+- CDBZ Archive (http://alex.zulenka.com)
+-- Forum: Forum Games (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=274)
+--- Forum: Chubbs Mafia (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=27)
+--- Thread: Pokemalfia Day 3 (/showthread.php?tid=17689)
Pages:
1
2
Pokemalfia Day 3 - Ashe - 06-08-2012
Also, kayne keeps posting in a completely white font. I only noticed it by checking the forum on my phone, but change to default theme and you'll see what I mean. Took me a bit to be sure it wasn't just my phone doing it.
Pokemalfia Day 3 - King B - 06-08-2012
I had no idea the color only came out in default theme. She has been posting in white font this whole time, gets pretty annoying. I do have suspicions of John Doe and Kaden mainly because of the way they behave in previous games and now. Shits getting confusin, but that's mafia for ya, you never can tell. :/
Pokemalfia Day 3 - Super Buu - 06-08-2012
I'm still absolutely in disagreement with the 'wait and gather evidence' lynching as an effective strategy for mafia, and we can see that in previous games it's resulted overwhelmingly in lost games for the town. However, from last game I know that it's not Kaden using that as a bluff, so I'm not sure. This is why I kept my vote on King B for last round, because any lynch regardless of outcomes brings actual concrete information that's not just 'suspicion', which is just that (unless you happened to be right, in which case you were RIGHT ALL ALONG!)
Pokemalfia Day 3 - Super Buu - 06-08-2012
Having caught up on some of the posts, yeah, I'm Scyther. THANKS FOR REVEALING THAT BY THE WAY. And yeah, it's ... a bizarre choice given the ability, as I said to Ashe. It's called 'Feint', because like Scyther is a swordsman I guess? And swordsman are good at like, secret talking. By feinting. With their swords. Like I say ... I'm not Mal, I didn't come up with this shit =P
I don't honestly care too much about it being revealed, because I'm pretty much one of the most useless characters here, like Ashe said we haven't even used it since Day 1 since he's not an investigative role (which I gambled on and hoped for when I picked him).
Pokemalfia Day 3 - Kayne - 06-09-2012
[COLOR="White"]
Ashe Wrote:Also, kayne keeps posting in a completely white font. I only noticed it by checking the forum on my phone, but change to default theme and you'll see what I mean. Took me a bit to be sure it wasn't just my phone doing it.
I'm not going to beat around the bush here, but yeah, it's intentional.
You remember that one episode of Family Guy where the Griffins get super powers, and everybody gets cool powers except for Meg? I'm Meg. :|
I post like this because I have to
[/COLOR]
Pokemalfia Day 3 - Kayne - 06-09-2012
[COLOR="White"]
I've thought about it, and I want to side with either Kaden or Ashe. What they said makes sense, and since both of those choices are part of who I suspect, I'll go with who I feel is more suspicious. I am going to LYNCH JOHN DOE. He could be an investigator type, or he could be mafia, who knows? Something tells me one of the two, or even both 17 and Doe could be a suspect.
[/COLOR]
Pokemalfia Day 3 - Android 17 - 06-09-2012
Seems likely this game'll wind up much like the last, where the mafia get to cruise to victory while the town sinks at a painful, unbearable rate. I can assure those of you who are legitimate townfolk that I'm not mafia, but I appreciate the personal help. Lynch Android 17
I wholly plan to resume my standard strategy of lynching John Doe tomorrow, and everyone should participate.
Pokemalfia Day 3 - Kayne - 06-09-2012
Why not lynch him tonight and help us get a majority vote? Just curious.
Pokemalfia Day 3 - Ashe - 06-09-2012
The town is trying the same tactic as last game - afk their way to a loss.
Seriously, extended day and people are just not bothering to vote or even post. We can't physically get votes for lynches at all because we require every single active person to agree on one target half the time, and those active people include mafia themselves. We don't have any room for disagreement or discussion because quite a few people have no plans to participate.
This is getting old. I want to be nice about it, but if this is the way the rest of this game is going to go, then I don't actually care when the mafia kills me. I've put a lot of information out there and, while some others are at least reading and responding, others are just not, at all. The town's biggest opponent is each other, because it isn't possible to reach majority votes. I've put out reasons for why I have suspicions or thoughts, and some of us aren't even visiting the site to read it and tell me what I have wrong so that we can attempt to actually win this thing.
Let's look at what we have as our likely final, just over an hour before the end of an extended (nearly two day) Day Phase.
It starts off with 2 votes towards Android 17 (someone who appears to have a vote reduction ability), and then due to disagreement flows into 2 other votes against Doe. We then get another vote from 17 for himself. We also have a vote against Kayne in there somewhere.
What does that tell us? It tells us that only 6 people are voting out of the 8 of us. We require a 5 vote majority, and some of us have vote reduction abilities. I would wager that at least 2 of those voting today are mafia.
We even tried to lynch inactives, but couldn't get enough active votes to try THAT tactic. So even if I changed my vote, we still won't reach a majority vote. Even if I use my power, which is the ability to add +1 to whatever vote I make, we still won't reach a majority vote, because all the voting powers in the world will not make up for non-participants/non-votes.
Today we are going to go another day of no lynch, for the second game in a row of a nearly perfect no lynch set of games, and go into Night Phase. The mafia will execute someone. I would say me, out of sheer paranoia but also just to off those who are actually trying to create some discussion. The other target that I would kill if I were a mafia would be Doe, which is why I am now suspicious of the votes made against him. I find it very convenient that, in a very inactive game, a strong push to vote out one of the most active and probing members. I have no idea if he's mafia or not, but at least he's encouraging people to be active and share information.
Want more information? If I get 3 votes against me, or even one vote with me then voting for myself and using my +1 vote ability to make 3, then I evolve into Ratticate. I then would basically have the ability to kill one person Vigilante style. I don't like that ability because it can harm the town as much as help, and I also know that acknowledging having it means you are an immediate lynch target. Here's what I'm doing if for some reason I'm not killed by the mafia and then for some other reason I evolve - I'm killing an inactive. Maybe I'll get lucky and catch a mafia, maybe I will just hit a completely detrimental townsperson, but I can't actually hurt the town other than removing a slight bit of padding.
Tonight we lose someone, anyone, and we go down to 7 players. We'll need a 4 vote majority to consider a possible lynch, COUNTING any vote reduction abilities out there. All of the mafia members, whether it be 2, 3, or fucking all 7 of the rest of you, are still alive.
Don't throw this game too, guys. Its getting really frustrating. If my post seems overly heated, then I apologize for coming off that way but I've done everything I can to try to stimulate this comatose town body into doing something more than signing up for a spot in the game and then going on vacation. I can't offer anything else.
Regarding my current suspect list, honestly, I've re-read some posts, looked at timing, and reconsidered some options.
1. Kayne is either being consistent with her actions last game, or she's intentionally trying to create an air of town agreement leading to split votes.
2. Kaden is on my list now. Kayne's actions make me suspicious as is, and Kaden (and myself) began to follow her lead when she suggested (a good suggestion) to eliminate inactives. Following that, he then began giving short posts about the need to vote against Doe, more or less just using vague arguments of why the second most active and probing person in the game should be removed, and Kayne immediately agrees and votes with him, helping derail a vote that's in place while knowing we need a strict majority. He isn't probing and asking nearly as many questions as I feel he usually does and is coming off more as just riding out a victory. This suspicion is going to be called a weak claim, but I disagree with that.
3. Android 17 / or Rose. At the moment, I can't decide between them. I lean to Rose, for some reason, but he's not being active enough to give me anything to go on, which makes me wonder if there's an in game reason for that. He's posting, just not posting votes. Whereas 17 doesn't line up as well with my thoughts of Kaden + Kayne all that well.
That said, I feel like the active town last game, when they reached the point where the mafia weren't even trying to be subtle or inconspicuous and still controlled the game entirely.
Pokemalfia Day 3 - Ashe - 06-09-2012
I still don't even know if I can remove King Bunny from that list either.
Fuck it.
Unlynch.
Vote Ashe
Pokemalfia Day 3 - Mal Nova - 06-09-2012
Shit was happening. Pokemon were becoming frantic. The mafians were still a mystery...
It had become crazy... Pokemon were even beating on themselves... Literally,,,
A 'woosh' happened...
A WILD ...ASHE HAS APPEARED!!! (Hehe get it?)
1. Doe
2. Kaden
3. Maruset(T)(Farfetche'd)
4. 17
5. Ashe
6. Rose
7. Kayne
8. Blue(T)(Lickitung)
9. Vad
10. King B
Players remaining: 8
Majority vote: 5
Votes after Modifiers
17( 17, Doe): 0
Kayne( King B): 1
Doe( Kaden, Kayne):2
Ashe(Ashe): 2
Only 6 of the 8 people voted.
No one was lynched.
Sleep tight Kiddos. Night Phase begins now... Day 4 begins at 8AM EST tomorrow.
Pokemalfia Day 3 - Mal Nova - 06-09-2012
Editted the Vote Count thing... overlooked Does vote..... it was so... inconspicuous... though it mattered little lol