Bujin's GFX Tournament: Round 1 Discussion

[Burter Jr]

Should the sig only include one person?

[Kaden]

Stickied for Bujin's convinience.

[Kaden]

Originally posted by Raditzu
Does the subtext on Silver's read "split second wildfire"?

Originally posted by Bujin

Originally posted by Bujin
Also, all C&C should go to the discussion thread.

*cough*

And yes it does.

[Burter Jr]

What's the point of PMing you if you're just gonna post it?

[Hellfighter 17]

Originally posted by Hellfighter 17
I loved MB's; the text was awesome and it all flowed very well. It is simplistic, but put together rather well.

As for Silver's, poor font choice. Making the flaming grass the foreground doesn't seem too good, mainly because the green clashes with it all; it might still do so if it were in the background, though. Nice choice of superhero, though, and I bet Rad would agree.

Originally edited by Hellfighter 17
EDIT by HF: =(

[Aero]

I'd personally would like to keep mine secret. Why? I dunno, just make me feel better. The only people that have seen it (besides myself) are Torbie and Bujin (When he looks at the PM)

[Jinpo]

mine's in!

Hope people like it.

[Burter Jr]

Who all is competing?

[Aero]

Burter Jr is going to win. Ass-Rape Man is the best hero EVER

[Piccolo Daimoun]

@ BJ:

If you drew Assrape man yourself, then that's pretty good. The text is nice, and the theme is pretty good. The one suggestion I could give is, although it's probably a bitch, to try and give the guys ass rape man...'helped'...Faces. I doubt they'd be as smiley as Assrape man.

Although, the mountain and him standing on it is pretty sweet. I like the sig, and I think it would look a bit better if you could somehow get clouds in there, though, or something.

Good job though dude.

[Burter Jr]

I actually worked on clouds, and it looked lame to me. Couldn't get it how I wanted. I ended up with that background as a result of just randomly clicking away.

Yea, I drew AR myself. I agree I probably should have spent more time on the, uh, "innocent civilans." I didn't think it was that important, but looking back it could have added to it.

[Alexander Trafford]

Yaj is the best.

[Jinpo]

I'd say that the top three were:
Gokua
Yaj
and myself

in no particular order.

Also, HF 17, Tooro's was not that bad. If he hadn't brushed over the render/lowered the opacity, it would have been better, but it wasn't in the bottom three IMO.

[Alexander Trafford]

Gokua's had that kind of 'too good so it ended up looking like shit' thing going on.

[Burter Jr]

Yep. Here we go. Clearly I'm going to have to hold a tournament for those who simply can't do art, but still want to try in order to have fun.

I think while my signature lacked artistic skills, it was a lot prettier then a few who quite simply sucked hard. Just because I don't have flashy graphics doesn't mean it was horrible. You guys are grading things on too high of a scale. "Who has the flashiest sig?"

That said, Cargo's was the best in my books.

[Hellfighter 17]

Cargo and BJ; I have an opinion, and I didn't like them. O.o Don't try to go on a justice trip there, Burter.

[Burter Jr]

Your opinion is based on the idea that whoever has the flashiest graphics is better. You made it clear in your comments to everyone. I don't think that is what the tournament is about, but whatever.

I knew when I posted it that you would hate it, because you always try to have a different opinion then certain people. And I knew you would be unable to agree with me, because you are too stubborn to.

[Hellfighter 17]

The things that I said I like, I said so because I like them. You se ethe sig I am currently using? It's a paint sig. I use it because I like it. It's not 'flashy,' at leats not to me, yet I like it.

I do? What I try to abid b y is the law and my morals, and if I am doing so, I use my opinion. And unable to agree with you? It's an opinion. You put everything you had to say out there, as far as I am concerned, with the sig itself, unless you made another one you would have liked ot switch it with before time was up.

[Aero]

Wow, I didn't expect such a good round.


Cargo's sig was very good.
Yaj's was fantastic as well, but I expect something like that from him.
Majin Buu's was refreshing.
Torbie's was unique, but I think he should have put more time into it.
BJ's was hillarious, but didn't take much thought.
PD's was decent, but didnt match much.
Tooro's BG was superb, but it lacked in some departments.
I like Bujin's whole scheme overall.

[Burter Jr]

Hey, that sig took a lot more effort then you think >=(