Ye Olde Mafia - End

[Ashe]

The first night I investigated Kaden, just to go ahead and get it out of the way. I did not want to have my opinions of things possibly mislead from the start if Kaden was a mafia.

My second night was almost a Mal investigation, but the way Sophia was posting, I had the feeling SOMETHING was up. I wasn't sure what though, so I investigated him and found him to be the vigilante. I re-evaluated what he'd said and that solidified a Mal Night 3 check that never happened.

In hindsight, I'm actually surprised no one suspected Mal on Night 3 after I died. He stated at one point that the position I was in on his "suspicion list" would have been Waffuru had Waff not been killed, and after I died I realized that meant he had placed us as equally needing to go, if he were mafia. I posted to at least get the consideration out for people to look in to (the post Mal quoted of mine, under his bolded part) but it didn't really seem to get much attention. I had tried to strongly hint that Kaden was a non-suspect on Day 2, but he still had a lot of fingers pointed at him, and that's largely due to one person.

I feel that Doe pretty much hurt us with his plays. He feels that he was being loud to be a target, but he was pretending to be Sheriff which caused the town to give more credibility to HIS suspicions and ignore my attempts to be subtle in clearing people (I figured I'd die before I could say much, so I wanted to have things posted for players to review after I died - instead, people kept pointing at Kaden). By pretending he was Sheriff (he kept saying "HINT HINT JUST KILL KADEN" and asking for doctor protection), I think that killed my chances of doing any kind of reveal without having a confirmed mafia. Without a mafia to lynch that day, it would be my word against Doe's and he was demanding protection, which would have the mafia simply kill me instead, in that scenario. So I didn't really like that play.