Why not? Are live actors any more real than an animation? They get dressed by other people, wear make-up applied by others, reading scripts that others wrote, showing emotions that they're told to, at times and places they have no control over. They're essentially flesh and bone puppets. I go back to George Lucas' complaint that Frank Oz's Yoda from 1983's The Return of the Jedi is just as valid a candidate for an acting award as anyone else.

