Waffia Day SEVEN

[Jonathan Meer]

Like you said, you're intelligent enough to spin shit so it doesn't look suspicious.

Which is to say, if I lie, you can be damned sure I'd come up with a better lie than that 'I am the Doktor and I protected myself every night lololol.'

You say you didn't want to put a target on yourself, even though by protecting yourself every night you have relatively little worry there. You worried that after going after you, they would then target Kraken, giving you the additional worry about who they'd kill. But, if you were the Doctor, you would already have that worry. I know I worried about it every night phase. Every night phase since Kraken revealed, I've protected him because no matter how useful I am, the Sheriff is WAY more useful. I would think you'd have done the same, had you been the Doctor as you say.

I gave my reasoning above for being very suspicious of Kaden. It's only when Raf did die and was confirmed as a sibling that I felt confident in his Sheriff-ness. Before that, it was too weird for my tastes. Still is damned weird.

I didn't want a target on myself as that would essentially nullify my power. Then I'd HAVE to protect myself thereafter. Or, try to second-guess the mafia and risk dying. Either way, I'd be of no use to Kaden, if he was the Sheriff. If I hadn't had so many suspicions about Kaden, I would have been protecting him all along, fuck my own potential death. But with my suspicion (I figured he could very well have been maf), there was no way I was wasting my heal on him; the only person I was pretty damn sure was legit was myself (well, and Jark, though her pardon thing seemed rather one-time-use).

If you had revealed when I did, and I had been lynched as Mafia, yes. It would have been tough deciding whether to protect yourself or Kraken. But part of the game is making tough decisions. And you would have brought the mafia down a member, given Kraken atleast one more shot to investigate someone, and given the town one less suspicious person to worry about. I mean, I've had people on the fence almost the entire game. That's worrying enough to me to want the person gone.

Again, I've already explained this; you're just trying to muddy up the waters.

You were pretty much guaranteed to die, until Jark saved you. A self-reveal would have been completely pointless.

If my self-reveal would cast suspicion on you (and after Jark's pardon and your apparent reprieve from suspicion the next day, I didn't see any reason to suppose it would work out for me), then I'm outed, and I still have no information on who's who (and am a target; I don't like being a target). Lest we forget, if you died and were revealed to be Mafia, the Mafia wouldn't have known that there was a Doctor at all, let alone that it was me. That lack of knowledge, too, shouldn't be underestimated (though, after my successful self-defense on night five, the first part of it went out the window).

As it stands, as far as I can see, we're in a perfect end-game. You're spun up into clear guilt; you've been investigated and you were shown to have a gun. EVEN ASSUMING there is an evidence-planter (and, again, for the sake of fairness, let's keep that on the table), it's very unlikely that you would have been targeted on that exact night. You gave no reason in the previous day to indicate you were a hot-ticket item for investigation.

Unfortunately, that perfect end-game is partially marred by Jarka's explanation-less vote.