Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Debate Discussion Thread
#21
Nah, I'd actually like to hear what I did wrong.
[Image: Ruhiel.png]
Reply
#22
First thing I thought when I saw 20's post: "ouch." The length kills your first impression. I understand it can sometimes be hard to really draw things out, but when you're following something as protracted as Will's quote-a-thon, responding with the appropriate presentation is a must.

Also, you're comment about how you feel, personally came off as both redundant and irrelivant. You guys aren't arguing against each other, per se, you're arguing against the topic at hand. Its inferred that you're against gay marriage because of the side you're arguing for.

"Our country prides itself on having complete separation of church and state (although it has been proven that this line has sometimes become a bit blurred and abused)"

Two serious problems with that: 1) no where does the topic say you are talking about the United States. The opponent who posted directly before you, in fact, is not; "our country" doesn't mean anything to him. Additionally, you have an audience comprised of people from Canada, Austrailia, Europe, and Africa: make sure to keep that in mind when talking about the laws of a specific country.

The second problem is that you should never durectly contradict yourself in an argument. For anyreason. What you're saying is fact, it your opponent has a problem with that, its on them to prove otherwise. While its commendible of you to try and PC about your arguments, its a wasted effort. You lose the effectiveness of your points and end up coming off as 'wishy-washy' about your side of the argument.

You were at a fairly huge disadvantage for getting the second post. It fell on you to rebute your opponent's opening (which, really, sets the tone for the entire debate) as well as setting the foundation for your side of the debate. You did a decent enough job of getting yourself set up, but you didn't really try to break through the other side's arguments.

Just so ya know, I mean absolutely nothing personal with any of these remarks.
[Image: RadOct.jpg]
"In this world, his world, life is just a game you play"
Reply
#23
Yeah, it took me about 5 minutes to realize that after I had said that "our country" thing, and I instantly went "doh!" Regardless, the separation of church and state holds true in the three big countries here, I believe.

And thanks for the comments. I simply couldn't attack Luc's argument, as that's not where I disagree with gay marriage. I'll do better to refute the opposition's arguments next time, as I also wasn't really sure if we were supposed to be attacking one another's statements to prove them wrong, or just put up our reasoning. I wasn't sure what separated "arguing" and "refuting."

My next post will be based on facts only. I suppose I did allow my own opinions to get too much in the way. I'm going to start doing my research for my next argument then. Going to take a while though, as I now fully realize that this isn't solely about the US. >.<
[Image: Ruhiel.png]
Reply
#24
Hehehe, alright, HF, you can go next. Vi's got me going now. =D

Good post Vi, but you seemed to jump around a lot from the topic of gay marriage itself. Such as the war in Iraq (which is one way to get me going, that's for sure XD), but regardless, you had some good logical reasoning behind your argument. But I think you sorta pulled what I did, as Rad pointed out to me, with the whole, lacking direct factual backing of your claims. You made some pretty extreme claims in your post, but that's what makes debates fun and interesting, right?

Regardless, you presented it well, and had a good logical chain of thought behind your reasoning, comparing it to other issues in the past that may seem similar to this. Such as the "male superiority" example you provided, that was a good connection.
[Image: Ruhiel.png]
Reply
#25
lol, the idea was better in my head. Things are always better in my head. The connection was thourough, (to me anyway) and all connected, if you read it enough times, you'll see the whole linkning together. I brought the examples I did in because all of it is just a bunch of bullshit propaganda brought on to spark malice in the people. Just another sheet to throw over our minds and make us think not for ourselves, but as a group. A person is intelligent, but put them together, and they are dumber than a box of rocks, you see what I am saying? Alot of information being fed to us is supposed to make us think as a group, not as an individual.


But anyhoo, the other half of my debate will go up after some rebuttals. ^_^
[Image: visigjune08_v2.jpg]

Fuck you, Photobucket.
Reply
#26
The paragraph including the Ten Commandments didn't really seem to fit in. You just seemed to state how there are other big issues out there and say that you thought it wrong with not much backing. Get on AIM, Twenty. I need to discuss this with you.
"We're just two lost souls swimming in a fish bowl."
[Image: HFSeventeen.jpg]
Reply
#27
Quote:Originally posted by Hercule
20, you tried to counter on the religion front and failed. Firstly you gave an entire paragraph that as far as I could see only fortified Lucifer's position. Also, you didn't make your sources and representations more obvious and you didn't build your arguement around the ones you used. Instead you continued on to the next area, in a way that leads me to believe your gonna run out of steam early. Seconding a motion is the only thing that gets it off the ground. Your arguement is twice as strong when its backed by something, even Wikipedia. As it stands, you stood in front of Lucifer and he ran you over.

While I appreciate the criticism, not a bit of my argument was on the religious front. Just to let you know. I didn't attack Luc's stance whatsoever, I just established my side of the argument, which is the legal side. It just appears that Luc ran me over because he established his side of the argument more thoroughly than I did.

And Luc, thank you so much for entering the legal front. I was sitting here thinking I couldn't touch you until you refuted HF's claims. Not meaning to sound offensive with that, it's just that you were kind of extreme in your examples, and it gives me something to finally fire back with. I suppose I'll go next then, if that's alright with everyone?
[Image: Ruhiel.png]
Reply
#28
I'm really impressed with the effort Lucy put into his arguments. Your first post really drew a nice line of contact, you set the issue on your own terms and made the other side fight on your own battefield.

Violet, your argumant sounded to passionate, more argumentitive than debating, and adressing Kirano in your debate just kinda killed what the format was supposed to create, a place for logical debate not arguing, spam, and flaming.

HF and 20, you've got a perfectly legitamate argument, but you both are trying to fight on the terms Lucy is setting, instead of bringing the debate to your point, the difference between the religious ceremony and legal privledges. You need to make a propsal instead of repeating: "We don't hate them, it's the ceremony" and issue a compromise that will appease both sides.
[Image: Yamusig3copy.jpg]

Dante's Abyss 2007 Runner-Up
Reply
#29
Quote:Originally posted by Yamu
Violet, your argumant sounded to passionate, more argumentitive than debating, and adressing Kirano in your debate just kinda killed what the format was supposed to create, a place for logical debate not arguing, spam, and flaming.

I wasn't deliberately trying to flame or spam, but simply addressing his previous comment about Japan and homosexuality. The whole point of that section was to inform about the history and the reasoning behind it.


The rest, well....We'll see in my rebuttal.
[Image: visigjune08_v2.jpg]

Fuck you, Photobucket.
Reply
#30
When Rad criticizes, it's cool, because he actually knows what he's talking about.

Hercule, you sound like you're just trying to make yourself seem more intelligent and failing miserably.
Reply
#31
Way to suck gokua.
Reply
#32
Quote:Originally posted by Murasaki
Way to suck gokua.


Where did that come from?
[Image: 1stAerosig.png]
Placed 3rd in Dante's Abyss 08
Reply
#33
Quote:Originally posted by Burter Jr
NOBODY POSTS HERE BUT THE PLAYERS OR STAFF ISSUEING A WARNING. I WILL WARN FOR INTERUPTIONS
Reply
#34
Will; your second last post had some good points, but there were some weak ones as well that can easily be exploited. Your latest one, though, was just plain bad. =\ It seemed as though you gave up when you were doing it pretty well.

Twenty; your latest one was magnificent.
"We're just two lost souls swimming in a fish bowl."
[Image: HFSeventeen.jpg]
Reply
#35
Didn't see that one, hehe. Anyway, my bad.
[Image: 1stAerosig.png]
Placed 3rd in Dante's Abyss 08
Reply
#36
Man, I jsut editted that post for nothing. I still got warned. Ahh honeybuns. >.<



Hell, I feel like debating now.
[Image: 1stAerosig.png]
Placed 3rd in Dante's Abyss 08
Reply
#37
Editing got yea off the hook. Pay attention next time, though.
"We're just two lost souls swimming in a fish bowl."
[Image: HFSeventeen.jpg]
Reply
#38
Yeah, that's not exactly my forte as you may know by now. Thanks though.
[Image: 1stAerosig.png]
Placed 3rd in Dante's Abyss 08
Reply
#39
Quote:Uh, I believe the appropriate response I'm thinking of here would be "WTF?"

Comparing me to Adolf Hitler? I think you've misinterpreted what I said above. Evolution was brought onto the table, used by both you and Hellfighter. I simply pointed out the blatantly obvious fact that homosexual couples can't reproduce, and in terms of evolution, can't futher the advancement of the species. There was no attack within anything I said against homosexuals, or attempting to make them inferior. So please, if you would, refrain from comparing me to a madman, thank you.

Yes, they will always exist. Yes they are still human beings, and are treated as such. But you can't take away the rights of the Church not to acknowledge their right to marry. Regardless, my point still stands, and am waiting to be convinced otherwise.



Why do people keep saying that homosexuals can't reproduce? >.<


This was basically a defensive standpoint for A20.

Also, Hitler wasn't a madman, he was the anti-christ.
[Image: 1stAerosig.png]
Placed 3rd in Dante's Abyss 08
Reply
#40
Quote:Originally posted by Dictionary.com
re?pro?duce Audio pronunciation of "reproduce" ( P )
Pronunciation Key (rpr-ds, -dys)
v. re?pro?duced, re?pro?duc?ing, re?pro?duc?es

1. To generate offspring.
2. To undergo copying: graphics that reproduce well.

Because they can't. Its biologically impossible.

Regardless, this thread is not to post your own views on arguments made, that's up to the debaters. If you have something to say about the discussion itself, then go for it.
[Image: RadOct.jpg]
"In this world, his world, life is just a game you play"
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)