Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Gay Marriage Test Debate: Vi/Luci vs HF/20
#9
Quote:Originally posted by Lucifer
Well, for my definition of homosexuality I used the Oxford English Dictionary, the most complete archive of the modern English language in existance. You used... Wikipedia? Forgive me for not finding your superbly credible sources all that credible. So let's ignore your Wikipedia quotes, because I certainly don't deem them suitable for this argument.
Okay? I was talking about the fact that you said sexual orientation was natural, as in you are born into it. I wa sin now way refuting your definition as it closely matches the one I received from the Encyclop?dia Brittanica, "Sexual interest in and attraction to members of one's own sex." So it appears we are on the same page, at least on the definition of homosexuality.

Quote:Originally posted by Lucifer
Of course, by natural, I don't mean that homosexuality is in our genetic makeup, because it's not. Very few things are. It's not in our genetic makeup to build houses. Or to be monogomous. We do it anyway. Marriage is a human condition. Invented by humans. It's not a natural ceremony that people suddenly become suitable for.
Okay. Glad to know you know.

Quote:Originally posted by Lucifer
You talk about evolution, Hellfighter. I'm assuming you're talking about Darwin's theory of evolution by natural selection. Survival of the fittest, evolution of the fittest, as it were.

I'm afraid you shot yourself in the foot with that one.

Natural selection is about passing on genes. The strongest of a species will be the ones who will live long enough to breed, to pass on their strong genes to the next generation, increasing the strength of the general population.

You appear to have established your argument around homosexuality being psychological. Therefore it has no bearing on evolution whatsoever I'm afraid. So we'll ignore that section of your argument, shall we?
Well, I won't be, but you can ignore me showing how badly you didn't comprehend what I was saying.

I said that homosexuality itself is something that is prenatal, my argument for that being encompassed by this passage in Encyclop?dia Brittanica

Quote:Encyclop?dia Brittanica
In addition, their study covered an unusual case of intersexuality betwene chromosomal twins... The gender identity and gender role (that is, the person's personal sense of masculinity or femininity and behavioral manifestations) that developed were compatible with the sex rearing regardless of the genetic and prenatal classification. At puberty these indiviudals were generally attracted to the sex opposite of their sex or rearing. The conclusions of these studies suggested that sexual orientationis is primarily established in postnatal experiences.
I just wnated to solidifiy that point.

Now to move on. I was using evolution about homosexual marriage. I don't want to have to point out what we are actually debating here, again. If two males have sex or two females have sex, do they procreate? I do believe that the likely outcome will be no. Thus, how can they further the evolution of the human race to be more accustomed to its surroundings; it may be essential that we do one day, and if the government endroses homosexuality, I think if the race hits a bad spot, then we could all be doomed.

Quote:Originally posted by Lucifer
Now, let's answer your next point. The marriage benefits. Only needed for couples to procreate and raise children?

"Hello, my name's Fred. I'm gay, meaning I don't need social security."

"Hi, my name's Lisa, I'm a lesbian, so I'm never going to get ill enough to need medicare."

"Hi, I'm Elijah, I'm a homosexual, so money comes easily to me. I don't want any benefits."

"I'm Eleanor. I'm a lesbian and I work for a large company. I don't mind when married couples get benefits which I don't within the workplace because they deserve the extra money and the car for when they decide to have children ten or twenty years down the line."

"I'm George. I'm gay, so I love everything. Especially my ridiculously high income tax from which I will recieve no deductions. *huggles*"

Realistic? I think not.

Do you honestly think those benefits are simply for procreation purposes? You should probably take a good look at them. You'll see that ANYONE would benefit from them.

But, we're forgetting, most homosexual persons don't want marriage legalized just for these benefits.
'Cause there are no other kinds of benefits out there. They should be an encouragement to advance the human race. I'm not claiming any 'Keep the arians purified,' just have it so that if anythign bad happens, we can actually continue to live and that those that woudl be born and become homosexual may live a happy life rather than not become.

Quote:Originally posted by Lucifer
They want a legal recognition of their partnership and their love.
'Kay. Call it a 'civil union' and and that's it. Nothing else. They will just get a paper and will have the chance to appear in civil union court.

Quote:Originally posted by Lucifer
As for your attack on Violet's comment regarding the human and penguin; Obviously it would be acceptable if Penguins could communicate their consent with us. But, we're not addressing inter-species relationships. We're addressing relationships between two human beings. Something we all seem rapidly ready to forgtet.
Many people claim to be able to talk to animals. They say the duck gave them a "Hell, yea!" in their native tongue. Good to go? Also, I find the last sentence ironic. IYou have argued the wrong point about letting homosexuals be homosexuals rather than whetehr they shoudl abe able to marry or not several times. I was trying to draw on a metaphor which I would with a response that was more intelligible.

Quote:Originally posted by Lucifer
I'd like to stick to the topic of animals for a moment though, and re-address HF's initial comment about homosexuality being something unnatural, rather something recieved.

http://endo.endojournals.org/cgi/content.../145/2/478

A fascinating article. I hope you take the time to read it.

"these results suggest that naturally occurring variations in sexual partner preferences may be related to differences in brain anatomy and capacity for estrogen synthesis."

Now, this is far from scientific fact, but it's a tad better than Wikipedia.

My point stands.
Yea, read about that on Wikipedia. I won;t deny that it doe snot have any impact, but its significance is most likely not too large. There are other prenatal factors along with manymore postnatal factors.
"We're just two lost souls swimming in a fish bowl."
[Image: HFSeventeen.jpg]
Reply


Messages In This Thread
Gay Marriage Test Debate: Vi/Luci vs HF/20 - by Hellfighter 17 - 06-23-2006, 01:33 AM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)