Kirano's Showcase

[Sullivan]

Double post, so to give C&C on Kirano.

Your work is better than mine was when I first started, I dunno if you're a beginner or not, but nothing you've done is too shabby. My favorite is the Cargo sig, though if you stroked the outside with a 1 pxl black border it would be a little more to write home about.

The latest is good, and I can tell the difference...they have different borders. Good work, keep on going, because you're getting better with everything you post in my opinion.

EDIT: Oh. >.>

Beat me here. Sorry Kirano, didn't mean to clutter up your sig thread. Just felt like I needed to clear that up, because lots of people judge Tom and Baron based on their C&C...rather than their work.

[Sullivan]

Quite welcome.

[Captain Silver]

Originally posted by Grandpa Gohan
Tch. Don't listen to Pui, him and Gokua are grinches on graphics

I told him I was going to be fair and strict. That is why he asked me.

And the I won't bother repeating what Kiro said because those are the reasons why me and Gokua are strict. Hell, we are strict on each others work. So yeah, Doug.

Edit:

Also, know your audience. Just because you hang with people who are 'perfect' graphic artists, doesnt mean that everyone is, and it should change from person to person.

Thats why it's so hard to give CnC.

We base our CnC off the scale from the greater artists that we've seen, and we won't change that just because you don't like it. Sure, it doesn't win us a lot of friends. But if people can't take my honest opinions and help then why should I care? Kirano even thanked me on AIM for my honest opinion.

Oh yeah, thanks Kiro for explaining that to Gramps.

[Grandpa Gohan]

Originally posted by Pui Pui

Originally posted by Grandpa Gohan
Tch. Don't listen to Pui, him and Gokua are grinches on graphics

I told him I was going to be fair and strict. That is why he asked me.

And the I won't bother repeating what Kiro said because those are the reasons why me and Gokua are strict. Hell, we are strict on each others work. So yeah, Doug.

Edit:

Also, know your audience. Just because you hang with people who are 'perfect' graphic artists, doesnt mean that everyone is, and it should change from person to person.

Thats why it's so hard to give CnC.

We base our CnC off the scale from the greater artists that we've seen, and we won't change that just because you don't like it. Sure, it doesn't win us a lot of friends. But if people can't take my honest opinions and help then why should I care? Kirano even thanked me on AIM for my honest opinion.

Oh yeah, thanks Kiro for explaining that to Gramps.

I know exactly why you grade the way you do. But is it 'fair' to grades someone work in contrast to the best sig artist you've seen, ESPECIALLY if theyre a begginer? Doubt it.

Granted, I give my honest opinions, if it sucks, then well Im gunna say that, if they dont like it, too bad. I dont EVER compare people to the best sig artists I've seen, cause I've seen some damn fine ones, Yourself and Gokua among those.

So yeah, Tom.

Editsu: If you and Kiro wanna cont. this or w/e you know my aim/msn. I PM'd Cel a reply that was gunna go in here, to avoid spamming his thread up, and so Im gunna stop posting in this thread about this. -_^

[Captain Silver]

Edited out because i'd rather not argue with you dude, because I actually think your a cool guy. One of the coolest on Chubbs because I actually took to you so fast. =o So yeah, sorry.