Workshop Sig Tournament; Janemba vs Kid Buu

[Alura]

VS



Subject: Videl

Theme: Dark

Font: Videl + anything you want

Judging: Public Vote to 5

*When posting your sig, explain in a couple sentences how it ties into your theme.

[Alura]

Kid Buu
The picture seems kinda cut wrong, to me, but maybe that's just how it's positioned. I personally really like it, but then again, I'm easy to please.

[Hellfighter 17]

Originally posted by Kid Buu


This signature ties into the theme of dark for a few key factors. First is just the general darkness of the signature, except around Videl for she is the figure of light. Her emotional expression is one that represents a great loss of some kind. The glowing balls on the right are supposed to look as though they are actually tears being carried away from Videl's eyes by the wind. Scan lines, to me, also give it that freeze frame feel of when something does go wrong.

Enjoy.

I really, really like it, man. It really does seem like a "freeze frame," too. I think the colour scheme helps with that. I just don't htink the font is a very good choice. Plus, the thicker strip coming from Videl the one with a black "tear" just sticks out to much for me. Otherwise, it looks simply scrumptious.

[Toshiro]

Ermm.. Never good at summing things up

This goes with the darkness theme becuase, to me, the fear shown on Videl's face show's how she is going thou a dark era at that time. While the image on the left show's how brave she can be, but also hold a sense of darkness to her concerning whom she may be fighting.

Sorry for that being so crap, like I said, not great at those thing's

[Alura]

Janemba
Okay, so, yea, it's not too pleasent to look at. I think the big mistake was the image on the left. Had you left that out and maybe moved the font to the left a bit, I would of liked it. The image on the right is dead on and perfect with your theme.

That said, public vote is now officially open. Any votes before this arn't counted. Please only vote based on the SIG, not the person or the description. If you are in the tournament, you may not vote.

You MUST give reasons.

That said, I vote for Kid Buu simply because it flows better and all around looks more like a decent signature.

[Alura]

VS





Burter's Vote- Kid Buu

[Hellfighter 17]

Originally posted by Janemba


Ermm.. Never good at summing things up

This goes with the darkness theme becuase, to me, the fear shown on Videl's face show's how she is going thou a dark era at that time. While the image on the left show's how brave she can be, but also hold a sense of darkness to her concerning whom she may be fighting.

Sorry for that being so crap, like I said, not great at those thing's

I really like the pic on the right, it follows the theme very well. It really makes Videl seem on the malevolent side, which goes with dark. Though, Kid Buu's does portray fear farely well, I feel that fear doesn't go with dark as much as molevolence, so. . .Janemba, I choose you!

[Alura]

I'm inclined to agree with Bojack. How can you not see the dark on Kid Buu's? You do know it doesn't have to literally BE dark to have a theme of dark, right?

I'm surprised by the turnout so far, it seemed to me that KB wiped it clean, but hey, it's the members choice.

Like Bojack said, 3-2 for Janemba so far. First to 5 wins

[Hellfighter 17]

Originally posted by Burter
I'm inclined to agree with Bojack. How can you not see the dark on Kid Buu's? You do know it doesn't have to literally BE dark to have a theme of dark, right?

I'm surprised by the turnout so far, it seemed to me that KB wiped it clean, but hey, it's the members choice.

Like Bojack said, 3-2 for Janemba so far. First to 5 wins

I realize that. I just feel that it has more of a fear for overall, which can tie into drakness, but not as much as Janemba's.

4-2 for Janemba.

[Jonathan Meer]

I must vote for Kid Buu's as well. While Janemba's does seem darker, Kid Buu's still has the dark theme going on. Plus, it's more visually pleasing. The biggest problem with Janemba's is the text. It doesn't blend well at all, and the font sucks.

4-4.

[Alura]

Originally posted by Furiza
It's 5 to Janemba. Janemba wins.

So either KB's wasn't portraying darkness well or everyone else is blind.

Uh, no. It's 4-4

[Toshiro]

I was aboutto say, where the hell did that extra vote come from..

[Alura]

Yea. 4 to 4.

First match, talk about close.

Next vote will decide it. Think carefully.

[Hellfighter 17]

I thought that Furiza's vote counts as two. I guess I was wrong.

Either way, I just want to say that both sigs were excellent.

[Alura]

Originally posted by Recoome
You can take my vote off Burter. Good idea to make it public, but idiocy intervenes as usual.

No. You voted. It stays. You can just not vote next time if you don't want it to count

[Hellfighter 17]

Originally posted by Kid Buu
It's shocking how some of you don't have any artistic sense or comprehension. Stupidity here once again surprises me.

I guess we should just ban opinions then, huh?

[Alura]

Originally posted by Hell Fighter 17

Originally posted by Kid Buu
It's shocking how some of you don't have any artistic sense or comprehension. Stupidity here once again surprises me.

I guess we should just ban opinions then, huh?

Didn't you get the memo he sent? If you don't agree with Kid Buu, you must be wrong.

Anyway, still 4-4. One last vote.

[Hellfighter 17]

Originally posted by Burter

Originally posted by Hell Fighter 17

Originally posted by Kid Buu
It's shocking how some of you don't have any artistic sense or comprehension. Stupidity here once again surprises me.

I guess we should just ban opinions then, huh?

Didn't you get the memo he sent? If you don't agree with Kid Buu, you must be wrong.

Anyway, still 4-4. One last vote.

I did, but I was out of newspaper for my bird's cage. Actually I wasn't, but still.

Well, congratulations, KB, your sig was very good.

[Alura]

Originally posted by Burter
If you are in the tournament, you may not vote.

4-4

>.<

[Rem-13]

*Votes Kid Buu*

It does give me the sense of darkness, not as much as janemba's, but look at it. In addition to that is very well done, its very clear and pleasing to look at. I think Kid Buu deserves the win.