Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Retribution Critique Thread
#1
Post 1 through 4 is already up. If I may, I'd like some opinions on how well I'm introducing Vad into the world as Toma's son.

Same rules apply, no flaming my work. I don't mind if you don't like it, just tell me why.

Thanks.
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
[Image: Viper-Adjusted-Mini-Sig.png]
[Image: Trixie-Mini-Sig-Fixed.png]

Fighting to the bitter end is an advantage when your opponent does not wish to perish.
Reply
#2
OK, I'm going to be frank. I didn't think I would like the idea of Trixie at all. But you have proven me wrong. I quite enjoy reading about her. Your plot and pace are exceptional, and I can't wait to read more. There are just a few things irking me, mainly grammatical errors that I wanted to alert you to. The one that happens most often is your trouble with quotation marks. There are two ways I saw you do this. First, when you have dialogue that is supported by something along the lines of 'character said' or 'said character' then it shouldn't look like this:

Quote:"Stay with me sexy, don't die on me" Trixie pleaded.

It should look more like this, adding a comma. And then comma should always be inside the quotation marks. Also remember that if you put a non-proper noun or a verb following the quotation marks, that it doesn't need to be capitalized. Ala, "Dialogue" Stuttered Vad. Rather, "Dialogue," stuttered Vad. But back to the comma:

Quote:"Stay with me sexy, don't die on me," Trixie pleaded.

And then like when you labeled something DNA Lab. You said this:

Quote:... that read "DNA Lab".

Once again, I think the punctuation should be inside the quotation marks, like so:

Quote:... that read "DNA Lab."

But that's really all I noticed. Watch out for those grammatical errors and you should be fine. I like it. =]

[Image: picture.php?albumid=31&pictureid=126]

Bio: Juno | Active Thread: The Invasion - Bad Medicine
Reply
#3
Thanks!

While posting this stuff, I actually thought up their first full blown fight scene together. Coming soon to a thread of mine near you.

And thanks for the grammatical help. I do my best, but it helps to have someone who knows what they're talking about help me out. =D

Posted again.

EDIT: BIG EDIT, the scene I just posted is my first one of its kind. I read how not to do it, and I went from there. Be nice! xD
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
[Image: Viper-Adjusted-Mini-Sig.png]
[Image: Trixie-Mini-Sig-Fixed.png]

Fighting to the bitter end is an advantage when your opponent does not wish to perish.
Reply
#4
I've admittedly only read the first couple, but I didn't like it at all. I ended up skipping most of it because I got extremely bored. You are clearly upping the lengths of your posts for maximum XP allocation. I think you would benefit greatly by posting short, good roleplays as opposed to long, boring ones.
Reply
#5
Alura Wrote:I've admittedly only read the first couple, but I didn't like it at all. I ended up skipping most of it because I got extremely bored. You are clearly upping the lengths of your posts for maximum XP allocation. I think you would benefit greatly by posting short, good roleplays as opposed to long, boring ones.

I needed to post what I already had. Plus I made a mistake in my first post, which needed correcting, by buying Flight. Problem solved. Time to get writing again.
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
[Image: Viper-Adjusted-Mini-Sig.png]
[Image: Trixie-Mini-Sig-Fixed.png]

Fighting to the bitter end is an advantage when your opponent does not wish to perish.
Reply
#6
Nothing you replied with had anything to do with my concern.
Reply
#7
Alura Wrote:Nothing you replied with had anything to do with my concern.

Well, I can't prove that it wasn't for XP allocation. I honestly just wanted to get this word document posted as fast as I could. But, I agree to a point, short and simple works. That's what will happen when I start writing.
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
[Image: Viper-Adjusted-Mini-Sig.png]
[Image: Trixie-Mini-Sig-Fixed.png]

Fighting to the bitter end is an advantage when your opponent does not wish to perish.
Reply
#8
If you have an entire part of the storyline written already, why not post it all in one fell swoop? That's what I would do =P

[Image: picture.php?albumid=31&pictureid=126]

Bio: Juno | Active Thread: The Invasion - Bad Medicine
Reply
#9
Juno Wrote:If you have an entire part of the storyline written already, why not post it all in one fell swoop? That's what I would do =P

7 pages of writing would have really exaggerated it. Haha. I gotta get into some music and write soon. I gotz ideas!
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
[Image: Viper-Adjusted-Mini-Sig.png]
[Image: Trixie-Mini-Sig-Fixed.png]

Fighting to the bitter end is an advantage when your opponent does not wish to perish.
Reply
#10
Still, I can't understand why you would pause between posting =P And I've seen posts before that were probably close to 7 pages.

[Image: picture.php?albumid=31&pictureid=126]

Bio: Juno | Active Thread: The Invasion - Bad Medicine
Reply
#11
Maybe he wanted some criticism before he posted the rest. Or maybe he wanted to leave the audience "wanting more." Or maybe he wanted to be a douchebag about it.

Edit: I'll review it later and tell you about it.
[Image: jd-1.jpg]
"I would happily blow 20 guys in an alley with bleedy dicks so I could
get AIDS then fuck a deer and kill it with my AIDS." - Louis C.K.
thanks waff
Kaden Wrote:I wish being ten John Does made me feel better than it actually does.
Reply
#12
Alright, the latest two posts have been straight from my head. Any critiques?
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
[Image: Viper-Adjusted-Mini-Sig.png]
[Image: Trixie-Mini-Sig-Fixed.png]

Fighting to the bitter end is an advantage when your opponent does not wish to perish.
Reply
#13
It's kind of unpolished. Like the monster that was attacking the man, was that supposed to be random, or did I miss out on how he fit into the story? You just find some monster eating a guy, you kill it and throw it aside, and then you move on... wtf? Are you going to come back to that later at least?

Trixie should be more provocative... you did that a few times, the other few times it was like she was an A.I. dashboard telling you where exactly you were bleeding. I liked the "stay with me sexy" line, and I wanted to see more of that. You should stick to that, the flirting and the suggestive speech. Fuck the rest.

I didn't get the thing with the aunt...

It had a lot of action, and you are good at that. Just try to work on your narration skills a bit. Right now, it seems like you'd do better in a fight or something than on your own telling a story.
Quote: "for a quarter million a year growing weed, i'd fucking be gay. with dick on the side." - Laura, on mairjuana
Reply
#14
Bil Baer Jaxx Wrote:It's kind of unpolished. Like the monster that was attacking the man, was that supposed to be random, or did I miss out on how he fit into the story? You just find some monster eating a guy, you kill it and throw it aside, and then you move on... wtf? Are you going to come back to that later at least?

Trixie should be more provocative... you did that a few times, the other few times it was like she was an A.I. dashboard telling you where exactly you were bleeding. I liked the "stay with me sexy" line, and I wanted to see more of that. You should stick to that, the flirting and the suggestive speech. Fuck the rest.

I didn't get the thing with the aunt...

It had a lot of action, and you are good at that. Just try to work on your narration skills a bit. Right now, it seems like you'd do better in a fight or something than on your own telling a story.

Is there a book labeled "How Joe Writes" somewhere? xD Christ, dead on perfect to what I think my areas of expertise are.

Yes, I admit, the intro was pretty fucked up. BUT, that's about to change. Soon. I promise!

And advice noted for Trixie. =D
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
[Image: Viper-Adjusted-Mini-Sig.png]
[Image: Trixie-Mini-Sig-Fixed.png]

Fighting to the bitter end is an advantage when your opponent does not wish to perish.
Reply
#15
Me and Piper are smacking some posts up. Any one care to C&C?
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
[Image: Viper-Adjusted-Mini-Sig.png]
[Image: Trixie-Mini-Sig-Fixed.png]

Fighting to the bitter end is an advantage when your opponent does not wish to perish.
Reply
#16
I love Piper. I always have =D

I'm still wondering where in the world your character could go, Vad. He seems like he could have a great story, you just need to pull it out. And... I'm going to have to say to either work on your sex scenes or fade them out... I was slightly disturbed, to be honest.

EDIT: Maybe it was the incest. Definitely no incest anymore, kay?

Oh, and I had to make sure Alex saw it: I LOVE PIPER <3

[Image: picture.php?albumid=31&pictureid=126]

Bio: Juno | Active Thread: The Invasion - Bad Medicine
Reply
#17
Juno Wrote:I love Piper. I always have =D

I'm still wondering where in the world your character could go, Vad. He seems like he could have a great story, you just need to pull it out. And... I'm going to have to say to either work on your sex scenes or fade them out... I was slightly disturbed, to be honest.

EDIT: Maybe it was the incest. Definitely no incest anymore, kay?

Oh, and I had to make sure Alex saw it: I LOVE PIPER <3

Noted...
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
[Image: Viper-Adjusted-Mini-Sig.png]
[Image: Trixie-Mini-Sig-Fixed.png]

Fighting to the bitter end is an advantage when your opponent does not wish to perish.
Reply
#18
If anyone has been keeping up. Any comments or critiques for either Piper or me?
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
[Image: Viper-Adjusted-Mini-Sig.png]
[Image: Trixie-Mini-Sig-Fixed.png]

Fighting to the bitter end is an advantage when your opponent does not wish to perish.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)