03-05-2013, 12:59 PM
That's random, though thinking on it I suppose it makes sense. So we've got a rough situation. We don't know about Dehan, though of the powers listed, it still seems he's the most likely candidate for mafia. I would call Kayne guaranteed town (or godfather type role). I'm the doctor, though obviously you guys have reason to take that with a grain of salt. I can't really do anything to prove it to you guys given the nature of my role.
So if there is one other, its between (at least for me, given that I am the only person in our group that can 100% rule me out, just like each of you can rule yourself out) Teemer or Doe for the liar, if Dehan is not a solo mafia member. Which is entirely possible, I suppose, given the two lives thing (perhaps counts as two mafia or something) but I'm not sure that's the route they'd take. I think Teemer's power (and some of his posts) are the most suspect of the two, honestly, but I give Doe more credit on the hitlist targets (King B was a pretty safe kill for them since the double vote is pretty dangerous out of the remaining powers and I'm going to be protecting myself).
What was Kayne's power again? I don't remember and don't feel like looking through, so enjoy this stream of thought.
Thinking on it... Of the powers of King B (double vote) and Doe (forced lynch)... Why was Doe not the target? I'd call his the more dangerous. This is all over the place, but actually given the powers, I think I'm the most skeptical about Doe and Teemer, with Dehan actually being town (I don't see why a mafia would have this ability, and the others could just be lying about their own). I still remember Doe pushing hardcore to get the Sheriff lynched after his reveal with Teemer being the final vote to seal the deal after we started looking like we realized it wasn't a great idea to lynch our Sheriff.
I think Teemer is the most likely mafia candidate and I think that Doe is also a mafia (at this point in time) and lying about their powers. Dehan's power doesn't make sense for a mafia, Kayne has been validated by Mal, and I know I'm not (which leaves the onus on you to now accuse me and try to act like one of the other dead roles are some kind of doctor). I would do the "Wart was the main bad guy of Mario 2" routine but that's just bad logic because we already know that if Wart is also mafia, its entirely just coincidence and not intended to be a give away.
Lynch Teemer
So if there is one other, its between (at least for me, given that I am the only person in our group that can 100% rule me out, just like each of you can rule yourself out) Teemer or Doe for the liar, if Dehan is not a solo mafia member. Which is entirely possible, I suppose, given the two lives thing (perhaps counts as two mafia or something) but I'm not sure that's the route they'd take. I think Teemer's power (and some of his posts) are the most suspect of the two, honestly, but I give Doe more credit on the hitlist targets (King B was a pretty safe kill for them since the double vote is pretty dangerous out of the remaining powers and I'm going to be protecting myself).
What was Kayne's power again? I don't remember and don't feel like looking through, so enjoy this stream of thought.
Thinking on it... Of the powers of King B (double vote) and Doe (forced lynch)... Why was Doe not the target? I'd call his the more dangerous. This is all over the place, but actually given the powers, I think I'm the most skeptical about Doe and Teemer, with Dehan actually being town (I don't see why a mafia would have this ability, and the others could just be lying about their own). I still remember Doe pushing hardcore to get the Sheriff lynched after his reveal with Teemer being the final vote to seal the deal after we started looking like we realized it wasn't a great idea to lynch our Sheriff.
I think Teemer is the most likely mafia candidate and I think that Doe is also a mafia (at this point in time) and lying about their powers. Dehan's power doesn't make sense for a mafia, Kayne has been validated by Mal, and I know I'm not (which leaves the onus on you to now accuse me and try to act like one of the other dead roles are some kind of doctor). I would do the "Wart was the main bad guy of Mario 2" routine but that's just bad logic because we already know that if Wart is also mafia, its entirely just coincidence and not intended to be a give away.
Lynch Teemer

