Ye Olde Mafia - End

[Sophia]

Killing Doe was obviously a mistake, but only because he wasn't mafia and I tore away from my initial cautious strategy. I honestly did about as much as I could to hint that I was the vigilante, especially last night, but...well, it is what it is.

There's nothing wrong with the strategy employed by a majority of the townspeople, but you have to know its limits, especially when the name of the game is manipulating other people. You also have to realize that it's not the only strategy. Tyr bandwagoned the whole time and we probably should have seen through it, but a majority of the people who jumped on random lynches were townspeople. In retrospect, the "caution vs. aggression" debate was the main theme of this game, but the people who tried to "gotcha" random lynchers muddled the whole situation. Again, nothing wrong with that tactic, but confusion is going to be a byproduct. All in all, like Rose said, we were mainly just unlucky.

Also, I don't really blame 17 for protecting Mal. Considering the circumstances, it was probably the best move to protect his role.