Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
(C&C) Burden In My Hand
#1
http://www.cdbzrpg.com/forum/showthread.php?t=24107

Might as well. C&C on the thread as we go would be appreciated.
Reply
#2
Bump. I'd really like some opinions, since this is the first storyline roleplay I've participated in that's been on a course to actual success.
"Maria..."
[Image: Sullivanbarscopy.jpg]
"...my star...'"
Quote:frickinegg 4:46 pm
To me, the thread is less about criticizing/defending Avatar and more about wondering how stoned Jack was when he saw the movie/made the thread.
Reply
#3
Alrighty:

First, both of y’alls work is excellent. I think in all twelve posts I found one wrong word (a her instead of a him) and no misspellings or punctuation problems so that’s some damn fine work, usually I find at least one a post so obviously you both proofread or have Mozart levels of cognitive thought. Overall, you guys have crafted a great story and have a seamless transition in writing each other’s characters and advancing along.

Also, my favorite thing about the two of you is that each post has a good ending AND always leads me to wanting more. I feel like there is a conclusion but I’m also eager to get to that next post and I find that to be very difficult to get done every time and you two both do it.

Ok now for the bad stuff seperatly:

Bujin: The biggest problem I had was a story issue. Your second post was well written but the fact that Bujin places great emphasis on helping Celipa but at the same time stops for a drink and talks to an old flame just makes him seem sociopathic, and then gets even weirder as Lyon mentions they should hurry then invited him back to meet people in the same breath. It felt…weird.

Structurally you have a little bit of the problem that Celipa has in paragraph breaks. Beyond using them to, you know, be grammatically correct sometimes you over use them:
Quote:Bujin gulped.

“That’s what happened to Celipa,” he mentioned, sighing. All of the people present blinked and looked amongst themselves.

Would fit better as just:

Bujin gulped. “That’s what happened to Celipa.” All of the people present blinked and looked amongst themselves.

I really like the way you built up your NPCs. Lyon and Kalia feel like flesh and blood not just instruments to get your story done. I loved the way Kalia asked about Celipa being your girlfriend before leaving the room and Bujin’s reaction. Awesome stuff.

I had a problem with using the ‘quote’ feature to establish a dream. It is more powerful if the reader thinks it is real to start off with. Having everything seem like it is the next part of the story then suddenly change as somewhere an alarm clock rings or someone who shouldn’t be there wakes him up has a greater effect. Starting in the quote box already takes the reader out of it. Personally, I don’t like using internet feature in writing like quote features, emoticons, or colored type. It makes the writing feel cheaper and cheesy to me.

Celipa: What I said to Bujin about paragraph breaks factors in much more for you. You use the breaks really well usually to pace the reader such as:

Quote: ---Undoubtedly, then, her wound was treated. Celipa lifted the covers off herself to find that she was in her under-clothing. She pulled her shirt up to reveal her stomach, which was adorned in a number of white bandages. Certainly, then, she could sit up.

She tried.

And failed.

But there were a few times where it seemed like the breaks interrupted a singular thought in the writing such as:

Quote: "What the Hell has gotten into you?" he began, but then he trailed off. "Oh."

He had spotted the glimmering item.

"Almost got it out of the sand, yet?"

Feels much better to me as:

“What the hell has gotten into you?” he began, but then trailed off as he spotted the glimmering item. “Oh. Almost got it out of the sand yet?”

My favorite part of your posts was the hallucination scene from:

Quote:"It's like trying to drug a fucking elephant!"
All the way through the goats and the pudding. That was seriously creative and funny and I loved it.


To both of you I want to say this is all really nit picky stuff because you have all the basic and intermediate stuff down and are solid writers. These are just things to keep in mind to push into sublime excellence. I can’t wait to see how y’all finish up. I also wouldn't turn down C&C on my Origin of Burter post if y'all find time.
[Image: Yamusig3copy.jpg]

Dante's Abyss 2007 Runner-Up
Reply
#4
That was some of the best C&C I've ever read. You have no idea how appreciated it is. =D

I'll definitely dig up the time ASAP to read through what you've posted in Origins of Burter and C&C it as thoroughly as possible.

Once again, thanks.
"Maria..."
[Image: Sullivanbarscopy.jpg]
"...my star...'"
Quote:frickinegg 4:46 pm
To me, the thread is less about criticizing/defending Avatar and more about wondering how stoned Jack was when he saw the movie/made the thread.
Reply
#5
I'll read where I left off, and give some good feedback, although I suck at it.


So far, what I've read has been awesome. I think I left a little present in the alliance forum about it somewhere.

[Image: siggy2.jpg]

Vad: Found my dicks btw
Vad: *DISCS
Kaz: XD!!!!XDXDXD!!
Kaz: oh man
Kaz: that was an awesome typo!
Vad: I MEANT ROUND CYLINDRICAL THINGS
Kaz: XD XD XD
Kaz: HAHAHHHAHHHAHA

Reply
#6
Ahaha, just caught the story part. xD Some of it was intentional to describe how flustered and confused Bujin was, but I definitely didn't mean to deviate that much.

Thanks, Yamu. Like Celipa, I'll try to gather what little C&C skills I have and give your work a shot.
Reply
#7
Yeah, we finally finished. <.<

This is almost to the point of futility, since this thread will be wiped on Wednesday. <.< But if anyone has been following our story or suddenly felt the urge to read it in its entirety tonight or tomorrow, they can feel free to post their thoughts on the story.
Reply
#8
I'll try to read this tomorrow. Celipa wants me too, I promised, now I'm forced to do it soon.
Quote: "for a quarter million a year growing weed, i'd fucking be gay. with dick on the side." - Laura, on mairjuana
Reply
#9
C'mon guys.

>.>

Please?
"Maria..."
[Image: Sullivanbarscopy.jpg]
"...my star...'"
Quote:frickinegg 4:46 pm
To me, the thread is less about criticizing/defending Avatar and more about wondering how stoned Jack was when he saw the movie/made the thread.
Reply
#10
I read it all, and it was SO good, that I will award you both 5 neopoints! Yayz!

But really, it was pretty awesome.
[Image: jd-1.jpg]
"I would happily blow 20 guys in an alley with bleedy dicks so I could
get AIDS then fuck a deer and kill it with my AIDS." - Louis C.K.
thanks waff
Kaden Wrote:I wish being ten John Does made me feel better than it actually does.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)