Waffia Aftermath

[Waffuru]

John Doe - Townsperson and Gun Collector, would return positive if checked by the Gunsmith
Rafael - Apprentice and Sibling, able to communicate with his sibling and able to assume any pro-town role if they were killed
Ashe - Townsperson and Never-sure, had to change his vote every post
Whompt - Doctor and Zoologist, I loved the secondary, best player evar
Kaden - Cop and Sibling
Vad - Godfather and John Doe fan, supposed to mention John Doe once a day
Jon Meer - Traitor and Typo, had to misspell a word in every post and Traitor returned pro-town if investigated until the mafia recruited him. He was recruited in the second night.
Orsalis - Townsperson and Artist, was supposed to include a picture in every post
Kole T Merr - Mafia goon and dictionary, had to use a 10 letter word in every post
Leo - Mafia spy, planted false evidence on Whompt and also he had cake
Rose - Gunsmith and Cocksure, unable to change vote once placed. Gunsmith could find out if someone owned a gun, which would've been mafia, cop and John Doe.
Kami - Townsperson and Weak Stomach, couldn't cast the lynching vote on anyone
Jarka - Townsperson and had the pardon to end a day phase, was shocked she lived long enough to make a difference with the pardon AND didn't pardon a mafia... especially since there was no confirmation of a false evidence mechanic and Whompt returned TWO positive "mafia" investigations.

Townspeople win. Meer was actually the last mafia, I was messing with you guys in the other thread. DERP!

[Rafael]

Never got to use my power lol, what're the odds?

[Jonathan Meer]

Let's hear the rationale, Mario. How were you apparently aware that there was an evidence-planter? How did you know I was Maf, despite Whompt clearly coming up as guilty in an earlier investigation?

[Waffuru]

Yeah, I definitely suspected someone was breaking the no talking about the game rule. :/

[John Doe]

WTF does "have cake" mean?

[Ashe]

I'll be honest - I absolutely suspected Kaden was mafia and just controlling the flow of the game by buying trust by sacrificing team mates. I wouldn't put such a bold move past him. That said, I wasn't certain by any means, but I hadn't ruled out that option.

It was interesting to see the conclusion. I assume what got me killed was the fact that the townspeople had finally stopped being on the rocks mostly about my alignment, which meant I was then a safe kill for mafia.

[John Doe]

btw I died because "You were annoying us."

[Blue]

Oh! Waff! When Rose investigated me... why did I come up positive for a gun? Was it because of the evidence being planted?

And yeah. I liked my secondary role too. I just wish I could have kept the puns up.

[Tyr]

WTF does "have cake" mean?

He gave me cake.

[John Doe]

So, pretty much as useless as a gun with no bullets, huh.

Man, I was so sure that you had some sorta retarded role. Or a questionable role. Turns out you were just mafia.

I'm glad Kaden managed to pull the win, though it still kinda shows how stupid powerful the sheriff role is.

[Tyr]

I was just poking at you really, for being an annoying cunt in the other games. : (

Also as a mafia, despite the traditional odds stacked against us, I read the roles now and feel like we were boned from start. I'm suspecting Rafael picked up Rose's role so we effectively had two sheriffs working together and Kaden just putting on a mask of "you were suspicious" to not out the advantage. Then Rafael suffered an accident.

[Blue]

I think Waff did a good job of providing roles to counteract the Sheriff. Both the Traitor and the Evidence Planter had ways to fool the Sheriff's senses.

[Tyr]

The Evidence Planter got counteracted by Jarka and the traitor got counteracted by the Apprentice, since it's sort of the townspeople version of the traitor (assuming a role beneficial to the faction). If we got a kill on a good role, he just snatched it and they would continue with communication. :z

e: why the fuck did I write counteract in two different ways in one post?

[Jonathan Meer]

Sheriff + sibling = op

4 mafia in a 13 person game = op

[Blue]

I don't know if the Gunsmith is really a pro-town role. Yeah, it provides information, but pretty vague information.

[Tyr]

It was annulled by the fact they were siblings. He knew his sibling wasn't a mafia, so it was a miss chance of 1 and we killed John Doe early because he was annoying (sorry JD).

[John Doe]

From what I understand, Kaden used his Sheriff power on Raf asap, because there was no guarantee that siblings could be mafia or town.

[Tyr]

Okay, so I'm guessing Kaden proved himself to be sheriff after one round of play by just investigating him and calling his role. It still pretty much meant there was 2x the second Rose died.

[Rafael]

Never got to use my power lol, what're the odds?

Didn't even consider picking up the gunsmith thing, seemed useless. I was backup incase doc or sheriff died, basically

[Tyr]

Fair enough, I missed your post, as I'm just lazy and use new posts and don't read entire thread. : o