07-29-2007, 07:15 PM
Weaksauce.
Some of the deaths were too quick, I mean Tonks, Lupin and Fred. Fred had least some part in the story where as Lupin and Tonks only appeared briefly and then suddenly they were dead. You literally go from one scene to the next and poof they are dead- zero meaning.
And Dumbledore, single biggest douche of the year award for him. Secrets within secrets which really should have cost Harry his life had it not been for the total Deus ex Machina of being a fuckin' horcrux.
And the elder wand, how the fuck did that work out? How do you come to the conclusion that it was Draco who defeated Dumbledore when all he did was disarm Dumbledore before Snape came and killed him. If disarming was all you needed to do, then everyones wand would act shitty after Expelliarmus, don't even get me started in the poor logic of stealing one wand from someone and getting complete loyalty out of every wand related to that person.
Also, the whole camping and arguing, that went on way too long, instead of spending a good third of the book on that they could have done a bit more with the character development and maybe spent half a paragraph for Tonks and Lupin's death instead of having them as an after note.
Some of the deaths were too quick, I mean Tonks, Lupin and Fred. Fred had least some part in the story where as Lupin and Tonks only appeared briefly and then suddenly they were dead. You literally go from one scene to the next and poof they are dead- zero meaning.
And Dumbledore, single biggest douche of the year award for him. Secrets within secrets which really should have cost Harry his life had it not been for the total Deus ex Machina of being a fuckin' horcrux.
And the elder wand, how the fuck did that work out? How do you come to the conclusion that it was Draco who defeated Dumbledore when all he did was disarm Dumbledore before Snape came and killed him. If disarming was all you needed to do, then everyones wand would act shitty after Expelliarmus, don't even get me started in the poor logic of stealing one wand from someone and getting complete loyalty out of every wand related to that person.
Also, the whole camping and arguing, that went on way too long, instead of spending a good third of the book on that they could have done a bit more with the character development and maybe spent half a paragraph for Tonks and Lupin's death instead of having them as an after note.

