| The following warnings occurred: | |||||||||||||||
Warning [2] Undefined property: MyLanguage::$archive_pages - Line: 2 - File: printthread.php(287) : eval()'d code PHP 8.5.13 (Linux)
|
![]() |
|
Body Split = Multiplier? - Printable Version +- CDBZ Archive (http://alex.zulenka.com) +-- Forum: Administrative Forums (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=7) +--- Forum: Questions and Suggestions (http://alex.zulenka.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=124) +--- Thread: Body Split = Multiplier? (/showthread.php?tid=10066) |
Body Split = Multiplier? - Belle Hibiki - 12-28-2006 Quote:Originally posted by Raditzu Not useless. It'd be a flavor ability. Just like all the other trainable techniques (not transformations) are largely flavor abilities. Seems perfectly fair and fine to me. Body Split = Multiplier? - Vegeta - 12-28-2006 It would be a combat ability that reduces your combat effectiviness. Body Split = Multiplier? - Belle Hibiki - 12-28-2006 It would be a combat ability that would do much of what SB has already stated IN ADDITION to just splitting your powerlevel. There are certain things that 2+ people can do that 1 person cannot do alone. Body Split = Multiplier? - Vegeta - 12-28-2006 Yes, but 2 weaker fighters are not as effective as 1 stronger figher. Body Split = Multiplier? - Drake - 12-28-2006 The problem is that people seem to think it works like Beam A + Beam B = Beam AB, but the truth is it's more like Beam A + Beam B = Beam C. Powers overlap, not multiply sort of like this picture below.
Body Split = Multiplier? - Jonathan Meer - 12-28-2006 Recap: SB's suggested power level system is that a person with 1000 Ki is 1/5th as powerful, and thus, 1/5th as effective against a fighter as someone with 5000 Ki. However, this neither follows the DBZ show itself, nor the current Chubbs system. The current system (as described by Rad) is exponential, in that four warriors at 50,000 would be slaughtered by a single warrior at 200,000. This is validated by the DBZ show, and has worked as the Chubbs system for a number of years. SB, you say that it seems dumb that someone could do "blah blah blah" with Body Split when, in reality, you've found a border in our exponential system. It might seem stupid to you, but that's how the system works. At Chubbs, we are conscientious of keeping the newbies actively involved in sagas and such, but we twenty of them won't be able to even scratch Raditzu. That's just not how it works. Body Split = Multiplier? - Super Buu - 12-28-2006 I'm currently waiting on a response from Rad in the other topic. In the meantime, Krillin, try not to demonise my responses. Plenty others can see the logic, so if you're going to give a neutral 'recap', don't give it from a biased standpoint. In the meantime (and whilst I wait/sleep), I'll remind you all of the first post of this thread. Quote:Originally posted by Super Buu I know that the kneejerk thing is to try and defend your decisions - or what you percieve as your 'side'. I'm not accusing you of that, Krill, but there have been one or two people leaping in without reading the thread. This is supposed to be about coming to a rational conclusion, not 'winning'. Taking a break. Will continue tomorrow.
Body Split = Multiplier? - Jonathan Meer - 12-28-2006 If you knew me well, Greg, you'd never even think of suggesting I have a closed mind. Body Split = Multiplier? - Super Buu - 12-28-2006 I didn't say that. In fact, I specifically said you weren't who I was talking about. I said that (read the start of my post because I can't be assed to repeat myself). Body Split = Multiplier? - Jonathan Meer - 12-28-2006 Regardless, I know full well that this is not about winning. What would I have to gain for supporting a system that I did not make myself, and take no benefit from, being one who trains my mentals? Wouldn't it be more impressive for me, as a Staff member, to show my "think-for-myself"-ness, and go against the grain? Wouldn't that establish myself as a creative individual to the higher-ups, who would then bestow all kinds of cool toys on my penis? I know what a debate is for and about. I'm not skimping your logic here any. But I would be willing to argue this point for an age. At least, until I'm confronted by some actual, conclusive reasoning. So far, I haven't seen it. Body Split = Multiplier? - Super Buu - 12-28-2006 Quote:Originally posted by Super BuuThat's what I was talking about. The rest was a general reminder. Body Split = Multiplier? - Sage - 12-28-2006 We've come to a rational conclusion, though. I mean, you're a great guy, SB, but you're wrong. Body Split -SUCKED- the way you're trying to make it. Nobody wanted it. Nobody even bothered getting it. =\ Body Split = Multiplier? - Super Buu - 12-28-2006 'Kay, seems like staff are ready to return to this argument, so, after a short hiatus (now with the information I needed from the other thread), let's continue. *Shuffles papers* I'm sure we're all familiar with the term Pebble Logic by now. In other words, a force combined is greater than the same amount of force separated up into chunks. The current system of Body Split seeks to compensate for that by making clones stronger. However, there is one thing that was made clear for me in the other thread, and that is that Body Split is intended to be a powerup. Even with Pebble Logic factored in, the clones should still be able to beat an opponent stronger than their own, original, un-split form. This is according to Waffuru, and backed up by Raditzu's claims that my numbers were off. I don't understand this. Firstly, Body Split is a common technique, not a powerup. It can be achieved very easily when compared to other techniques, and especially other multipliers. Secondly, I think people are failing to factor in the non-numerical advantages of the split. It can be assumed that each body acts independently, and can react to dangers without a mental cue the 'real' split-ee. This gives a massive advantage in itself. There is also the fact that attacks can come from multiple directions instead of just one. It's a lot easier to dodge one kamehameha than it is to dodge four. If you need to complete two tasks at once (disarming a bomb whilst protecting the president from Changelings) you can also do that. Why, then, does Body Split need an additional advantage in the form of being a multiplier? As I said before, it's classed as a 'decent' technique - on the lowest level, from what I can tell. Its strength, like most techniques, comes from battle versatility - it opens more options for strategy, and just plain lets you do more things. Body Split isn't 'useless' because of this. If you're going to call Body Split useless, you may as well throw every non-powerup technique besides Fusion in there as well. Metal Binding offers no statistical advantaged. Neither do the kinesises, shapechange, telepathy, or any of the others. What do they offer? Versatility. I don't see why Body Split, a common technique that already offers a number of cool advantages, should be any exception. Body Split = Multiplier? - Kaden - 12-28-2006 Quote:Originally posted by Super Buu None of the other techniques weaken your character for using them. We're not forgetting the non-statistical advantages at all, but those can't be factored into a discussion like this because the application of such advantages depends almost entirely on the writing abilities of the one using it. As such, the level of advantage it provides differs from one individual to the next. Either I misspoke, or I was misunderstood. Body Split isn't a "power up" per se and it shouldn't be talked about as such. The technique was altered so that the individual clones would not be useless against an opponent. If you're fighting someone and you both have 1000 speed and you use Body Split to split into two, you're now two characters of with 500 speed. The faster character would simply be out of the league of the others. Remember that ki is always based on physical stats. Any time a technique talks about modifying ki, you have to understand that it does that by modifying a character's statistics. SSJ doesn't actually multiply your ki at all, it multiplies your stats. For the purposes of the end result, however, its the same as saying it multiplies your ki. The case is the same for Body Split. Your ki is modified because the technique is modifying your stats. Body Split = Multiplier? - Yamu - 12-28-2006 I understand SB's problem in that Body Split becomes a de-facto powerup. I honestly think the gains made by Body Splitting will never be a deciding factor in any battle. If a judge ever looks at a fight and goes...'Well John Q Split so that would mean..." what do I mean 'if', it will never happen. The new rule allows for IN YOUR WRITING the clones to be able to fight at the same level of effectivness as the singlar unit only now they are seperate entities. I think the discussion has gone so many different way no one knows why the other is upset. The change in rules, I believe, is only meant to facillitate writing with Body Split and making in an attractive technique instead of one that literally harms you instead of helping. The problem here is not with math or pebbles or whatever. Don't take the multiples literally they are but a balance to ensure a diverse level of RPing. Body Split = Multiplier? - Super Buu - 12-28-2006 That idea came from Waffuru: Quote:Body Split is a powerup, so the split fighters are NOT equal to the original. That's where your math is wrong. If that's wrong, I'm assuming Body Split is supposed to be an accurate representation of your battle effectiveness. By that I mean four of your split selves fight, together, at roughly the same level as your whole self, right? From this, I can derive that, on Chubbs, a fighter is equal to two fighters 80% of his own power. Or three fighters 70% of his own power. Etc. If that's correct (IF, don't kill me if I'm wrong >_>), then my problem is more with the extremity of Pebble Logic on Chubbs than Body Split itself. Like I said on the other thread, one complete Rad being worth three complete Reijins seems a little ... much. Body Split = Multiplier? - Kaden - 12-28-2006 Quote:Originally posted by Super Buu Wrong. Body Split = Multiplier? - Super Buu - 12-29-2006 So it is effectively a powerup? Body Split = Multiplier? - Kaden - 12-29-2006 No. Body Split = Multiplier? - Super Buu - 12-29-2006 So they're weaker? If not, some kind of explanation would help me out here. |