened him deeply. He had wanted to become different, to become a better person; but if God refused to let him, how could he refuse God’s wishes?

The young man of nineteen years lay in the grass, feeling the wind caressing his face like a woman’s touch; he could barely remember that feeling, but it was one of the few joyous feelings he had stored in memory, so it lingered. As the grass brushed his sides, he sat up, taking a look at where he was.
Ok, I see what you’re trying to get across in this section, but it’s a bit...the grammar is prodding me with a stick here. He’s a nomad, ok, and something’s happened to his sister. He’s 19 years old, and his past actions have given him cause to regret some things. He’s obviously spiritual, as per the reference to God. And he’s in the wilderness. That’s a lot of information squeezed into two paragraphs.

First off, and this isn’t really a rule so much as good practice, but you want to try to create his surroundings first and foremost. Writing fiction is like painting scenery. You’ve got to give your audience somewhere to go off of. Supporting details are key, here. You’ve got some, but it doesn’t really give me as vivid an image as say perhaps this:

Quote:Warm, mellow sunshine spilled its hazy beams over the wavy grass, caressing the weather-beaten skin of the young man that lay in the almost endless blanket of emerald blades. To the north, a fringe of trees held the field at bay, so thick was the foliage, that the heavenly light barely penetrated its heavy canopy. All around him was Mother Nature at work, weaving into her intricate tapestry the story of the nineteen year old man known as Julius.
As serene as his surroundings were, he couldn’t seem to lull into the gentle embrace that was offered him by his sacred God. He didn’t realize what a slap in the face this was to Him, for he had other things to distract him than the simplistic beauty that was given to him.
As you can see, we start with imagery. We paint our scene so we can place our reader there. Can’t you smell the scent of the wildflowers bending gently to the soft breeze? Feel the sunshine as it warms your face? Hear the birds singing deep in the forest? All of this is an irony to the storm that rages on within Julius. The outside may be utterly incomparable in its beauty, but the ugliness inside his head is what we need to bring to our reader afterwards.
The questions I am left with after reading this is what did he do to his sister? What did he regret? Its obviously stemmed off anger, but what did he do? Now, you don’t have to go into complete detail with what he did, but hint towards it, like, say, “he shouldn’t have hit her.” Or something similar. Physical violence always tends to bring out some sort of regret in people, and thus, would be logical for him to be the way he is.
Quote:He sat smack dab in the middle of the wilderness. Smack dab in the middle of the “wild Earth” as it was called. And he expected to be tamed? He really could be stupid sometimes.

I wanted to separate this part of that paragraph because it bothers me. Repetitiveness is the killer of good writing, and using ‘smackdab’ twice in the same paragraph doesn’t really make sense. Sure, he’s in the middle of the wilderness, we kind of got that when we established the above paragraph, painting the scene. What did he expect to be tamed, him or the Earth?

Quote:But he liked it here.

BAD BAD BAD. Starting a sentence off with “but” is always a bad idea, unless you can somehow work it in. This doesn’t do it. Who am I to preach, though, I do the same thing. XD However, you could have done this differently than starting with a preposition. “He had to admit, however, that he really liked it here.” Better?

Quote:Perhaps he was never meant to be the person he wished he could be. Perhaps he was always meant to be angry, violent, and revolutionary—it shocked him. As a child (add a comma here, there’s a pause), he had never even considered ending up like this. To him, this status, the status of being poor, homeless—a nomad—it was the lowest he could possible get on the social ladder.

But then, social aspects of life didn’t particularly matter to him anymore. Since he had injured his sister, he’d lost interest in associating with people. Before, he had had friends, enemies, lovers, and his sister; when he left after injuring her, he lost contact with everyone. He abandoned them with one wish: that they take care of Alice. And make sure she is better than he was. He knew they wouldn’t understand. But he could always try.
Again, ‘but’ is a bad way to start off a sentence, much less a paragraph. Try “Then again, the social aspects of life didn’t particularly matter to him anymore.” This part would have been good if joined to the end of the last paragraph, instead of separating it.

Now, you’ve established that he’s hurt his sister, but what did he do? Again, you got word repetitiveness, with ‘sister’ in the immediate paragraph. Perhaps you could have used her name here instead. The following segment wasn’t really that interesting, either.

“He had left with only one wish: that his baby sister would be cared for, and ensure she would be better off than he was. He knew they wouldn’t understand, but he could always try.” More interesting, yeah? Combining sentences is a great idea, as well.


Quote:It was true. He had been living on Earth for more than just a few months. In fact, it was closing in on a year now. But he had just begun to do something with his spare time. He had decided that, in the absence of something to rehabilitate him, he would improve himself physically and mentally. And that was when he had started training on what some of the warriors called “ki.” Harnessed energy. It had come almost naturally to him, and within a few weeks he had the ability to shape it to his will—within reason, of course. He knew he wasn’t that skilled with it yet, but he was progressing. He had also taken up hunting instead of scrounging for berries. The animals were his friends; but the animals were also his food. He needed them for sustenance.
What was true? Perhaps this sentence should have been cut out. A good rule to keep in mind is if it doesn’t add to the story, cut it out, and this sentence, and the one following it are prime examples. I really like your take on his discovering ki, however. In fact, the rest of the paragraph is pretty good. It was to the point, and contributed to the story.


Quote:It was at this thought that he heard the growl.

It came from somewhere around him, and he knew what it was, he just couldn’t find it—it was a bear. He had seen bears around his campsite many times before, but he’d never really had to fight one. But if it was threatening him or his supplies, then he supposed that bear-wrestling would be a good hobby to take up.

Ok, the first paragraph/sentence was well placed, although, you could have combined it with the following paragraph, as well. Watch this, I’m going to reword this to make it more interesting:

“It was at this thought that he heard it: the unmistakable growl of a bear. The scent was strong, acrid to his nose as Julius found himself frozen to the ground. It was close. His eyes widened in fear as he slowly turned his head, hoping that the bear wouldn’t be there, wishing it was only a product of his vivid imagination. As his eyes focused on the large animal, however, and saw the dried blood matted in its mahogany fur, he knew this wasn’t any mere daydream. This was real.”

You could still finish with another paragraph by appending the rest of the old one, and still make it interesting. Something that I fail to do quite often (and I’ve noticed a lot of writers here also tend to overlook) is sensory writing. The ultimate goal of fiction is to immerse your reader as much as possible into the story. Try to include something that will stimulate the senses, even smell. You don’t know how important this, as well as touch, sight, and hearing are to a story unless you’ve read a really good book and remember a certain scene so vividly that you could swear you were there.



Quote:It came from nowhere, as if it meant to attack; he knew that bears were more afraid of humans than humans were of bears, but this grizzly showed no signs of fear as it lunged from the shadows of trees around the clearing. The two fighters, both of the wilderness, grappled and fell onto the soft grass. It was almost cushioning for Julius, and he almost found himself enjoying this fight, until the bear lunged again, scraping his chest. He could feet the blood rolling fluidly from the wound, and pushed with all his strength at his attacker. But the bear would not yield. Julius’s strength was never the best; usually, he relied on speed and tactics. But when a very large bear is lying on top of you, you don’t really have much time for “tactics.”
Instead of using “it”, you could use some other noun, like “the beast emerged from the darkness of the forest, his eyes alight with fire as if it meant to attack at any given moment.” See what I did?

Quote:It all happened so fast, that there was really no time for Julius to realize what was going on. He punched, and the bear fell off of him; the fight continued for several more seconds, but after the punch, the bear seemed to get progressively weaker. It came and went, but the battle was turning quickly to his favor.

And in about five minutes, the bear was stunned just enough for Julius to grasp his dagger from his satchel and plunge it into the bear’s chest. And just like that, the battle was over—it was finished.

The bear was dead.

Try to cut back on using “it” so much, I guess that’s what I’m trying to say here. There’s nothing wrong with describing things instead of just pawning them off with a generic noun such as ‘it’. In some situations, it’s appropriate, but overall, I think this is something you’ve got to work on.


I’m sorry if I’ve sounded like an asshole here, but I really hope you’ve learned something, and can perhaps use it in the future. To recap everything I’m trying to get across:

-Work on your sensory descriptions. Involve as much as you can to paint as vivid a picture as you can.
-Don’t tell what happened, show what happened (this is also some good advice I was given when I started out). Words are your paint, the paper your canvas.
-Try to eliminate repetitive and unnecessary words/sentences. http://children.fictionfactor.com/articles/sparkle.html this has helped me, it has good tips that I think you would find really useful.

Overall, however, I got the point you were trying to convey. Its not as bad as you think, and you can only get better from this point onwards. Tomorrow or something I’ll do the second rp.

[Image: siggy2.jpg]

Vad: Found my dicks btw
Vad: *DISCS
Kaz: XD!!!!XDXDXD!!
Kaz: oh man
Kaz: that was an awesome typo!
Vad: I MEANT ROUND CYLINDRICAL THINGS
Kaz: XD XD XD
Kaz: HAHAHHHAHHHAHA

Reply


Messages In This Thread
Revolution - by Juno - 04-30-2008, 09:31 PM
Revolution - by Ashe - 05-01-2008, 05:39 AM
Revolution - by Juno - 05-01-2008, 09:32 PM
Revolution - by Ashe - 05-02-2008, 04:19 AM
Revolution - by Juno - 05-02-2008, 11:36 AM
Revolution - by Juno - 05-03-2008, 03:21 AM
Revolution - by Kazuya - 05-03-2008, 03:36 AM
Revolution - by Juno - 05-03-2008, 03:39 AM
Revolution - by Juno - 05-03-2008, 04:45 AM
Revolution - by Ashe - 05-03-2008, 05:26 AM
Revolution - by Kazuya - 05-03-2008, 07:15 AM
Revolution - by Juno - 05-03-2008, 01:51 PM
Revolution - by Juno - 05-03-2008, 06:12 PM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)