I'm going to fill in what Mal probably meant to say:
Let's examine what we know about John Doe. It's possible that none of what he posted is reliable, but whatevs.
We can assume that he is not the doctor, because he asked for doctor protection. That eliminates a possibility, so as there are three mafia people, there is a ~33% chance that he's a mafia player, an ~11% chance that he's the vigilante, an ~11% chance that he's a sheriff, and a ~45% chance that he's a townsperson.
He said he is a person the town cannot afford to lose, so let's assume that he's not a townsperson. He's either the vigilante, the sheriff, or a mafia player. Honestly, we could afford to lose either non-mafia role if it meant taking out a mafia person. If he IS a townsperson, we'd at least have more to go on.
Considering that we literally have nothing else to go on...lynch John Doe.
Let's examine what we know about John Doe. It's possible that none of what he posted is reliable, but whatevs.
We can assume that he is not the doctor, because he asked for doctor protection. That eliminates a possibility, so as there are three mafia people, there is a ~33% chance that he's a mafia player, an ~11% chance that he's the vigilante, an ~11% chance that he's a sheriff, and a ~45% chance that he's a townsperson.
He said he is a person the town cannot afford to lose, so let's assume that he's not a townsperson. He's either the vigilante, the sheriff, or a mafia player. Honestly, we could afford to lose either non-mafia role if it meant taking out a mafia person. If he IS a townsperson, we'd at least have more to go on.
Considering that we literally have nothing else to go on...lynch John Doe.
![[Image: SophiaRetro.jpg]](http://rpnexus.com/sig/miscsig/SophiaRetro.jpg)
And tell me where is the love
In what your prophet has said?
Man, It sounds to me just like
A prison for the walking dead.