LoM2 - Day Two

[John Doe]

Why's that?

[Tyr]

It's a pretty elaborate description on abilities we don't know with champions we don't know for him to be bullshitting.

We're talking like, movie scripted bullshitting here.

[Vad]

Womanly intuition.

[Waffuru]

Avast, it would be me guess that he is more likely Singed or someone who has an ability that does something if ye get targeted. Announcing that ye are Warwick would surely turn a landlubber into chum.

Or mebbe he be Swain!

[Tyr]

Avast, it would be me guess that he is more likely Singed or someone who has an ability that does something if ye get targeted. Announcing that ye are Warwick would surely turn a landlubber into chum.

Or mebbe he be Swain!

Okay I actually missed that, he could of course just be Swain. He's a new role and he can just borrow the Warwick description from the last game (if I recall correctly, he was there too).

Also I really like your role if Ashe made it or your initiative if you just adopted that, it's pretty sweet.

[Super Buu]

Since it doesn't look like we're going to get a full lynch vote tonight, Unlynch Keiko and Lynch Kaden to see if I can get some more info. I'll change my vote if there looks like there might be a majority before I sleep. This 'sitting around doing nothing' strategy stinks.

[Kole T. Merr]

Haha. Yeah, of COURSE I would have "connection troubles". Sorry guys. I've just been SUPER busy IRL, what with having a girlfriend and all now (what what!). I also have a class that I'm supposed to be writing two papers for (They're due in 7 hours!) But I am here, and ready for this. I will read day one stuff and see if I can glean anything from it, but LOL at Mal Nova being dead.

[John Doe]

LOL at Mal Nova being dead.

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA

Best way to find out if Rose is not bullshitting is to lynch somebody. As in, actually lynch somebody. Last time we did the whole waiting game, our biggest source of information was abducted into the mafia. How about we do something with what leads we have instead of dicks up the butt. I don't like dicks up my butt.

[Vad]

We have no leads.

[Tyr]

If we are to lynch, we should definitely stick with the one we're most sure of. I don't think we should just all gang up on someone with no shred of evidence.

I'm going to go over possible outcomes here if Greg is major bullshitting, but really the worst case scenario is he's a Joker. His job is to get lynched. When you kill a Joker, he randomly takes one person in the game with him and we lose three people in one go because we lynch based on his call, then we kill him to get payback, then he kills one of us. That's not counting for the mafia who will take a fourth and if they have a kill power ready, we're utter fucked at about five straight up kills in two rounds.

It could also just be hyper aggressive mafia. If the mafia has some sort of post mortem power, like the Karthus one, with this few people, we could also be dramatically fucked because Greg will have earned our trust and he will be able, with good roleplaying skills, to call out shots for people he dislikes as the game goes on and we'll believe him because we have no other investigative role.

In summary: shit.

[Super Buu]

We have no leads.

If we are to lynch, we should definitely stick with the one we're most sure of. I don't think we should just all gang up on someone with no shred of evidence.

DUDES. In any game, having someone say "I'm the cop, X is mafia" is the BIGGEST LEAD YOU GET. Besides actually being the cop and knowing 100% sure they are mafia. That's the way mafia works! Nobody ever knows if anyone is lying until the very end of the game, at which point you've usually already won/lost, as a result of earlier guesses and gambles which is where the actual game is situated. There are a billion possible rational reasons someone could be doing something, which is why the game is as much luck as it is skill. The only guaranteed way to lose is to do nothing.

Man, I hate to explain this but you guys stink at this game D=

[Tyr]

I meant you changing your lynch to Kaden, lol.

[Super Buu]

Like I said in that post, I'm just changing my lynch to Kaden to try and get a bit of information, since my ability works by telling us about whoever has the most lynch votes, and Kaden's my arbitrary pick. I don't intend to actually lynch him (at least not today). Sniff.

[Tyr]

Ah, I actually didn't know how the role worked because I'm too lazy to read all the other roles. What if we lynch someone, is it then the next msot voted or what?

[John Doe]

We DO have a lead, being Keiko. I think it's highly likely, given the descriptions of the GM, the information Rose has given us, the lack of info Keiko has given us, the fact that I'm LeBlanc, the low number of players, and the posting rules. I'll point it out since it's obvious, but Rose has been posting with things having to do with smell. Unless you have a better champion that goes with smell besides a champ with bloodscent and who also somehow knows Keiko is Swain, then please let me know.

I refer to the number of players because, as I said earlier, it's HIGHLY UNLIKELY that there are any fractions besides "Town" and "Mafia" in this game. Therefore, the possibility of a "Joker" character is pretty slim (I say that knowing that Shaco has already been mentioned). There's two things that can happen if we lynch Keiko. One, we lynch a townie and then lynch Rose tomorrow. Two, Keiko is a mafia and we are one step closer to winning this game. If we don't act, we will lose another townie (me probably) and encourage more crazy shit to happen that the Mafia can capitalize on.

Rose said it already, but you guys are terrible at this game. I'm going back to SWTOR and I better see more lynch votes.

[Super Buu]

No, it only works if no players are lynched. Sniff.

[Vad]

Lynch Rose

[Vad]

Lynch Rose

Actually no. Unlynch

I am formulating a battle plan.

[Tyr]

I'd imagine a 9/10 remaining could be fractions. Also you gotta stop speaking in plural, JD. I've probably played more mafia than anyone in this thread.

Pros cons wise, it's the same no matter what we do. The same amount of people will die. Let's lynch and get it over with.

Lynch Keiko Brykein

[Vad]

Lynching the newcomer is so last year.

Lynch Tyr