Mafia - Debrief

[Jonathan Meer]

1 Jarka
2 Sigfried
3 Waffuru
4 Rafael
5 Celena
6 Leo
7 John Doe
8 Piper
9 Moyki
10 Rose
11 Whompt
12 Alex T

HOLY SHIT WHOMPT. Single-handedly won that game. Seriously. I've never seen the Doctor pwn that hard.

...Sign-ups for the next Mafia round will be up tonight, and there will be more special roles. =D

EDIT: This is a place for your thoughts on the game, but I also want your thoughts on the way it ran. Did anything seem unbalanced or unfair?

[John Doe]

Did anything seem unbalanced or unfair?

I think everyone knows the answer to that one.

Who's Currently Online.

[Super Buu]

Fuck yeah Whompt. That was insane prediction.

I was gonna offer to run the next mafia so you could have a go, but either way I'm in. Personally I'd just swap up the roles for variety, maybe give the mafia a 'special'.

[John Doe]

I was gonna offer to run the next mafia so you could have a go, but either way I'm in. Personally I'd just swap up the roles for variety, maybe give the mafia a 'special'.

Meer told me he wanted to run another one first, then pass the torch to whoever. I'm up for another, save the Who's Online thing stays down.

[Jonathan Meer]

Yes, Who's Online.

Moyki, I can't really fault you for jumping on that. I didn't explicitly bar it. But that's not the sort of dynamic I want to encourage for Mafia. Part of the way the game works is that there should be no indication who Mafia are during Night Phase. Townspeople are, for all purposes, 'asleep,' they should not gain more information during that phase.

Now, of course, I can't keep any of you from doing that sort of thing during the Night Phase; checking on when someone was active and trying to line up things in that way. But, as a matter of honor, I want to discourage those practices in the strongest possible terms. The game is to be played via the topics, and one-way PMs to me.

[Blue]

It would have been balanced if I hadn't kicked so much rear. I didn't think I'd have actually guessed right four times in a row or got the whole group behind me on all my lynches. It was crazy!

It actually took a lot of reading into the way people were presenting themselves to figure out the mafia's targets. When Leo died I was blown away. He was so low key I hadn't even considered him for a possible target. Moyki I always considered because of his paranoia and aggressive strategy. Myself, I wanted everyone to be guessing about me because it was the best way to be targetted and to keep people from thinking I was the Doctor. It was hard, guys... This game takes a lot of logical and analytical thought and I found myself spending much more time trolling this thread than I originally thought I would. I also was surprised at the level of post activity I put in. I was definitely not making myself a small target.

[Super Buu]

I figured they went for Leo specifically because they'd failed so many times in a row and wanted to go for someone unexpected.

[John Doe]

Yeah, we were trying to avoid the targets we knew weren't key roles. Rose and Sig gave themselves away early on that they weren't anything special. Moyki, I'll be honest here, I wanted to kill because he pissed me off with the Who's Online feature. The moment he even suggested it, I wanted him dead. To test him, I stayed on PM for 5 minutes, and sure enough, he caught me. If it wasn't for that, our first kill would have been Leo. I'd say the MVP of that game was Moyki, because if he wasn't in that game, Mafia would have won pretty handedly.

I should have played that game better, but my own anger cost us the win. GG either way.

[Blue]

I love the fact that Waff pretty much called the mafia members with his first post. Then we lynched him. Jeez... imagine if he'd stayed.

[John Doe]

I love the fact that Waff pretty much called the mafia members with his first post. Then we lynched him. Jeez... imagine if he'd stayed.

Sig also called the Mafia as well. And if he stayed, there would have been a lot more .jpg wars.

I liked mafia a lot better when my character didn't look the part.

[Blue]

That was amazingly amusing. Heh!

I'm just glad the townies managed to work together. That no lynch day sucked.

[Moyki]

I was mvp on the first mafia lynching. No one expect raf till I did.

I figured out whimpt, raf, and piper weren't townspeople based off of the Online thing. I knew it would be banned, but it was a legal loophole until it was banned.

John doe, pms didn't lead to me believing you were mafia. I just kpt my eye on you and sig. I figured 1 if not both of your were mafia.

[Celena]

Moyki was the star of the show IMO. Sherlock eat your heart out. And even after Raf got lynched, he knew I wasn't Mafia.

Edit: If people aim at him in the new Mafia, you know it's because they'd feel threatened.

[John Doe]

John doe, pms didn't lead to me believing you were mafia.

UNVOTE WAFF

LYNCH JOHN DOE


Caught John Doe PMing not too long ago.

Righto, mate.

[Sigfried Hunin]

All I'm saying is that where logic failed, psychic premonition outlined every single one of the mafia on the very first day. I let my friendship with Piper cloud my vision on the very last kill, but he was there on the list.

NOW WHO'S CRAZY HUH!?%!!?#% HUUUH>!$^%?#!^

[Moyki]

Yeah, and u were pming me, JD, so I had actually taken u off my suspect list until u voted celena instead of raf, and then u wantd to vote celena in to

I knew aftr raf was mafia celena couldn't be, because tht would be too simple.

[Alexander Trafford]

I knew Raf and Doe, they were pretty obvious, but I never suspected Piper. Probably because I never suspect Piper. Damn trickster.

[Celena]

I get it now! Raf must have voted for Leo twice because he knew he was the Sherrif whereas I truely believed Leo was Mafia due to hardly contributing in the thread. So when we both voted for him twice, I can see how you got suspicious Moyki.

[John Doe]

Yeah, and u were pming me, JD, so I had actually taken u off my suspect list until u voted celena instead of raf, and then u wantd to vote celena in to

I knew aftr raf was mafia celena couldn't be, because tht would be too simple.

Could you use a damn spell check? You're sounding like Mal.

I voted off Raf in the 3rd round. I told you guys I'd vote for whoever got 4 votes against them. But when the time was getting close, I had to pick Cel, who had the most votes at the time. Mafia or not, I made the logical choice.

And how was I obvious, Traff?

Edit: nvm, I can see how you thought so, even though that was just me getting people to talk and reveal their deepest, darkest secrets.

[Blue]

I had actually originally suspected none of the mafia who ended up being so. I knew moyki wasn't because of how into finding them he was. But I thought the mafia were Waff, Cel, and Alex originally.