Ye Olde Mafia - Day Two

[Anzekay]

I've been posting, you jerks, just not spamming like the rest of you.

[Tyr]

snip

edit: snipped

edit: corrected grammar mistake

edit: i failed typing the

edit: failed typing the third edit reason which was: i failed typing the corrected grammar

[Kaden]

I've been posting, you jerks, just not spamming like the rest of you.

I apologize. You and King B basically flipped your post numbers on days 1 and 2. I looked at your Day 1 and his Day 2 and put them together for you.

That makes my vote even more solidly Keiko. Unless the sheriff reveals themselves and points to a mafia, I won't be changing my vote.

[Mal Nova]

TO trust the kaden Or lynch the Doe... One has to wonder? AShe? What you Think?

[Tyr]

[Anzekay]

woah when did they do that

[King B]

Didn't you say the same thing in the previous mafia game? You know, before you killed everyone?

lol.

I find it weird that the Mafia targeted Waffuru, who had a total of 1 post in the past day phase. I would assume this is to protect themselves from the loudmouths that have already accused someone. With that said, I feel like there's reason for me to conclude that in the past day phase, at least one or two mafia members have been subject to lynch votes or suspicious speculation, and therefore chose to kill off the quiet one to protect their positions.

Stupid mafias.

[King B]

Also to answer about my activity, my sleeping schedule has been off track and therefore I'm posting right now at 4 AM.

[King B]

But now? Spam.

[King B]

Also, I'm inclined to not trust Kaden at all because he has some sort of magnetic power under his walls of posts that forces you to see his reasoning. He could possibly be mafia again just for this quality, after all, the GM has fun while putting this together too. Watching everyone trust a mafia into screwing over the entire town sounds like something I would enjoy watching if I was a GM.

I also don't understand how I suddenly became a subject of suspicion, if you're basing off day one lynch votes, you might as well be lynching a random person anyway.

I'm also just an average dude, no powers, no nothing. Let's see if I'm as persuasive as Kaden?



I'm this dude too.

[King B]

Also, I find it stupid to speculate people that are so called "inactive" as mafia. After all, in early game, the mafia has odds against them being at a number disadvantage despite having more intel (assuming so). If you were mafia and really wanted to close that gap, you are almost forced to try and be active as fuck to take out us town bitches. The more you drag this game out the more you are at risk of being discovered, and that means in order to secure an early advantage you'd want to be extremely active in the first couple day phases. How convenient is it that the people that aren't posting as much to defend their position are the perfect scapegoats? Just a thought.

[King B]

Also, the reason I separated all of this was because someone was complaining about editing. So treat the above as one big post. I'm just posting as these thoughts come to my mind.

[Sophia]

People are going to edit, Mal. You would benefit from that ability too, you know, so just shut up about it.

As for people being suspicious of me, I haven't played many mafia games with you people. I figured people were just going to lynch like crazy...like most mafia games. By the time I realized that wouldn't happen, it was already night phase.

EDIT: Also, don't post images that stretch out the board. It's freaking me out.

[King B]

I feel like I should also explain my lynch vote for the Doe. I voted to Lynch him because he's a loose cannon. Instead of being a sensible person and actually contributing to either faction, he chooses to troll everyone. I mean, that's just how he is, and in any game other than mafia, it's usually nice to have a person like this around. I felt, eliminating him would be beneficial to townspeople, because he won't be around to confuse everyone. A lot of what he says feels rhetoric, and I know I'm not the only one thinking that. You guys have discussed this already, we don't know if he's really a sheriff or just trollin', and because we know what kind of a person he is, we are inclined to believe that he's just trollin'. This is the sort of confusion that could be bypassed if we got rid of him in the first day, instead of keeping him around to fuck with everyone's head. But that's just me, ya kno?

[John Doe]

Yay! People be saying shit. This is one of the most active Mafia threads since I can't even remember! ;3

If you want, you can look at the posts a different way. Just look at who's pointing fingers at who and how they relate to one another. I'll start by bringing up the last game. Mafia members tend to not sell out their own unless the odds are truly against them, and even then they'll try to defend their kin. Take a look at Keiko and Kaden from last game. Keiko got the shitty luck draw of being tagged by WW while also being Mafia. When this came up, Kaden professed his distrust of Rose despite being the clearest lead the Town had at that moment. Later on, he offered to instead vote lynch Vad to give Keiko another day to live (which also would give her a chance to use her abilities another night phase). That segues nicely into my next point: Kaden was against Vad. Throughout the game, he tried to get Vad killed. I believe I mentioned that either Kaden or Vad was Mafia, but it couldn't be both. That's because I saw that they were not at all on the same wavelength. If I had lived on the third night, I would have totally brought that all up.

Now we move back into the current game. Who's been targeting who? I'll just go in order:

Tyr > John Doe, King B (I'll ignore the "Ashe Mal Nova Kaden" thing since that was a joke)
King B > John Doe, Kaden
John Doe > Everyone that's not John Doe (but mainly Kaden)
Kaden > John Doe, Keiko
Anzekay > Sophia
Android 17 > Kaden
Mal Nova > John Doe, King B, basically everyone honestly
Ashe > John Doe, Kaden, Mal Nova
Keiko > Nobody
Sophia > John Doe

Man, I sure am popular huh? I ignored most (one? 15 if you count all of Mal's) suspicion lists since those are just a bullshit way to hide a fellow Mafia inside a blanket if they get killed to avoid blame. I won't (can't would be a better word, classes start in less than an hour) explain the specifics, but I still am going to vote for Kaden based on this and I'll let the rest of you guys decide if I'm reading too far into this or if I actually have a point.

Prepost Edit: HOLY SHIT I almost lost this because my college cut the cord of my net. Fucking hell, they pick the worst times I swear.

[John Doe]

Have something else to say as well. Information and assumptions are different. Based on what the GM has said, there are 3 town roles (Cop Doc and Vig) and three mafia, and the rest are normal townies. That's what we know; that is our information. The rest is an assumption. For example, we are assuming that the Vig did use his/her power last night because there was only one death. However, it is also possible that he/she did use her power and the Doc canceled it. It might not mean much, since the end result was all that we saw, but it could change the way we see things. Why do some of you think that I am not the Vig? Because Mal is alive. What if I am the Vig and Mal was kept alive because I couldn't kill him? What if Mal is the Doc? What if Mal is the Vig and I am the Doc?

Assume everything, and don't rule out possibilities strictly based on end results. I have classes to catch now so I'll see you all in the Mafia afterlife.

[Sophia]

John Doe is actually being coherent, so I'll follow Anzekay's advice and try to avoid a day two lynch.

Unlynch.

[Kaden]

Assume everything, and don't rule out possibilities strictly based on end results. I have classes to catch now so I'll see you all in the Mafia afterlife.

Nothing is true? Everything is permitted?

[Kaden]

I also don't understand how I suddenly became a subject of suspicion, if you're basing off day one lynch votes, you might as well be lynching a random person anyway.

Which is actually what I said.

It'll be sweet when I die and everyone goes back to read my posts again knowing I was a townsperson.

[Mal Nova]

And they all knew that no one would get any sleep tonight. THose bastards were all still out there...ever lurking. *Grabs the baseball bat*