Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Gay Marriage Test Debate: Vi/Luci vs HF/20
#10
Quote:Originally posted by Hellfighter 17
Do you feel the same way about inter-species sexual relations, such as those between an adult female penguin and an adult female human? If it makes the person happy, what is the harm, using your definition?

How does homosexuality go to branch on to animals? We?re not talking about other animals, we are talking about human beings. I know that there are people out there that have beastiality tendencies, but that branch of humans will always be humans, and animals will never be recognized as humans. Homosexuals are humans.

This also raises another question, for something so personal, why is it such a public controversy? Why not make women who?s menstrual cycles are fucked up a popular controversy? Oh! Look! She has fucked up cycles! She can?t procreate!! =\


Quote:Originally posted by Android 20
"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof"

Right there is the entire basis of what I'm getting at. I don't care how much our current president allows his personal religious convictions to get in the way and make it appear that the Church and State are not separated. The Executive Branch cannot make laws. Only Congress can. And the Bill of Rights, one of our most cherished documents that guarantees us our civil liberties and the right to debate something such as the right of gay marriage, says that Congress cannot pass a law that would interfere with religion

And yet, it is an unavoidable fact that both religion and the US government, although it is heavily denied, are entwined. ?Legally married?. Lets look at that. ?Legally? meaning by law. Government=Law. For many things in this country, you have to be ?Legally Married? to be recognized by the government, as HF had said, for benefits. But also, lets look at another perspective: serious injury or death.

What was to happen if two homosexuals, one without a family, and one with a family, were to get together, and one of them, the one without the family, was to get into a serious accident and be mortally wounded? He?s on life support, and he doesn?t have a will dictating whether he should remain on life support or not. Usually in these instances, the next of kin would be notified as to what to do next. The partner in this case, would be the next of kin, if everything were to be factored that way. As a legality, only the next of kin could make the decision for the comatose/mortally wounded person. And thus, the partner wouldn?t be recognized. Our friend would be left on life support, suffering until he died naturally. Where is the justice in that?

Deny it or not, it doesn?t matter how pretty the words are, but religion and government ARE NOT SEPARATE. Marriage would be such a case, as both the Church and Government recognize it.

When you do your taxes, you have an option on there for spouses. Spouses=partner. Spouse= Marriage. Church=marriage=government. You see where I am getting at here?

Quote:Originally posted by Hellfighter 17
-Insurance benefits through a spouse's employer
-Insurance discounts offered to married couples and related persons living in
same household
-Government benefits such as Social Security and Medicare
-Income tax deductions, credits and exemptions
-Payment of wages for deceased partners and worker's compensation benefits
-Company benefits/perks offered to spouses
-Commercial discounts/incentives offered only to married couples or families

These are some examples taken from christiangays.com (I will admit the source may seem odd for the position I am taking, but people have been known to fuel their opposition) of some breaks for marriage couples. These seem to me be benefits for married couple so that they can procreate and supply for their children. I will admit that some couples do not have children, but a majority do if they are given sufficient time to do so. About two-thirds of all births happened in wedlock in 1990 in the US according to answers.com. Of cours ethis statistics is variable across the globe, but it would most likely lower as you go east.

So?let me get this straight. Even though homosexuals are human beings and citizens of their respective country (As used in my example, the US.) they aren?t entitled to any benefits just because they are gay? Homosexuality is a personal decision, albeit natural.

Let me give you a personal example. My uncle Toby and his lover, whom I respectfully addressed as Uncle David. Before they were together, and before they had the courage to ?come out of the closet? both men had led heterosexual lives. Why? Because back in those days, it was frowned upon to be homosexual. It was taboo, shall I say. If anyone remembers the Matthew Sheppard case, where the college student was hazed and killed just because he was gay, or the Teena Brandon case, you will see what I am talking about.

Instead of risking their lives just so they can live an honest life as two homosexual men, they decided to force themselves to lead heterosexual lives. My uncle Toby had two children, David had three, and was even married. Both led homosexual relationships even inside marriage, because they were, in fact, not heterosexuals, and were trying to do what felt right to them.

The times had begun to change about homosexuals, and it was becoming socially acceptable for them to make their appearances into society as homosexual beings, and they finally came out. Both men began to pursue their homosexual lives, leading relationships with other men and so forth. They were finally free to do what they thought was right to them all along, without all the major degradation from society.

Toby met up with a guy named Roger, I still call him uncle, he was a bisexual. These two were in love, and would have gotten married if it were legal. They were together for several years, and helped out my mother after she left my father. (She left him because he physically and mentally abused her, and even though I was real young at the time, I remember quite a bit, he used to do this shit in front of me and my little brother. You can?t shake those memories.) But anyways, back to topic, they helped my mother get her a place, furniture, and helped provide clothing and other necessities out of the kindness of their hearts for my mother and us kids.

Time had passed, and they got into a fight (Toby and Roger) and my uncle, in a rage, went off to the local bar to cool down, where a few of his friends had worked. Another gay man came up, and off they went, and several months later, one of the friends over heard the guy that my uncle slept with, bragging about how the guy went around purposefully infecting others with HIV. He went to go get tested, and sure enough, he had it. This was almost 14 years ago.

Moving on, Toby and David eventually got together, and had it not been illegal, they would have married. They were together up until oh, 1996, a few months before David died. He didn?t have insurance, and had Hep C, and AIDS, and couldn?t afford the medicine necessary to keep himself out of pain. He committed suicide. I remember him being in pain from these diseases, but he hid it well. Had he and Toby been married, they would have both been able to benefit from my uncle?s insurance, and perhaps have been treated, and be with us today.

Toby died in 1997, he still had insurance, and up until a month before his death, was doing fine, save for being weakened from chemo for colon cancer, which he had thankfully, overcome by chemo. In the end, if gay marriage had been legal, both would have benefited from the shared benefits that came with marriage, such as the insurance, the same that would have been for any straight couple.

My whole point being, why should married gays be denied the same benefits as married heterosexual couples just because they are gay?

If you guys didn?t get the point of the personal story, reread it, and if you STILL don?t get it, you seriously need to do some research.

Quote:Originally posted by Android 20
Can homosexual couples have children? Not unless they adopt. But if they adopt, it's not furthering the advancement of the human race, according to evolution. So, as Hellfighter stated, should the government encourage something that goes against what is more suitable for the human race?

You know, there are millions of children out there that need to be adopted, and many heterosexual couples don?t take the initiative to give them homes, so why not let a loving homosexual couple adopt them, give them a home and two loving parents, and let them grow up with a family? Seriously, you don?t know what kind of life it is like for an orphan, what they would GIVE just to be in some type of family, other than in a group home. I have had several friends who were with foster parents, and even though some of their foster families were horrible wretched monsters, they would rather take that than go back to a group home. There are many homosexual couples that would be glad to take in children and raise them with as much love as any heterosexual couple could give. To tell truth, the Earth has an overcrowded population, so perhaps this is just nature?s way of saying that we need to slow the fuck down on procreation?

The human race won?t be going into endangerment anytime soon, rest assured. There are over 6 billion humans on this planet today, and unless some massive asteroid comes barreling from space, propulsion of our species will go on until some natural disaster happens and fucks up our environment so bad, that stasis won?t be able to support life, in which case, all living things will be screwed.
[Image: visigjune08_v2.jpg]

Fuck you, Photobucket.
Reply


Messages In This Thread
Gay Marriage Test Debate: Vi/Luci vs HF/20 - by Violet - 06-25-2006, 12:03 AM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)