These are pretty cool animoose, I suppose

[Anzekay]

Alright, Tryg, I ended up with this list for this season. This is stuff that made it past the 3 episode trial.

Guilty Crown
Kyoukai Senjou no Horizon
Last Exile, Fam The Silver Wing,
Persona 4 the animation
UN-GO
Ben-To
Mirai Nikki
Chihayafuru
Boku Ha Tomodachi Ga Sukunai
Tamayura hitotose
Shana 3
C3
Fate/Zero

Some are going better than others, some are inconsistant (C3, Guilty Crown, Last Exile), some I have no fucking idea what is going on (Horizon) but are still good. I'm not sure what your tastes are like so some of that list may not be for you.

As for last season, you absolutely have to check out:
Mawaru Penguindrum (this show is ongoing and absolutely incredible)
Usagi Drop
Kamisama Dolls

Other than that I watched
Ikoku Meiro no Croisee
Dantalian no Shoka
No.6 (this show was pretty damn good until the last two episodes, which bombed and pissed me off so bad).
The Idolmaster (ongoing, I'm way behind at like episode 8, it was okay so far but I've heard very good things about it later on)
Kamisama no Memochou
and the guilty enjoyment of Yuru Yuri which is like 1/3 awkward, 1/3 clever, 1/3 hilarious.