Actually, the basic Mafia game doesn't have any neutrals, so Kaden was about right.
Edit: On that note, I also hate adding the Cult or similar things to a Mafia game. Both the Mafia and the Town have enough issues with winning without adding in a group that can reduce the ranks of the others while bolstering its own.
And you might say, "But if they target a Mafioso, then the whole thing is destroyed." But looking at the percentages throughout the game, the chance of actually picking on stays relatively low. Hell, they never even have a 50-50 chance.
Edit: On that note, I also hate adding the Cult or similar things to a Mafia game. Both the Mafia and the Town have enough issues with winning without adding in a group that can reduce the ranks of the others while bolstering its own.
And you might say, "But if they target a Mafioso, then the whole thing is destroyed." But looking at the percentages throughout the game, the chance of actually picking on stays relatively low. Hell, they never even have a 50-50 chance.