Sig Tournament II: Retane vs Selipa

[Alura]

VS



Subject: Bardock

Theme: Speed

Requirements: Short description of sig and how it ties into your theme. Any text you want (text not required)

Submission: PM or IM the sig to me(Burter). It must be uploaded to your own reliable server first.

Voting: Public vote to five[/img]

[Alura]

I just used the first Cell Jr sig I could find. I know you didn't make it

[Hellfighter 17]

Originally posted by Burter
PM or IM the sig to me(Burter). It must be uploaded to your own reliable server first.

Your supposed to PM or IM it to Burtah.

[Alura]

Subject: Bardock

Theme: Speed



Selipa

Trying to develop a signature towards a curtain theme I found somewhat difficult and a little limiting however I gave it a great amount of time so let?s begin the contest.

In the depiction of bardock is it clear to see him in flight, speeding along from the imposing explosion that is hindered behind him, as shown in the multiple streaks of light that are heading in all directions. The lights showing movement, along with the background lining from one side to the other showing speed. The signature in effect is very sturdy with a sense of continuous motion.



Retane

"I tried to choose a picture that resembles Bardock moving and I think I succeeded in it. The background is not tied to the theme I just tried to make it pwetty. The quote is self explanitory. "


Vote now, you must include reasons. First to 5 wins.

Keep track like this:

Selipa- 0
Retane- 0

[Hellfighter 17]

Selipa - 1
Retane - 0

Retane's is lacking too much colour. =o

[Abel]

This one is hard. Selipa shows speed better but Retane's is pretty. I'll tell my vote later.

[Kaden]

Selipa - 3

Retane - 1

I vote for Selipa. I thought she did a significantly better job of expressing the theme.

[Sage]

Selipa - 3

Retane - 2

Retane's sig is fantastic. It doesn't convey the theme quite as good as Selipa's, but, no offense meant, Retane's is of a greatly higher quality.

In fact, I haven't seen a new sig as good as this one in a long time.

[Jonathan Meer]

While I agree with Bra, in that Retane's sig is absolutely kickass, I must vote for Selipa, mainly because I can't find a single ounce of "speediness" anywhere in Retane's sig. Sorry man, you win big time on awesomeness, but for the competition, it's gotta go to Selipa.

Selipa - 4

Retane - 2

[Jonathan Meer]

Originally posted by Toma
Retane-3

I know what scene he used that Photo from and its perfect for the speed depiction of bardock.

And that would be all fine and dandy if the spirit of the scene was somehow encapsulated in the sig. But it's not.

[Alura]

Right now it's 4-3 Selipa winning

[Dr. Cringle]

Originally posted by Spice
Retane-4
Selipa-4

I choose Retane because Selipas really hurts my eyes.

Hmm, I have to go with........
Retane. Even though he didnt go exactly with the tehem, he sure beet it with quality.

[Alura]

WINNER

5 TO 4

[Old Selipa]

Wow, I was totally was surprised at the sum of votes I got by the crapy signature i made, thanks guys. Retane?s signature is just truly amazing, dead sexy. Congratulation on the winning.