Mafia - Day Two

[Blue]

Alex might not be mafia, but think on this: he hasn't really contributed to our lynching discussion, so he's adding almost nothing to the group. Furthermore, if he were sheriff or the doctor, shouldn't he be atleast trying to either point a finger at someone, or allay our suspicions about someone else? I think he is mafia, but if he's not I don't think it'll hurt us terribly to lynch him.

[Moyki]

Then he should be #1 suspect for sheriff. but not us.

Plus, there's a chance Alex might not even post, so he could be killed due to inactivity.

[Jarka]

I agree with Moyki. No use lynching somebody that's not raising any real suspicion.

Honestly, I think he might be the doctor. It seems like a Trafford thing to do to choose to "heal" himself on the first night.

[John Doe]

I'm more inclined to agree with Whompt's logic. It doesn't make sense that you would be sheriff or doctor without even trying to add anything to the lynching discussion. If he were mafia, however, saying little to nothing would benefit his position.

Regardless of what I think, the fact is that, according to everyone else's logic, we should lynch somebody in this phase. Alex is suspicious by trying to not be suspicious, and offers the least amount of negative benefits if he turned out to be a townsfolk (he didn't really chat or discuss with the group, so it's not like we'd lose an active member). If we don't pick somebody soon, the phase will end with a no-lynch anyway.

Edit: lol I typed no-lunch first.

Edit 2: We have about 4 hours until the end of this phase, so if we're lynching somebody we got to do it now.

[Blue]

No one said the doctor healed him or herself. The doc could have just guessed right. I'm hoping that remains the case, but we'll see. But, since Alex may end up being killed due to inactivity, what's the harm in putting the power in our hands and lynching him? I'd rather have some control over this game than none at all.

[Moyki]

Yeah. Or the mafia could've just not killed anyone, to limit clues.

This is the second phase in a row that Raf and Celena initially voted for the same person -- Leo.

From my knowledge, throughout this entire game Celena and Raf haven't made any direct contact to one another (at least not via forum). So, is it a coincidence that Celena and Raf are voting in unison? Maybe, but in a game like this, where everyone seems to have their own ideas, and then merge them together, Celena and Raf have stayed consistent.


Thus, I stay with my idea of voting Celena or Raf.

[Blue]

That makes sense. I'll go along with it for now. They've been pretty nonexistent here as well, so here goes:

Unvote Alex
Lynch Celena

[Super Buu]

See now we're making some progress.

[Jonathan Meer]

Leo 1/6 (Celena)
Whompt 1/6 (Piper)
Piper 1/6 (Sigfried)
Rafael 2/6 (Moyki, Jarka)
Celena 2/6 (Rose, Celena)
John Doe 1/6 (Leo)
Alex T 2/6 (John Doe, Rafael)

[Moyki]

It it means anything, it seems like one of us is going to get our wish - Alex, Celena, and Raf tops for chopping block.

[Blue]

No one's going to get any wish if we don't get on the same page here. If you think Celena is mafia, vote with me and Rose. Otherwise we're going to stalemate because we can't make any decisions as a group.

[John Doe]

Teamwork's the best.

I'll agree to vote for whoever gets 4 or more votes, as long as they seem reasonably suspicious.

[Tyr]

I'd rather want a possibility excluded than nothing happening at all.

Unvote John Doe
Lynch Celena

Also did Celena vote for himself? : o

[John Doe]

Leo 1/6 (Celena)
Whompt 1/6 (Piper)
Piper 1/6 (Sigfried)
Rafael 2/6 (Moyki, Jarka)
Celena 3/6 (Rose, Whompt, Leo)
Alex T 2/6 (John Doe, Rafael)

[Celena]

I say we get majority vote for either Celena or Raphael. Both of them kind of linger in the thread but produce minimal posts.

If we're a miss on either one of them I'll be the first person to vote myself in next time, for this would the second person I got majority to vote for. So, if I'm wrong twice I deserved to be lynched.

I'll raise your hand. If I get lynched because of your accusations, everyone else will get to lynch you next round, deal? Or are you not have the balls to take the risk?

Yeah. Or the mafia could've just not killed anyone, to limit clues.

This is the second phase in a row that Raf and Celena initially voted for the same person -- Leo.

From my knowledge, throughout this entire game Celena and Raf haven't made any direct contact to one another (at least not via forum). So, is it a coincidence that Celena and Raf are voting in unison? Maybe, but in a game like this, where everyone seems to have their own ideas, and then merge them together, Celena and Raf have stayed consistent.


Thus, I stay with my idea of voting Celena or Raf.

I'm voting for Leo because I've suspected he's been Mafia since day 1. I voted for Leo to get lynched, I'm trusting my isntincts, what more do I need to say in this thread?

Edit: You know what, even better, if it turns out I'm Mafia staff can ban me for 6 months. I'm a man of my word.

[John Doe]

I'll raise your hand. If I get lynched because of your accusations, everyone else will get to lynch you next round, deal? Or are you not have the balls to take the risk?

I'm voting for Leo because I've suspected he's been Mafia since day 1. I voted for Leo to get lynched, I'm trusting my isntincts, what more do I need to say in this thread?

Edit: You know what, even better, if it turns out I'm Mafia staff can ban me for 6 months. I'm a man of my word.

It honestly sounds like you're trying to muscle your way out of being lynched.

[Celena]

You're going to end up lynching every towns person here if you listen to just one person's logic. I'd lmao if Myoki ends up being Mafia after having misled you all.

[John Doe]

I think the logic is that we should lynch to if just to lynch. Not my own logic, mind you, but I don't think I have much choice on that. We either move as a group or not. I'd still rather vote for Alex over you, but with less than an hour left in this phase, I'll do what I can.

Unvote Alex

Lynch Celena

[Tyr]

The problem is that it's a wasted lynch if he gets auto lynched anyway. This way we can exclude two possible if an auto-lynch comes into play.

[Celena]

Before I as a townsperson gets lynched let me just throw in my own theory.

Why is Moyki the only person concerned with Raf and I lynching Leo? I suspect that he's trying his best to save Leo's neck because they're both Mafia.