Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Gay Marriage Test Debate: Vi/Luci vs HF/20
#7
I found Lucifer's claims at the end of his argument to be quite interesting as well. To quote him, "complete nonsense, but interesting." Except I wouldn't say that his argument is "complete" nonsense. Just partial nonsense, if that is possible. I feel the need to clear up this whole issue of what I mean by separation of church and state.

But first, I need to point out the errors in your accusations, Lucifer.

Quote:Originally posted by Lucifer
Your country is THE worst example of separation of church and state I have EVER seen in my entire life.

You see, I find that sort of funny, in a way. It's your opinion to believe so, but I hope that you do not believe it to be fact. Because that is quite an unfounded accusation you made, one that I'm afraid I'm going to do my best to prove wrong.

Let's take a look back in time, shall we?

Now, I am aware that many of you all are not from America. However, I believe that if you are from Great Britain, you will be aware of this piece of history. If you would recall the Puritans that came from Britain, who were upset with the Church of England, and wished to "purify" it, hence their name. They left England due to the fact that they were being persecuted by the government for being against the Church of England, especially the Separatists, a radical group of Puritans that wished to break all ties with the Church of England, the same group of people that came to America on the Mayflower, the Pilgrims. They left England escaping the interference of the government in the matters of the Church, which England had been continually doing, ever since the English King Henry VIII separated ties with the Catholic Church for not allowing him to annul his marriage.

Now, I could continue to bore you with more references of American history, such as the founding of Rhode Island, the founding of Penslyvania, and other such events, but I'm going to skip straight through the Revolutionary War and reach the Constitution and the Bill of Rights.

Google it if you aren't familiar with it. It's the ammendment that most people here simply assume to be "freedom of speech." However, here's how the very first ammendment to the Constitution reads:

"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof"

Right there is the entire basis of what I'm getting at. I don't care how much our current president allows his personal religious convictions to get in the way and make it appear that the Church and State are not separated. The Executive Branch cannot make laws. Only Congress can. And the Bill of Rights, one of our most cherished documents that guarantees us our civil liberties and the right to debate something such as the right of gay marriage, says that Congress cannot pass a law that would interfere with religion.

America, while to many may appear to be heavily swayed by religion, simply cannot be on the legal level. The document that our country is defined upon prohibits this. And even if Congress were to bypass this ammendment, the wonderful system of checks and balances would step in. The Judicial Branch would step in and declare such a law "unconstitutional."

What the Executive Branch says or does will have no effect on the separation of Church and State. While lately he has gained more power than a president likely should, he is still incapable of passing laws without consent of Congress and the approval of the Judicial Branch.

So, please, explain to me where our country has become a terrible excuse for separation of Church and State, if you would. I fail to see it. Marriage is a religious ceremony, as I stated before. The government cannot interfere.

Quote:Originally posted by Lucifer
Natural selection is about passing on genes. The strongest of a species will be the ones who will live long enough to breed, to pass on their strong genes to the next generation, increasing the strength of the general population.

I very much agree with you here. That is exactly the idea of natural selection. Now tell me how is it that genes are passed on again? Ah yes, when half the DNA of a father fuses with half the DNA of the mother, when the sperm fuses with the egg. And I'm afraid that two males and two females just aren't capable of doing that. Thus, how can a species continue to evolve if they can't reproduce? Just thought I should pose that question to you.

Quote:Originally posted by Lucifer
Do you honestly think those benefits are simply for procreation purposes? You should probably take a good look at them. You'll see that ANYONE would benefit from them.

Of course they would. Most people would of course. However, the majority of benefits awarded to parents with children would not. The IRS has stated that a parent may claim up to $1,000 in tax credit per child based on economic situations. Also, the HM Revenue and Customs Reserve also offers benefits to having children through the Working Tax Credit, variable on economic status and the status of the children.

Can homosexual couples have children? Not unless they adopt. But if they adopt, it's not furthering the advancement of the human race, according to evolution. So, as Hellfighter stated, should the government encourage something that goes against what is more suitable for the human race?

I feel I need to stop there though, I've made this long enough as it is. I'll leave it to my opponents to refute what I've said in response to their claims.
[Image: Ruhiel.png]
Reply


Messages In This Thread
Gay Marriage Test Debate: Vi/Luci vs HF/20 - by Ruhiel - 06-21-2006, 09:27 PM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)