LoM2 - Day Two

[Kaden]

Honestly, I don't really like how this is playing out. It's turning into a situation of the loudest people being the rightest.

Would have responded to Rose's post earlier, but was busy until just now.

I honestly don't believe Rose. I find it unlikely that he's a character that was used in the last game with the exact same power. More unlikely that he just happens to uncover a mafia and that Doe instantly believes him. What seems more likely to me is that Doe and Rose are both mafia and Rose decided to just play out a character that had already been used to try and gain trust.

I'm not saying that's the case, I'm just saying that seems more likely, to me, than someone having a duplicate ability that sniffs out a mafia at random.

I get the whole "well just vote for Keiko and we'll know if Rose is legit" logic, but that's a huge risk, at this point. If we assume there are three mafia then we're at 6 townspeople. If Rose is bluffing, we lynch an innocent, go to 5, they kill someone during the night, we're down to 4 and then it's basically a perfect game for them at 4v3.

Giving mafia an extra night absolutely isn't ideal, either. =\