Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Body Split = Multiplier?
#1
So yeah. I've decided to start giving suggestions again. I decided it was better to get the ideas out, so that even if they rot at the bottom of the failure pool, I can at least say I gave it a shot. I'm going to try and pace myself by giving these suggestions one at a time, as a courtesy so that I don't overwhelm the staff. Throughout this gruelling series, I'm likely going to be trying your patience. I know that arguing over these things probably stresses you staffers out, but know that that is not my intention. I just want to try and improve the RPG. I know your immediate reaction is to try and defend the things I'll be criticising, but I ask you to try and keep an open mind.

Anyway, the first topic is a old favourite technique of mine which I think has gotten stale and is in need of revitalisation. Body Split.

What's my problem with the technique? The mechanics. This is something I have never quite understood. Right now, Body Split is effectively a multiplier. For those lazy folk who can't be assed to click on the main site:

Quote:Your ki gets reduced by 10% mutliplied by the amount of "selves" you become. If you split into two, both are at 80%, if split into three, all are at 70%, etcetera. If your selves get beaten down and forced back into one body, you get weakened by 5% multiplied by the amount of extra selves you had in addition to your weakened state of getting beaten

IMO, this is a confusing and over-complicated version of the show's Body Split. The problem is that the regular "your powerlevel is split by the number of bodies" has somehow been made into a multiplier.

Take, for example, Cell. When transformed, his powerlevel is roughly 50,000,000. When he splits into two bodies, you'd expect this to be split equally, but somehow his power level increases. With two bodies at 80% each, he now has a combined power level of 80,000,000. But that's only the tip of the iceberg. With three bodies, his power level more than doubles, ending up at 105,000,000 combined. With four bodies, 120,000,000, and with five bodies, the maximum of 125 million.

I love Body Split and intend to train for it someday, but I still don't see the need for such a complicated and potentially overpowering system. What's bizarre is that there is a 'best' number - five. If you go beyond this number, the effectiveness starts to go downhill until you hit the maximum of nine bodies.

I think that gaining extra corporeal bodies is enough of a benefit in itself. There are some IC situations where you want to have all your power in one body, and others where it's advantageous to split up. There need be no 'incentive' for splitting up by making the bodies stronger than they logically should be.

My suggestion is the obvious one: each body has a fraction of your powerlevel depending on how many bodies you split into. Two bodies at 50% each, four at 25% each, etc etc. This brings up the question of the limit. Either set it at nine (the old limit) or some new number, or make up a new system. You could have it as a mentals or powerlevel-based thing - the better your stats are, the more bodies you can split into.

I can think of a thousand suggestions, but this is the one that seems to me to be the best. It's simple, but it still makes a lot more sense than the way Body Split is handled right now. I can see how the current system can work, but I don't see why we should bother when there are much less confusing and much more sensical ways of dealing with it. Body Split isn't the most complicated technique out there. Tongue

Any alternative ideas are welcome. Keep it civil, and don't bother replying unless you've read everything, because I don't want to have to repeat myself. Wink Thanks.
[Image: superbuuelectricityne4.jpg]
Bra Wrote:People are dumb, essentially.
Reply
#2
I give it my stamp. Nice job.

Oh, and I like eight as a limit.
"We're just two lost souls swimming in a fish bowl."
[Image: HFSeventeen.jpg]
Reply
#3
The idea was for it to -be- a pseudo-multiplier. It was deliberate. O.o;

We used to have the system SB is talking about. It was scrapped.

Thus, I'm against it. I like body split being advantageous.
[Image: Sage.jpg]
Reply
#4
I like the "split by 50%, then 25%, so forth" idea
Reply
#5
Quote:Originally posted by Bra
The idea was for it to -be- a pseudo-multiplier. It was deliberate. O.o;
Is there any reason for that? My reasoning against was thus:

Quote:Originally posted by Super Buu
I think that gaining extra corporeal bodies is enough of a benefit in itself. There are some IC situations where you want to have all your power in one body, and others where it's advantageous to split up. There need be no 'incentive' for splitting up by making the bodies stronger than they logically should be.
In other words, it shouldn't be about the powerup; and in any case, it's supposed to be (as you yourself have said before) a fairly common technique. It's situational. For example, if you need to head down two different corridors, Body Split has massive advantages. And having two corporeal bodies, whilst weaker individually, allow you to work as a team. It's also confusing for your opponent trying to know where all of you are at all times.

Also:
Quote:We used to have the system SB is talking about. It was scrapped.
I knew it! There are never announcements when there are edits to the main site, so I always wonder whether I'm just crazy or whether it really did change. Back when it got changed, I was like "hrm ... that's a little weird."

Summised: I like the technique without it having to be a pseudo powerup.
[Image: superbuuelectricityne4.jpg]
Bra Wrote:People are dumb, essentially.
Reply
#6
Quote:Originally posted by Bra
The idea was for it to -be- a pseudo-multiplier. It was deliberate. O.o;

We used to have the system SB is talking about. It was scrapped.

Thus, I'm against it. I like body split being advantageous.
Being advantageous in the sense that it can make a x40 technique a x100?

I really think this was just not noticed. Vegeta Junior made the change one year ago, and I think he meant, and it was interpreted, that the combined ki of two split bodies equals ninety percent of the original ki. His English isn't the best, though.

Also, seeing how we classify body split as decent, I doubt we were aware of this.
"We're just two lost souls swimming in a fish bowl."
[Image: HFSeventeen.jpg]
Reply
#7
I like SB's idea, but at the same time, I don't.

I mean, all together it makes comeplete sense, if you split bodies,the combined power level is still equal to that of the full version, but if say I'm fighting someone who's slightly stronger than me, then I split, then he's facing two of me that are 50% weaker and that person would EASILY defeat me, thus making Body Split more of a problem than anything else.

EX:

Piccolo vs. Cell

Cell 2,481,875 99,275,000(pretend he has his x40 >.>)
Piccolo 2,442,000 98,680,000

Cell at full power: 99,275,000
Piccolo at body split(2 bodies): 49,340,000

- Look at the huge drop in advantage, if we take power level into accont, Cell woud more than likely kill both Piccolos.

Cell at full power: 99,275,000
Piccolo at body split(4 bodies): 24,670,000
- No way Piccolo could win. =(


Old way

Cell: 99,275,000
Piccolo(2): 78,944,000
- Much better chance for victory.

Cell: 99,275,000
Piccolo(4): 39,472,000
- Stronger than SB's versoin by about 15,000,000 and only weaker than 2 bodies splits by 10,000,000... here there would be a small chance for victory, but with the extra 15 mil and 4 extra bodies, then Piccolo stands a real chance.
I guess I'm kind of in between.
Reply
#8
Quote:Originally posted by Hell Fighter 17
I really think this was just not noticed.

Incorrect. The technique is a "power up" because it was made that way.

The old Body Split had taken the same path that Spirit Bomb did. It was perceived as a worthless technique, with the exception of providing mindless roleplaying fodder. And indeed that was the case. When people actually tried to use it in a fight, they found that they ended up intentionally putting themselves at a huge disadvantage.

What you're looking at incorrectly, Super Buu, is your "maximum ki" figure. Just because four characters have 250,000 ki individually doesn't mean they fight together at the level of a fighter with one million ki. Even if all four of the weaker characters punch the stronger character at the same time, he's not going to feel any of them.

Let's put this into Chubbs terms:

Super Buu -> Max ki = 34,540,000
Raditzu -> Max ki = 168,025,000

By your logic, five of you should be able to match one of me, but that's not the case. Raditzu could systematically destroy each one of the Super Buus while completely ignoring the attacks from all the others.

My point being that splitting your power, even with the current Body Split formula, doesn't mean you can add up the individual clone's ki and say "since they all are this strong, its like one of me with a boost of times X." If you keep this in mind when looking at the numbers for splitting into multiple forms, its not nearly as powerful as you seem to think.

Obviously this is being stated in terms of power level only, as that is the argument you presented. Its impossible to take into account all of the different levels of writing abilities when looked at under the tastes of all the different possible judges.
[Image: Kaden2.jpg]
"It's on my brain, driving me insane.  It's on my mind, all of
the time, and if it left... I would be fine.
"
Reply
#9
Hmm...Piccolo has a point. But, say when a copy is killed, that copy's energy returns to the original. So, you have four copies, Piccolo, Cell kills one, and then you have the same power as the other two copies comibined. How does that sound everyone?
Reply
#10
Quote:Originally posted by Piccolo
I mean, all together it makes comeplete sense, if you split bodies,the combined power level is still equal to that of the full version, but if say I'm fighting someone who's slightly stronger than me, then I split, then he's facing two of me that are 50% weaker and that person would EASILY defeat me, thus making Body Split more of a problem than anything else.

That's exactly what the problem was before, Piccolo.

I completely acknowledge that the Body Split technique, according to Chubbs, does not follow the logic of the technique in the show, but this is a game. Things have to be rebalanced to take into account the fact that Toriyama hasn't already written out how the fight goes, regardless of which techniques are used.
[Image: Kaden2.jpg]
"It's on my brain, driving me insane.  It's on my mind, all of
the time, and if it left... I would be fine.
"
Reply
#11
yup, and that's why I'm inbetween.

Logically, it makes sense the other way, just by the math and what not, but for any real advantage, the current way is the better way to have an actual advantage.
Reply
#12
Quote:Originally posted by Raditzu
What you're looking at incorrectly, Super Buu, is your "maximum ki" figure. Just because four characters have 250,000 ki individually doesn't mean they fight together at the level of a fighter with one million ki. Even if all four of the weaker characters punch the stronger character at the same time, he's not going to feel any of them.
Well ... that doesn't make a lot of sense. The punches should still do damage, just a quarter of the damage they would normally do. I disagree with Piccolo's argument on the same principle.

It seems to me like people just weren't being creative enough. Obviously splitting your body holds no advantages in pure power - or at least, it shouldn't. That's what Fusion is for. The advantage comes from the fact that you're coming from four different directions. Three of you can grab the opponent whilst one more charges up a Kamehameha. Sure, it's less powerful, but it gives you a lot more control over the battle.

Body Split isn't supposed to be about brute force, it's a strategical thing. Thus why Piccolo and the others used it in the show to try and take down stronger opponents (though that was more of a surprise tactic, and didn't work Tongue). Techniques should be situational, and Body Split is a great example of this. It's a decent technique, but it shouldn't be something you use every single battle to increase your chances of winning.

Or as Peppy would say: use bombs wisely.
[Image: superbuuelectricityne4.jpg]
Bra Wrote:People are dumb, essentially.
Reply
#13
Why would it work that way, Rad? Unless ki work exponentially, which I see no reason why it would, the figures would simply add up in the manner Super Buu described. Say all five of them started charging a kamehameha in line. Upon launching it, the five beams would come together, and wouldn't the force simply add up? The same would then be said of rcombiend kicks, combined punches, combined whatever.
"We're just two lost souls swimming in a fish bowl."
[Image: HFSeventeen.jpg]
Reply
#14
Quote:Originally posted by Hell Fighter 17
Why would it work that way, Rad? Unless ki work exponentially, which I see no reason why it would, the figures would simply add up in the manner Super Buu described. Say all five of them started charging a kamehameha in line. Upon launching it, the five beams would come together, and wouldn't the force simply add up? The same would then be said of rcombiend kicks, combined punches, combined whatever.
Indeed. I'm aware that in the show, the big guys would kick the shit out of weaker fighters without fail, but I was under the impression that for the purposes of fairness (ie newbies having some sort of chance against high-powered folk) and the fact that this is a game, Chubbs didn't use the exponentially scaling system. Tongue
[Image: superbuuelectricityne4.jpg]
Bra Wrote:People are dumb, essentially.
Reply
#15
Quote:Originally posted by Hell Fighter 17
Why would it work that way, Rad? Unless ki work exponentially, which I see no reason why it would, the figures would simply add up in the manner Super Buu described. Say all five of them started charging a kamehameha in line. Upon launching it, the five beams would come together, and wouldn't the force simply add up? The same would then be said of rcombiend kicks, combined punches, combined whatever.

The way I see it is this.

If four people threw a 1/4" pebble at a window, they'd probably bounce off, but if you take a full 1" rock and throw it at the window, it'll shatter.

>.> I was going somewhere with this, but I forget now.

But yeah, I think the technique is fine as is, but I wouldn't fret over it changing, I mean, mathamatically it'd make more sense SB's way, but advantage wise, the current way takes the cake.
Reply
#16
I think it mainly has to do with conception.

I think of power levels like the levels of an RPG. A level 20 character, even five level 20s, aren't going to do jack shit against a level 100, hence the change to the current system, where five level 50s would be going against the level 100.

Overpowering? Not really, since you're not dealing with absolute numbers, but factoring in things like reduced toughness, speed at evading attacks, and whatnot into the ultimate damage that those "split fighters" can deal and take. Piccolo's analogy about the window is a good example about the limits of dividing your power.

And let's face it: in the show, this was pretty much the case. Weaker characters regularly didn't do anything at all against stronger opponents; they couldn't break the villain's "tank".

On the other hand, CDBZ, at least to my knowledge, has never been about the raw numbers game, and the overly mathematical explanation of Body Split seems a bit goofy when RP > everything else.

I don't think Body Split is really all that bad, just a sort of head scratcher in an area or two.
[Image: Bellesig6-1.jpg]
Reply
#17
Quote:Originally posted by Sno
I think of power levels like the levels of an RPG. A level 20 character, even five level 20s, aren't going to do jack shit against a level 100, hence the change to the current system, where five level 50s would be going against the level 100.

That's exactly what I was going for. You just worded it better.
[Image: Kaden2.jpg]
"It's on my brain, driving me insane.  It's on my mind, all of
the time, and if it left... I would be fine.
"
Reply
#18
I.. was going to say something Important that would blow you all away, but I can't remember it. Any of it.. argh..

I awknowledge both sides of this, but I have to lean more towards Rad's. This is Chubbs, not Dragonball Z. While this is *based* off of Dragonball Z, it is different. We do several things differently then what the show does, body split being one of those many things. Is that bad? Not really. At least not in my opinion.

I personally think that it is rather innovative to do Body Split the other way, its taking a old ability and putting a spin on it. I adore that.

While your idea, Super Buu, makes more sense, I personally would rather have it the other way. Mostly because if I have 100 Million Ki, and my Opponet has 100 Million Ki, I'm not going to roleplay beating them if I divide into four people, or even two. I *don't* imagine that is what would happen, and when roleplaying is what counts on this forum, that is a big difference.

In my mind, two people with Fifty Million Ki, even *two* people, tag teaming, shouldn't beat someone with One Hundred Million Ki. Never should that happen, unless the person is a goofball.

In the way you have it, it would be one of those moves that is of very poor quality, unless fighting a bunch of people weaker then you, or for those every so often moments, like going down two passages. While that in itself is pretty useful, I would rather be able to use it more as a technique.

Just my two cents, my cents that make almost as most sense as the bald spot slowly growing on the back of Hell Fighter 17's head.

>_> <_< ~Sticks Tongue out at Hell Fighter 17~
[Image: chidorihp1qgrq6.gif]
Reply
#19
With the level thing, level ten is not going to be just twice as good as level five, he is going to be about ten, and, if doubling happens, sixteen, times as good as him. Say we reduce one-hundred million ki to four ki and twenty-five million ki to one ki. Are you saying that instead of the former being four times stornger, he is going to be eight times stronger?

Also, my bald spot rocks.
"We're just two lost souls swimming in a fish bowl."
[Image: HFSeventeen.jpg]
Reply
#20
Bear in mind that RPGs have all sorts of things like armour in place, which nullify weaker attacks completely. This is not done for realism, but so that newbies can't easily destroy monsters they shouldn't be destroying. They have elite monsters if guys want to gang up to tackle 'bigger' game.

I can appreciate the 'one bigger stone works better than four little stones' logic, but I was still under the impression that Chubbs was a game, and powerlevels didn't work that way for the sake of fairness. It's not as though taking down a high-level person isn't difficult enough as it is. Tongue

This isn't for the sake of show logic. This is for the sake of not making things impossible for newbies.

You're also missing the point with your examples. Body Split isn't exclusively for one-on-one fights against powerful foes. For example, pit Rad against Rei in that example that's no longer there:

Raditzu -> 168,025,000 ki
Reijin -> 123,255,000 ki

You could argue that because of the 'exponential' thing, the extra power makes up the difference, putting four split warriors on the same level as Reijin where they wouldn't otherwise. That's dandy, but what about when fighting weaker warriors?

Raditzu -> 168,025,000 ki
5x Super Buu -> 34,540,000 ki

It looks as though the Buu squad has at least a snowball's chance in hell of winning, right? What about when we bring current Body Split into the equation?

5x Raditzu -> 84,012,500 ki
5x Super Buu -> 34,540,000 ki

Oh god oh god oh god I'm gonna die.

Whereas with new system:

5x Raditzu -> 33,605,000 ki
5x Super Buu -> 34,540,000 ki

Rad can still take on five of me, but it's a little less horrifically unfair.
[Image: superbuuelectricityne4.jpg]
Bra Wrote:People are dumb, essentially.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)