12-28-2006, 11:02 PM
'Kay, seems like staff are ready to return to this argument, so, after a short hiatus (now with the information I needed from the other thread), let's continue. *Shuffles papers*
I'm sure we're all familiar with the term Pebble Logic by now. In other words, a force combined is greater than the same amount of force separated up into chunks. The current system of Body Split seeks to compensate for that by making clones stronger.
However, there is one thing that was made clear for me in the other thread, and that is that Body Split is intended to be a powerup. Even with Pebble Logic factored in, the clones should still be able to beat an opponent stronger than their own, original, un-split form. This is according to Waffuru, and backed up by Raditzu's claims that my numbers were off.
I don't understand this. Firstly, Body Split is a common technique, not a powerup. It can be achieved very easily when compared to other techniques, and especially other multipliers.
Secondly, I think people are failing to factor in the non-numerical advantages of the split. It can be assumed that each body acts independently, and can react to dangers without a mental cue the 'real' split-ee. This gives a massive advantage in itself. There is also the fact that attacks can come from multiple directions instead of just one. It's a lot easier to dodge one kamehameha than it is to dodge four. If you need to complete two tasks at once (disarming a bomb whilst protecting the president from Changelings) you can also do that.
Why, then, does Body Split need an additional advantage in the form of being a multiplier? As I said before, it's classed as a 'decent' technique - on the lowest level, from what I can tell. Its strength, like most techniques, comes from battle versatility - it opens more options for strategy, and just plain lets you do more things.
Body Split isn't 'useless' because of this. If you're going to call Body Split useless, you may as well throw every non-powerup technique besides Fusion in there as well. Metal Binding offers no statistical advantaged. Neither do the kinesises, shapechange, telepathy, or any of the others. What do they offer? Versatility. I don't see why Body Split, a common technique that already offers a number of cool advantages, should be any exception.
I'm sure we're all familiar with the term Pebble Logic by now. In other words, a force combined is greater than the same amount of force separated up into chunks. The current system of Body Split seeks to compensate for that by making clones stronger.
However, there is one thing that was made clear for me in the other thread, and that is that Body Split is intended to be a powerup. Even with Pebble Logic factored in, the clones should still be able to beat an opponent stronger than their own, original, un-split form. This is according to Waffuru, and backed up by Raditzu's claims that my numbers were off.
I don't understand this. Firstly, Body Split is a common technique, not a powerup. It can be achieved very easily when compared to other techniques, and especially other multipliers.
Secondly, I think people are failing to factor in the non-numerical advantages of the split. It can be assumed that each body acts independently, and can react to dangers without a mental cue the 'real' split-ee. This gives a massive advantage in itself. There is also the fact that attacks can come from multiple directions instead of just one. It's a lot easier to dodge one kamehameha than it is to dodge four. If you need to complete two tasks at once (disarming a bomb whilst protecting the president from Changelings) you can also do that.
Why, then, does Body Split need an additional advantage in the form of being a multiplier? As I said before, it's classed as a 'decent' technique - on the lowest level, from what I can tell. Its strength, like most techniques, comes from battle versatility - it opens more options for strategy, and just plain lets you do more things.
Body Split isn't 'useless' because of this. If you're going to call Body Split useless, you may as well throw every non-powerup technique besides Fusion in there as well. Metal Binding offers no statistical advantaged. Neither do the kinesises, shapechange, telepathy, or any of the others. What do they offer? Versatility. I don't see why Body Split, a common technique that already offers a number of cool advantages, should be any exception.
![[Image: superbuuelectricityne4.jpg]](http://img148.imageshack.us/img148/3128/superbuuelectricityne4.jpg)
Bra Wrote:People are dumb, essentially.

