Mafia - Day Two

[John Doe]

I'm more inclined to agree with Whompt's logic. It doesn't make sense that you would be sheriff or doctor without even trying to add anything to the lynching discussion. If he were mafia, however, saying little to nothing would benefit his position.

Regardless of what I think, the fact is that, according to everyone else's logic, we should lynch somebody in this phase. Alex is suspicious by trying to not be suspicious, and offers the least amount of negative benefits if he turned out to be a townsfolk (he didn't really chat or discuss with the group, so it's not like we'd lose an active member). If we don't pick somebody soon, the phase will end with a no-lynch anyway.

Edit: lol I typed no-lunch first.

Edit 2: We have about 4 hours until the end of this phase, so if we're lynching somebody we got to do it now.