02-13-2012, 01:24 AM
If we are to lynch, we should definitely stick with the one we're most sure of. I don't think we should just all gang up on someone with no shred of evidence.
I'm going to go over possible outcomes here if Greg is major bullshitting, but really the worst case scenario is he's a Joker. His job is to get lynched. When you kill a Joker, he randomly takes one person in the game with him and we lose three people in one go because we lynch based on his call, then we kill him to get payback, then he kills one of us. That's not counting for the mafia who will take a fourth and if they have a kill power ready, we're utter fucked at about five straight up kills in two rounds.
It could also just be hyper aggressive mafia. If the mafia has some sort of post mortem power, like the Karthus one, with this few people, we could also be dramatically fucked because Greg will have earned our trust and he will be able, with good roleplaying skills, to call out shots for people he dislikes as the game goes on and we'll believe him because we have no other investigative role.
In summary: shit.
I'm going to go over possible outcomes here if Greg is major bullshitting, but really the worst case scenario is he's a Joker. His job is to get lynched. When you kill a Joker, he randomly takes one person in the game with him and we lose three people in one go because we lynch based on his call, then we kill him to get payback, then he kills one of us. That's not counting for the mafia who will take a fourth and if they have a kill power ready, we're utter fucked at about five straight up kills in two rounds.
It could also just be hyper aggressive mafia. If the mafia has some sort of post mortem power, like the Karthus one, with this few people, we could also be dramatically fucked because Greg will have earned our trust and he will be able, with good roleplaying skills, to call out shots for people he dislikes as the game goes on and we'll believe him because we have no other investigative role.
In summary: shit.
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

