Posts: 66
Threads: 1,078
Joined: Aug 2004
Nice job with the scriptures. I think you did an excellent proving the point you were trying to and it seems evident that you held back on many more points for retorts. Can't wait until I get the chance to respond.
"We're just two lost souls swimming in a fish bowl."
![[Image: HFSeventeen.jpg]](http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v687/hf17/HFSeventeen.jpg)
Posts: 0
Threads: 200
Joined: Feb 2006
WTF is all this about gay marriage?
I think gay marriage is wrong, so I am against it. People should only marry and have SEX with those of the opposite gender that they were designed for in 80% of all religions. I do think it is wrong to take someone away from someone you love, but loving another man or woman is wrong, and they can just skip to Japan or something.
****************
***MORE SOON***
****************
Posts: 66
Threads: 1,078
Joined: Aug 2004
No, there will not be more soon. You are receiving a warning, since Lucifer said no discussing the topic itself, and you are banned form this thread. If you post in it again, another warning.
"We're just two lost souls swimming in a fish bowl."
![[Image: HFSeventeen.jpg]](http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v687/hf17/HFSeventeen.jpg)
Posts: 56
Threads: 218
Joined: Nov 2004
Yeah, very good job, Lucifer. A bit harsh, but effective at getting your point across. You want to go next, HF, or me?
Posts: 15
Threads: 60
Joined: Mar 2006
Wow. That was an amazing argument you put up Lucifer. I'm glad I'm not your opponent. ^_^;
Posts: 154
Threads: 759
Joined: Nov 2005
You never fail to impress me, Will. You make me proud to be bisexual.
I wish I put Kirano in the debate. His arguement was hilariously dumb.
Posts: 63
Threads: 81
Joined: Jun 2004
William you genius, fantastic arguement.
Posts: 56
Threads: 218
Joined: Nov 2004
Alright, I'll have my argument up after I get back from work.
Posts: 7
Threads: 124
Joined: Dec 2005
Quote:Originally posted by Kirano
WTF is all this about gay marriage?
I think gay marriage is wrong, so I am against it. People should only marry and have SEX with those of the opposite gender that they were designed for in 80% of all religions. I do think it is wrong to take someone away from someone you love, but loving another man or woman is wrong, and they can just skip to Japan or something.
****************
***MORE SOON***
****************
I hope Vegeta beats the shit out of you in anyway he can. You pretty much said all those people on the East side of the world are gay.
EDIT: You pretty much also said they are worthless. You my friend are one stupid bastard.
Nice job Lucifer, that was really good even tho I'm against it. But nice job nonetheless.
EDIT2: And thanks for who ever deleted that other post, like I just woke up so...ya, no idea what I was doing >.<
Xbox Live GT: GoDzLeftHanD
Posts: 61
Threads: 398
Joined: Oct 2005
I'm not Christian, but I was still really impressed with your points and backup. Very enjoyable to read your argument.
Bra Wrote:People are dumb, essentially.
Posts: 23
Threads: 148
Joined: Aug 2005
That was...Pretty awesome, really. It'll be a bit difficult to defend against that.
Though I bet 20 and HF know what they're doing.
Posts: 169
Threads: 575
Joined: Oct 2001
I don't see a way for anyone to beat Will there. I am already completely in agreement with all of his points, but his wording was perfect.
"I'm gonna fuck that unicorrrrrn"
Posts: 0
Threads: 39
Joined: Feb 2006
Quote:Originally posted by Burter Jr
You never fail to impress me, Will. You make me proud to be bisexual.
If I were a creeper I would hide in... your closet. Or under your bed, you know, depending on the weather.
Posts: 11
Threads: 193
Joined: Apr 2006
Will if I were gay, would you marry me?
Edit: What I mean to say is I though that was amazing and I think I love you...in a hetero kind of way.
Posts: 56
Threads: 218
Joined: Nov 2004
*shakes head*
That wasn't the best I could do really, but me and Luc are shooting at two different topics. I'm going legal, he's going religion. That got the main point I was trying to get across, but there was more I wanted to discuss, that didn't pertain to why it should or shouldn't be allowed. Hopefully Luc or Vi will try to refute my points so I'll have something more to work with. Legal is what I'm good at.
Posts: 6
Threads: 76
Joined: Aug 2005
You both did very well.
Lucifer- Superb quoting of the Bible, you made some good points. Your argument is very convincing, i'd hate to be against you.
20- You emphasized the legal portion of it, and how it would affect the church and religion. Good Job.
I see this as an interesting debate, I can't wait to read more.
I also thought i'd add that I think it's ironic that the person arguing the religious aspect has the character name 'Lucifer'. (Yes, I know that Lucifer is technically Satan's name while he was an Angel supposedly and means 'Light Bringer'. But we've come to use it as a synonym for the Devil.)
Posts: 112
Threads: 443
Joined: Dec 2002
Halfway through your post, Will. I'm just throwing this here so I don't forget it.
The first thing that caught me was how you leapt straight into the whole "religion" topic. There was hardly a transition to speak of, leaving your reader littel time to switch over to considering that topic. I, for one, was lucky it was written down, because, had you been speaking this argument, I would have completely missed your next point.
The whole "bible quote" thing, while effective, was definitely watered down by the fact that all but three of your quotes (and all of the one used for the bulk of the first half of your post) came from the same book. Instead of maintaining a strong poignant argument, it just became "we get it, this dude wanted to kill everyone." I understand that the bible isn't exactly the shortest read ever, but citings from multiple books would have drastically improved the effectiveness of what you said.
Something that you had problems with (from my point of view) in the beginning were your broader, sweeping generalizations about those who you were arguing against. "God is the weapon of the bigot," " person deserves fewer rights than anyone else because they are different in a way they cannot change," "put an end to every teenage girl on her period too." Yes, those quotes were taken a bit out of context, but generalizations about things like this can easily switch people from thinking about your argument and start thinking things like "but I don't treat gays like that." And that's not helpful to anyone's case. As it went on, you got away from that, but its something I would keep in mind.
[added below]
Several times you used the phrase "many Christian groups" or some variation of that. While its probably understood that there are many Christian groups opposed to homosexuality, that argument loses weight when your target is left that vague and generalized. Citing who said what probably wouldn't take much more than a couple minutes on Google and then gives the imaginary target you're taking swings at real form.
I was really thrown by the whole Soddom and Gamorrah bit, since I don't know that story from the bible. Since it was summarized in a single sentence, that didn't help either. I'm only mentioning this because you stated, before your quote, that this was one of the most referenced arguments "many Christian groups turn to for justification of their condemnation." My exact thought after reading through that bit was "yeah, so?" Admittedly, had I been judging this debate I would have done my own research on the subject, but making assumptions about your general readership's knowledge base is still a bad idea.
Hope you found that useful, Will.
"In this world, his world, life is just a game you play"
Posts: 154
Threads: 759
Joined: Nov 2005
Nobody start arguements. Rad is criticizing, he's not shooting on Will about the topic. He's just talking about the post itself.
I don't want someone to start debating here
Posts: 112
Threads: 443
Joined: Dec 2002
Thanks, BJ. I knew Will would see what I was doing for what it was, but I didn't think to actually add a foreword to that.
I'll do the same for 20, if he doesn't object. I just assumed brit would welcome the critique.
"In this world, his world, life is just a game you play"
Posts: 154
Threads: 759
Joined: Nov 2005
Quote:Originally posted by Raditzu
Thanks, BJ. I knew Will would see what I was doing for what it was, but I didn't think to actually add a foreword to that.
I'll do the same for 20, if he doesn't object. I just assumed brit would welcome the critique.
*points to Kirano's post up top*
|