05-26-2007, 02:06 PM
I am... mixed. I liked it for sure. It was epic, but there were a few things that irked me. I shall list them, because I like lists.
1) Multiple Jacks. Even if the brain line was one of the funniest it still didn't redeem it for me. Praps if they just didn't have the tiny ones, and had them big all the time it wouldn't be back. Otherwise its just sort of a jarring experience, taking you out of immersion. And yes I know its because Jack was cracking up.
2) Calypso. Something just didn't sit right. It might be the fact it was the voodoo woman. Were there hints to it in the second movie?
3) Sextuple double crossing. A POTC staple to be sure. But at some point enough is enough. I followed it fine, but complexity a good plot does not make. Not to say the plot was bad, just I think it could have been more clever without quite as much betrayal.
That said I really did enjoy it. This irks may disappear on the second watching.
1) Multiple Jacks. Even if the brain line was one of the funniest it still didn't redeem it for me. Praps if they just didn't have the tiny ones, and had them big all the time it wouldn't be back. Otherwise its just sort of a jarring experience, taking you out of immersion. And yes I know its because Jack was cracking up.
2) Calypso. Something just didn't sit right. It might be the fact it was the voodoo woman. Were there hints to it in the second movie?
3) Sextuple double crossing. A POTC staple to be sure. But at some point enough is enough. I followed it fine, but complexity a good plot does not make. Not to say the plot was bad, just I think it could have been more clever without quite as much betrayal.
That said I really did enjoy it. This irks may disappear on the second watching.
Sinners make the best Saints
![[Image: tobiasyu5.jpg]](http://img261.imageshack.us/img261/5609/tobiasyu5.jpg)