Ye Olde Mafia - Day Three

[Mal Nova]

Trying to lynch someone that is inactive might even make them active.

[Android 17]

Well I suppose that if everything is a waste, I should waste my time on something I find worthwhile.

Lynch Mal

[Mal Nova]

You SHALL NOT PASS!

[Kaden]

I didn't say everything's a waste. The logic that a lynch vote with reasonable justifications is a waste just makes no sense.

People have expressed dissatisfaction with this course of action and then provided no other alternative. That's why people think I'm good at this game. I'm just trying to make stuff happen. Is it necessarily the best stuff? No. Is sitting around getting picked off any better? Definitely not.

Also, this game is far from over. There's still a doctor and a vigilante out there. Yeah, last night was almost the worst-case scenario for us (doctor dying instead of normal townie would have been worse) but it could easily swing the other way. If doctor gets a protection and then we go lynch + vigilante on the mafia, the game is basically over in the opposite direction.

[Kaden]

Keiko - Kaden, Anzekay, Mal, Sophia, King B
Mal - 17

Those are the lynch votes so far. 5 is majority.

[Anzekay]

It's quite possible that Keiko may not be posting much, but is still mafia and still dicussing stuff with the other two mafia.

It's worth it. And if Kaden isn't right here, then I have good reasons to suggest he's next on the block tbh.

[Android 17]

There won't be a next block. If Keiko's a townperson, then the mafia will win after the night cycle. (unless I'm doing my math wrong)

[Kaden]

If two townspeople die, then yeah, mafia wins. That means that Keiko (assuming she gets lynched) needs to be a townsperson, the Doctor needs to miss his protection, and the Vigilante has to either not use his power or hit a mafia with it.

So if you don't like lynching Keiko, what makes sense as a next course of action?

[Super Buu]

Hey Rose, it would be appreciated if we could get vote totals at the end of each day.

kk

Got about 11 and a half hours left mothafuckas

[Android 17]

If two townspeople die, then yeah, mafia wins. That means that Keiko (assuming she gets lynched) needs to be a townsperson, the Doctor needs to miss his protection, and the Vigilante has to either not use his power or hit a mafia with it.

So if you don't like lynching Keiko, what makes sense as a next course of action?

Mal. He's either mafia or the vigilante. The dude hates Doe, and Ashe was up on his list of suspects. Either way, he's the last person we need murdering people.

[Tyr]

So I took a nap after my initial post and that seemed to take significantly longer than I foresaw.

I agree with the Keiko lynch. She's inactive and doesn't add anything to the entire game and honestly I'd hate to eventually find out she was mafia while being so inactive.

Lynch Keiko

[Kaden]

Unlynch

Anzekay, Sophia, and Mal are my picks for mafia.

I didn't actually have any intention of lynching Keiko. 17 is correct, the risk of losing tonight isn't worth taking that shot. The plan was to, once again, pull the vote out at the end, leaving her alive. Tyr voting, though, means that even without my vote Keiko is dead so now I have to hope someone else decides to withdraw as well.

[Keiko Brykein]

Two things to say here.
1) Thanks for the vote of confidence that semi-activity deserves a lynching. I put "semi" because I haven't been inactive. I might not have posted much, but at least I haven't been trolling. So, if I would have been more active, I would not be on the chopping block? That’s just Fuzzy Logiv. Well, let's do this then.

2) Moving? Not that I know of. I have explained where my semi-activity comes from, 8 - 12 hour days and a computer that crashes way to often. And needless to mention, RL responsibilities.

Bonus thoughts:

1. Waffuru - DEAD
2. Tyr - Townie
3. King B - Townie
4. John Doe - DEAD
5. Kaden - Vigilante
6. Anzekay - Mafia
7. Android 17 Doctor
8. Mal Nova - Mafia
[COLOR="Red"]9. Ashe - DEAD Sheriff [/COLOR]
10. Keiko Brykein - Townie
11. Sophia - Townie


Now for my reasons; (Which comes from being quiet and waiting til now to voice my opinions)

2. Tyr (Townie) Tyr seems to be throwing out random, confused lynch votes and commentary. He is participating, but waiting for someone to make a valid point that he can latch onto. Or at least waiting for someone to show up with some evidence that can be backed up. But with the only Sheriff gone that leaves a definitive accusation impossible.

3. King B (Townie) The King was very hesitant with their lynch votes, aside from Doe, who almost everyone wanted to Lynch on Day 1. The King could always be mafia, but it’s not what I feel, and therefore part of my opinion.

5. Kaden (Townie - Vigilante) Kaden has wanted Doe to get lynched for sometime now. I assume that he figured the mafia would avoid lynching Doe for fear of the Doctor's protection. I believe Kaden is a townie, but has the vigilante role.

6. Anzekay (Mafia) I have seen a few instances where Anzekay has pointed out possible mafia members, but then said that lynching without reason is dumb. Considering no new information has been gained, other than my semi-activity, he has all of a sudden cast his first and only lynch vote, with a stipulation. "If Kaden is wrong in his finger pointing, then Kaden must be mafia," which is a great way to draw attention away from himself and quite possibly kill off the Vigilante as well.

7. Android 17 (Townie - Doctor) 17 has been semi-active, such as myself, but hasn't chosen to lynch anyone(at least not that I have noticed). On the contrary, he has been giving most people the benefit of the doubt when accused, and I am not throwing myself into that category. If you check back on day 1 and 2, in my opinion, 17 has been the voice of reason against a mob that has been out for blood. This is what makes me think 17 is the Doctor. Considering I work in a hospital IRL, 17 reminds me of someone that wants to not go triage style until he absolutely has to. Doctor.

8. Mal Nova (Mafia) Besides, throwing accusations all around, and I mean all around, Mal seems that he is trying to hard to prove his worth and to be noticed as a vital part of the game. Where it seems that Doe drew the wrong attention and turned out to be a townie, Mal has drawn the ‘right’ attention and managed to stay off the radar pretty much. Besides, his top Mafia suspects have all turned up dead and townies.

10. Keiko Brykein (Townie) Mainly because Rose never sent me any kind of PM or message telling me that I am Mafia.

11. Sophia (Townie) - Sophia is really weighing her options on what could actually be going on and not trying to lynch at random. I have read a lot of what Sophia had said in the previous days, all of it actually, and it all could be a ploy to fake being a townie. But that’s not what I see when I go back over everything.


If anyone has any thoughts of their own regarding everyone, or just a handful of people, now would be a good time to put it out there. Especially since the only ‘logical’ evidence going around right now is, “Lynch the Inactives’

With that said, I say, Lynch Mal Nova

[Sophia]

Unlynch

Anzekay, Sophia, and Mal are my picks for mafia.

I didn't actually have any intention of lynching Keiko. 17 is correct, the risk of losing tonight isn't worth taking that shot. The plan was to, once again, pull the vote out at the end, leaving her alive. Tyr voting, though, means that even without my vote Keiko is dead so now I have to hope someone else decides to withdraw as well.

I envy Rose right now. I'd be laughing at that if I was in that position.

I was hoping it would be fairly obvious that I'm not mafia by now.

EDIT: Also, in regards to Keiko, the only person who I'm willing to bet on being mafia at this point is Mal. I still suspect Kaden, and I agree that Anzekay looks suspicious too, but I'm not willing to go much farther than that.

[Keiko Brykein]

Ha! I just realized that I didn't put in a 3rd Mafia spot. Probably because I don't have a clue, but as I said, I think that Mal and Anzekay are Mafia

[Tyr]

Unlynch

Whatever, I cooperated with Kaden to get my win on the mafia side, here's hoping I'll get a townspeople one too.

[Tyr]

Also, because people dislike edits, I honestly hope Rose made Mal Nova vigilante solely so he could get back at Doe.

[Kaden]

So, a lot of people seem to be suspicious of Anzekay. Mal seems suspicious, but I'm not sure if that's because he's actually being suspicious or because it's just Mal. Could go either way on that one.

Soph: What makes you think you've made your innocence obvious? I may have missed something.

Keiko: Yeah, inactives should get lynched in my opinion. That opinion, as it turns out, carried a bit of weight. Is it fair? Not really. Does that change my opinion on it? Sadly, no.

I keep going back and forth on whether or not a lynch seems like a good idea right now. There's still the risk of getting a miss and straight losing the game. That said, same is true if we don't lynch and the Vigilante just... goes all vigilante and kills a townsperson.

Lynch Anzekay

Seems to have built up the most suspicion today along with Mal and likely myself. Since there's a reasonable chance the Vigilante gets us killed today anyway, might as well try something that is within our power.

And no, the Vigilante was not me. Ashe definitely wouldn't have been my first target.

[Sophia]

So, a lot of people seem to be suspicious of Anzekay. Mal seems suspicious, but I'm not sure if that's because he's actually being suspicious or because it's just Mal. Could go either way on that one.

Soph: What makes you think you've made your innocence obvious? I may have missed something.

Keiko: Yeah, inactives should get lynched in my opinion. That opinion, as it turns out, carried a bit of weight. Is it fair? Not really. Does that change my opinion on it? Sadly, no.

I keep going back and forth on whether or not a lynch seems like a good idea right now. There's still the risk of getting a miss and straight losing the game. That said, same is true if we don't lynch and the Vigilante just... goes all vigilante and kills a townsperson.

Lynch Anzekay

Seems to have built up the most suspicion today along with Mal and likely myself. Since there's a reasonable chance the Vigilante gets us killed today anyway, might as well try something that is within our power.

And no, the Vigilante was not me. Ashe definitely wouldn't have been my first target.

The vigilante might not have targeted Ashe.

I'm going to go ahead and unlynch. I might revisit it before I go to bed tonight.

[King B]

I don't see the reasoning behind the vigilante taking out Ashe. Ashe had been one of the more sensible people, and I would've kept him around for the sake of the townies. Somehow I trusted Ashe was a townie, didn't think that he would've been a sheriff though. Reading everything above, even though I am not completely on the same boat as Mario, the plausible suspicion does not lie. Which means I will go ahead and Unlynch.

Either I end up looking like a complete jackass here, or we save the townies and live to see another day. Common enemy makes us allies. Lynch Anzekay