03-02-2007, 10:20 PM
Quote:Originally posted by KrillinHe did.
As I just said, I was attacking the principle. I had assumed Aqua got his facts correct, and decided to go with them.
Quote:Because these are the 'facts' he used to create his argument, then it is absolutely necessary to use the same 'facts' to defeat the argument.Okay, but he did. So you were arguing against something nonexistant.
Quote:If I had considered it at all necessary to actually get the specific instance cleared up, then I probably would have checked, but I was more concerned with the principle.You argued that 06ers won because they are the most populous class and that they thus voted for their friends in the same 'class'. That's what you concluded. But 06ers didn't win, so obviously they're not as bias as you think.
Conclusion: Not worrying about facts that do not at all actually apply to the intent of my counter-argument does not constitute an ignorance of what I'm talking about.
So yes, IMO at least, getting your facts straight does matter, even if you're already arguing for the 'right' principle. I myself agreed with Kibbles, but arguing something that's 'right' for the wrong reasons is just as bad as arguing something that's wrong.
The problem with this method of debating is that it counts on nobody calling it out. Still pretty effective when you have the power to lock threads, though.
![[Image: superbuuelectricityne4.jpg]](http://img148.imageshack.us/img148/3128/superbuuelectricityne4.jpg)
Bra Wrote:People are dumb, essentially.

